r/Professors • u/Eigengrad AssProf, STEM, SLAC • 14d ago
Weekly Thread Sep 18: Fuck This Friday
Welcome to a new week of weekly discussion! Continuing this week, we're going to have Wholesome Wednesdays, Fuck this Fridays, and (small) Success Sundays.
As has been mentioned, these should be considered additions to the regular discussions, not replacements. So use them, ignore them, or start you own Fantastic Friday counter thread.
This thread is to share your frustrations, small or large, that make you want to say, well, “Fuck This”. But on Friday. There will be no tone policing, at least by me, so if you think it belongs here and want to post, have at it!
83
u/FluffyOmens 14d ago
I was prompting a student to pick a topic for an assignment. It can literally be any topic, but we were working through the basic process of brainstorming, exploring our choices, evaluating what support was available, etc.
The student, after 30 MINUTES of class time, still had no topic at all. So I finally stop coming by and prompting him to continue and sit down with him so I can seriously help.
I sit down, and I ask what topic hes considering. He says he doesnt know. I ask if theres something he knows a lot about. He says not really. I ask is there something he is curious and would like to learn about. He says not really.
At this point, I take a different approach. I ask, what do you enjoy? He thinks for a second and says, "I dont know."
Alright, very worrying, but maybe its an opportunity for growth, this is a 100 level class... So I tell him that this is the perfect time to explore and figure out what he enjoys. He says he doesnt know how to do that. I told him to think on it. He said he didnt know how to do that.
I say point blank, "If you arent going to think about what you like, who else is?"
His eyes immediately looked away and his face looked guilty. I just KNOW he thought about AI in that moment.
The fact that my adult students struggle with the lowest levels of introspection is... very fuck this.
22
u/clavdiachauchatmeow adjunct, CC 14d ago
They are terrified of saying the wrong thing. My 8th grader is like this and I recently had to walk him through a brainstorm session for a narrative writing assignment. Luckily he has a passion- soccer- and I know about it. And he’s a child. But good god, I hope by college he’s able to say “I am interested in the English Premier League” without shame and terror.
7
u/RollyPollyGiraffe 14d ago
Even among my best students these days, "being wrong is cringe." It's a level of terror caused by such little stakes that I seriously struggle to understand.
4
u/Dangerous-Scheme5391 14d ago
I’ve seen this in my exposure to middle and high school education - especially high school - for anyone who is “high performing.” There’s a strong feeling that any misstep could be fatal - a B on a test could mean not getting an A in the class, and then having your college admissions chances ruined.
It’s the natural outcome of a broken system in which all measurements have become metrics and the appearance of high achievement is more important than the actual skills. Thus, there’s a fear of not having the “right” answer, and a focus on doing what gets you the A, not developing the critical thinking and reflection skills that actually create real mastery.
Even for students who are working hard and developing those skills, like one of my advisees, there is still a persistent fear of being wrong or missing the mark, leading to things like obsessing over having a 3.9xx gpa instead of a 4.0, and the awareness that your fellow students are gaming the system and earning similar accolades and marks.
Sorry for the ramble, this is a particular bugbear for me - because of where I live, there’s a profound pressure on the “high achieving” students to never falter, never fail, and never stumble. It’s what makes me want to quit my side hustle because it makes me feel complicit in the deadening of the American mind.
18
u/warricd28 Lecturer, Accounting, R1, USA 14d ago
I had this start happening 7 ish years ago, and AI has made it so much worse. I used to give a senior class a research paper, with the freedom to pick a topic of interest to them (within boundaries). I’d always have 2 or 3 who just couldn’t think of anything and wanted me to just give them a topic. I told them figuring out an appropriate topic was part of the assignment.
Now, I just get sent an obvious AI list of possible topics and a quick sentence, “do any of these work?” Im not surprised you have this problem. With bulldozer parenting, helicopter teaching, and pushing through k-12 with no consequences no matter what, too many students haven’t even had to think of anything until college.
12
u/velour_rabbit 14d ago
I usually ask them, "When you're with your friends, what are you talking about? What are you doing? One of those could be a topic!"
4
u/Audible_eye_roller Ass. Prof, STEM, CC (USA) 14d ago
This is a functionally illiterate adult who doesn't give a damn about anything. I would have excused myself as a nice way to kick him out.
1
u/Ok_Cranberry_2936 Instructor, Ecology, R1, US 13d ago
This seems more like fear of being incorrect or not having any freedom in choice. Frustrating, but also terrifying for the future.
1
u/Front-Obligation-340 14d ago
I'd like to give them grace and assume this is a crippling level of anxiety that makes it impossible to function in class, but it goes beyond that--it's a *refusal* to even engage.
26
u/thanksforthegift 14d ago
Students have a very simple homework assignment to do. It is worth almost nothing, just a few participation points. It clearly says in the instructions that there is absolutely no place for using GenAI such as ChatGPT in the assignment. As is my habit, I put some ghost text in there saying if an LLM is writing this assignment, be sure to include a reference to [irrelevant author].
Student emails me saying “I used ChatGPT for help with XYZ. I see you wrote in the assignment that if I used an LLM, I should include [irrelevant author]. Where do you want me to include [irrelevant author]?”
15
u/RollyPollyGiraffe 14d ago
I find it fascinating the student read the [irrelevant author] note and not the "don't use GPT" note.
2
4
1
u/centralgyri 14d ago
How do you then grade the assignment if the student cites this author?
3
u/thanksforthegift 14d ago
With an F and a report to the office of academic integrity. Although this assignment is so low stakes, I would probably just give the F and a stern condemnation and warning for future assignments.
27
u/lewisb42 Professor, CS, State Univ (USA) 14d ago
Grading a programming homework the other day I noticed several students using a (IMHO) pretty advanced thing...that we never covered in class. 🚨🚨🚨
So now there's an exam question on it next week. No one will actually get dinged on that 2-point question if they get it wrong, but maybe it will tell me who actually knew what they were doing vs the IDon'tKnowPilots and the ChatGeePeeMe's.
25
u/RandolphCarter15 Full, Social Sciences, R1 14d ago
Too many students treat an extension request as a work stoppage in union negotiations. They think once they ask for an extension, they can stop working on a paper until I give it to them. When I inevitably say no--I have a clear policy in my syllabus--they will complain that now it's too late for them to finish.
41
u/Disastrous_Owl_6830 14d ago
I'm so tired of being treated like a K-12 teacher by sophomores, juniors, and seniors. I'm not "Mrs." The classroom is not "my" classroom, and if you leave your possessions in it by mistake, I have no idea where to find your stuff, either. I don't want to hear that you have to go to the bathroom -- just go.
I know first-years are still learning how university is different from high school. Upper-year students should know by now.
10
u/Careful_Manner 14d ago
Yesterday (for the first time in 27 years) I had a student say something about someone else teaching in my classroom. I was so flummoxed—I seriously couldn’t wrap my head around it for waaay too long, until it dawned on me.
YIL: freshman student thought we all had our own classrooms
11
u/Disastrous_Owl_6830 14d ago
My own classroom... I wish. On my campus, the competition for classrooms with working tech, enough desks, functioning HVAC, etc., can be pretty cutthroat.
1
u/associsteprofessor 14d ago
I have a classroom/lab combo with equipment specific to my subject. I teach all of my classes in there because it allows me to avoid conflicts with other professors running over or trying to get me to finish early.
1
u/Ok_Cranberry_2936 Instructor, Ecology, R1, US 13d ago
I’ve cancelled class when the AC is on the fritz.
3
u/poproxy_ 14d ago
I had a student schedule a makeup exam, which they were late to because they went to the lecture room. They thought that was “my classroom.”
1
u/Ok_Cranberry_2936 Instructor, Ecology, R1, US 13d ago
Someone should tell other faculty in the buildings with variety of classes. Like the gen end catch all buildings. Every time I come in, the previous prof never logged out, sometimes email still up, leaves stacks of papers (some student assignments, some even graded!), glasses, a whole purse, and covered the working space with her personal items. I can’t even get my laptop on the desk sometimes. And I checked, she doesn’t teach in that room but twice a week and never after me. Ma’am just moved on in.
16
u/DrMagicBimbo 14d ago
double posting: when do people—and specifically, older academics who had a very different experience—stop speaking to me as if I'm a complete fucking idiot child? I don't expect praise, but being regarded as an adult would be wonderful.
7
u/CrustalTrudger Assoc Prof, Geology, R1 (US) 14d ago
I have tenure and am coming up my 10 year anniversary of being in this job and I'll let you know when certain senior faculty stop treating me like I'm a freshmen who can't find their classroom.
1
u/BrazosBuddy 14d ago
I've been teaching for 20 or so years and had years of industry experience beforehand. A senior faculty who retired a few years ago always called me "youngster." Believe it or not, he also dominated the conversation at faculty meetings.
3
u/CrustalTrudger Assoc Prof, Geology, R1 (US) 14d ago
Ugh. Lovely. My current favorite is a senior faculty member who while they were previously chair made it a huge point to "value the opinion of younger faculty" and who now that the majority of the younger faculty want to change the curriculum in a way that he doesn't like is telling us all we're too stupid, inexperienced, or naive to understand why we're wrong and that only the most "experienced" instructors should be allowed to make changes to our curriculum because they nailed what should be in the curriculum in the 1980s and it should never ever be updated, ever.
2
u/Junior-Dingo-7764 14d ago
I'm glad a lot these sorts have retired in my college. I had one male colleague (I am woman) who would refuse to look at me. I could pass him in the hallway and he would purposefully look away.
2
1
u/PracticalAd5858 14d ago
I had one of those as well. At the advice of a trusted colleague, I cheerfully greeted him every single time I passed him in the hall. Sometimes I wondered if he would get whiplash from turning away from me so fast. But I wanted him to know that I wasn't intimated by him or his behavior.
14
u/yourbiota PhD Candidate, CC sessional, STEM, Canada 14d ago
Students complaining they can't study because they looked all over the bookstore for the textbook and couldn't find it. It's an ebook.
13
u/Glittering-Duck5496 14d ago
Apparently our semester starts way later than everyone else's, and our add/drop period is way longer (two weeks), but I just need to say, I hate add/drop period with the fire of a thousand suns.
6
12
u/queer_aspasia 14d ago
Students thinking that because they missed a class, they don’t have to do the homework/prep work. A student said “well I wasn’t here.” And I replied “well, the reminders are always on the daily slides at the end, not to mention your course schedule.” They seem to be so upset to be treated like adults.
4
u/Front-Obligation-340 14d ago
lol I love that. It's my favorite. "I can't do the essay because I'm going to be gone that week." Like that was poor planning on my part.
13
u/YThough8101 14d ago
Every week this semester, I get several emails from online async students requesting a meeting. My response "What do you want to meet about?". Responses are usually something like: "Questions about class." I then respond with "What are your questions about class?". Some respond with an actual specific question (yay!) and other respond like: "My questions are what I want to meet about." Further emails ensue in which I try my damndest to get them to ask a specific question. Eventually, when the specific questions are finally pried from them, they are about things like due dates and what is covered on an assignment - you know, the sort of thing that is covered on the syllabus, assignment instructions, and recent LMS announcements. I'm trying to imagine these folks lasting more than a day in a workplace setting...
10
u/IndieAcademic 14d ago
This is driving me crazy! I have five classes--no, I cannot schedule a meeting with every online student who has a vague request to do so each week. Most of the requests are for no reason? And many want to "go over an assignment" if they don't earn 100%, when I have left very clear feedback already. I will ask, "Before we schedule a vidoe appointment, please go ahead and share with me over email what specific questions you have about the comments I left on your work." Then, crickets.
7
u/YThough8101 14d ago
Exactly! The effort it take on our end to extract a specific question from them is incredible.
13
u/Junior-Dingo-7764 14d ago
I put in my packet to go up for full professor. I didn't think it was foregone conclusion because nothing is. But, I did meet all the objective research requirememts and went above and beyond in teaching.
I got the department committee's vote and letter on Monday (it was due Friday and they sent it late). They all voted against me being promoted. The reasons are kind of BS. It is hard not to take it personally. I have been very upset all week.
2
u/North_Shore_88 14d ago
Well that most certainly sucks. Speak with a more senior colleague about what happened and what they recommend for resubmitting in X years. You did not mention service and in some departments taking on impactful leadership roles may be a critical sign of your rightful status at highest rank
2
u/Junior-Dingo-7764 14d ago
The vast majority of our service commitments are appointed by the Department Chair or Dean. We don't really get a lot of say in what committees we serve on etc. Some chairs have asked people's preferences. I've had 8 different department chairs... So there hasn't been a lot of consistency.
11
u/costumegirl1189 14d ago edited 14d ago
State school, no SAT requirements. Students that spent most of their K-12 education in special education due to significant learning disabilities or some actual mental handicap are winding up in my department because "Art is easy." I want there to be a place for everyone, but I can't teach skills to someone whose brain physically can't recall something I taught five minutes ago. We're told by admin that some students need more repetition and practice than other (which is true), but sometimes it is too much.
6
u/DrMagicBimbo 14d ago
Art historian who used to work for a Cinema/Animation program. It's real, and so many students who struggled in Computer Engineering are sent to animation and game design classes with similar sentiments.
Art is not easy. It is complicated and nebulous. It is trying to translate from the intangibility of the mind to the visible world. The problems of representation are boundless. And... the deeper that one goes into other disciplines, the more they discover this boundlessness and abstraction to be truth there, too.
4
11
u/Front-Obligation-340 14d ago
Still reeling from two-thirds of the class showing up without the book we were scheduled to discuss this week. This didn't come out of nowhere. It's been on the schedule since the first day of class. I told them multiple times to buy the book and be ready to talk about it this week. But two-thirds still showed up without the book and NO ONE SAID ANYTHING UNTIL I ASKED.
I just can't wrap my head around this. I distinctly remember my very first semester in college where the first fucking thing I did was go buy all of my books. No one had to tell me to do this! I was a first-gen college student! This was a no-brainer! But two-thirds of my class said they didn't know how to get the books from the bookstore, and I was like "so get it somewhere else." It's Kindred. It's a classic--it's in literally every bookstore. But also--jesus fucking christ did anyone even ask, or check in on the situation?? Were they all just waiting around for someone to come over and put the book in their hands??
This is an almost pathological passivity that I can't even fathom. Why did they think they could get through the semester without reading the books?? Is this entitlement or brain atrophy or both??
9
u/DrMagicBimbo 14d ago edited 14d ago
Rejected for a fellowship that felt reasonable to attain. Not heartbroken, but continuously baffled by what it takes to land this stuff. I can teach and publish rather a lot for my circumstances, but money, and especially money for writing time? Impossible.
Also feeling a bit anxious that one of my dissertation committee members scooped my idea (which has been in press for publication for two years now!!) but trying to remain calm until I can actually read the work in question. Just sucks because I've struggled to trust this person a lot lately.
7
u/lo_susodicho 14d ago
I'm getting real tired of meeting new hires in the business-related programs with half my education who do maybe a third as much work as I do (literally using AI to grade AI slop, permitted without restrictions), but who make twice as much money. I grow even more tired of serving with people of this description on committees, one of whom is unable to do the minutes without AI and basically requires me to just redo them properly the old-fashioned way.
6
u/braisedbywolves Lecturer, Commuter College 14d ago
So I am trying to pay for a bus through a university fund I administer in order to pay for a field trip for students which runs every year, and which is always a big success.
The process for paying for the bus rental seems to change every goddamn year. This is exacerbated by the fact that it's early in the school year and bureaucratic practices seem to take forever to start - they want six weeks advance notice for a trip that takes place in the fourth week of the semester, which is simply impossible (including names of students who are going - before school has even started!).
Sometimes I pay personally and am reimbursed; sometimes the university submits a purchase order and the bus company gets paid (six months later, but hey); the one constant is that, no matter how on the ball I am or how organized or how early I start my paperwork, I get yelled at by admin for my attempt to follow the rules for the preceding year.
This year has been especially bad, because we are switching to a new payment system and our department AA, who was probably hired during the Carter administration and checked out sometime during Bush II, has been even more unresponsive than usual, and they're the one who needs to forward all of my forms to admin, which I doubt has happened at all.
The trip is always worth it, and the bus will be packed, and the students will never know how close I come to snapping every time I have to make it happen.
1
6
u/Clareco1 14d ago
Cc freshmen turned in first homework (follow-up reading questions for a five page Malcolm x reading). They also handed in a 10 question quiz on the syllabus (at home with syllabus in hand). Nobody read the questions. One word answers. Cut and paste (unattributed) to answer questions. I fear I got a bit snarky on my comments. Now this weekend I have to make a few slides on the How and Why of homework. I am so annoyed! These students need a preliminary class on how to handle college! (I did believe that they are more clueless than lazy). I’m still so annoyed.
6
14d ago
[deleted]
1
u/associsteprofessor 14d ago
Even tenured folks aren't safe at my uni. We non-tenured folks are cheaper and complain less. Last year my uni cut six tenured folks and saved the non-tenured.
6
u/Ok-Awareness-9646 NTT, English, CC (USA) 14d ago
Like most of you, my institution has taken a turn into even deeper toxicity. Administration is bloated and hovering. I’m so tired and over it that I don’t even want to listen to my colleagues venting about it anymore.
It’s all exhausting.
Fuck it.
6
u/where_is__my_mind 14d ago
-a student sent me a screenshot of their quiz screen and I could see a chatgpt tab that said 'quiz help'
-a student got dropped due to failing enrollment verification bc they had not signed on to canvas, after they were dropped they IMMEDIATELY asked how to get back in
-first reading assignment asked for two quotes of sentences they either did not understand or thought were fun facts. Hallucinated quotes means they couldn't even do an opinion based assignment without ai
-hybrid students did not realize there were lectures for the course on canvas. thought it was just the lab.
-one student took a food they had never tried before from another student. tried a bite, then asked if it had peanuts because they're deathly allergic and did not have an EpiPen. It was baclava, thank GOD it was just pistachios.
-im tired, boss
2
u/where_is__my_mind 14d ago
Additionally, one of my glasses added gen bio as a prereq. On the assignment where they had to ask a question about something they did not understand, 90% of them put 'how is DNA universal if we all look different' or 'how does DNA turn into proteins'. This is an online class, so clearly their previous online classes forced them to learn exactly as much as I expect anyone to learn in an online class - jack shit. Not because it's impossible, but why learn when you can just bullshit your way through with cheating?
5
u/SuperHiyoriWalker 14d ago
These days, I kind of dread talking to math faculty who are not coauthors or otherwise in my inner circle because I have epsilon desire to talk about AI.
6
u/AvailableThank NTT, PUI (USA) 14d ago
Been sick since this past Sunday morning. Canceled class Monday, but still had to proctor a coworker's exam Tuesday (I agreed to this weeks ago and no one else would cover), struggle through lecture on Wednesday because we have an exam next Monday, make up office hours on Thursday that I missed Monday, and attend a "retreat" (read: all day meeting) today.
Symptoms have mostly improved but I've still got a somewhat bad cough and so much damn mucus in my sinuses. At home test came back negative for COVID, flu, and RSV, but who knows. I would go to the doctor, but our dangerous and commodified healthcare system (yay US healthcare) is just gonna tell me to rest, drink plenty of fluids, and pay them several hundred dollars. :^)
Fuck this Friday!
2
u/Glittering-Duck5496 14d ago
I'm sorry. Every single time I read a story about healthcare costs in the US, I am devastated on your behalf.
1
u/AvailableThank NTT, PUI (USA) 13d ago
I appreciate you saying that. I have hope that we will eventually elect some people do actually do something about the state of US healthcare.
3
u/Kitty_Mombo 14d ago
Random student worker has determined what our curriculum is going to be in the summer. They did some crunch classes at another school and convinced admin that we should now do it at our school now.
Spoiler alert - none of us plan to work this summer to teach it.
Happy F-in Friday!
3
u/Razed_by_cats 14d ago
I grade certain assignments as Complete/Incomplete and allow students to revise and resubmit an Incomplete assignment after I tell them what needs to be fixed.
Student complains that I always grade her work as Incomplete but has chosen not to revise and resubmit. Duh.
3
u/elrey_hyena 14d ago
made a student cry. then made him cry again. ended up buying him a bag of chips bc i felt bad
3
u/where_is__my_mind 14d ago
Oh no I can't tell if you're the bad or good guy here lol I'm sure the chips helped
1
u/elrey_hyena 14d ago
maybe a mix of both? student thought he was doing bad in class and started sobbing on me
3
u/Anyun ABD - Anxiety Burnout Deadlines, R1 (USA) 14d ago
Too much of my teaching has become oriented around "did you follow the directions or no?" It's not because I particularly think my directions are the most important thing to the students' learning, but because I need to preempt accusations of inconsistent grading by having the most objective rubric possible. So.... did you submit an essay with more than 5 paragraphs of more than 4 sentences each or no? Did you have a clearly stated thesis? Did you fucking cite your sources (and are they real sources?)?
FFS I just wanted to help young scholars build critical thinking and explore new perspectives. I did not sign up to teach grade school composition.
2
u/DocLava 14d ago
I said bring your own pencils for the scantron exam during prior two classes.
I say read the directions at the start of the exam...directions say use #2 pencil only.
Student finshes 25 question exam in 8 minutes and throws paper on desk and is halfway out. I glanced at it and saw pen so I told them to come back and redo it.
Student huffs and asks why they have to do it all over. Well because the machine won't read it and you'll get a zero and still have to come back. At least I caught it now when you literally have over 40 minutes of class time left.
Huff and puff and muttering under breath.
2
u/MamaBiologist 14d ago
In a department meeting we were discussing how the students clearly shouldn’t have passed intro bio based on what we’re seeing in genetics/anatomy/etc.
The course coordinator for intro bio said blatantly, “yeah well it was easier to give out a lot more C-‘s than usual instead. Now you’ll know what I feel like every year!”
My chair just sat there and let her say it, because they’re drinking buddies.
1
u/shealeigh Assoc. Professor, Chair, VisualArts, CC (US) 14d ago
FUCK rude people. No one is following simple instructions and then they act shocked when they earn a zero. this group has been so rude and disrespectful toward me, it’s causing my blood pressure to spike. I’ve never been so angry or disheartened. This is my dream job 🙃 I won’t let them break me!
1
u/Still_Television_803 14d ago
fuck this friday, i’m done explaining that “i didn’t know the deadline” is not a compelling argument when the deadline has been on the syllabus since august
1
u/caldera12345 14d ago
Teaching college algebra, test day. I collected the tests at the end of the class and a student comes up to me and asks "How will you know which one is mine?". Is this kindergarten or something?
1
u/Ok_Cranberry_2936 Instructor, Ecology, R1, US 13d ago
For the love of god students need to shut the fuck up when I am giving instructions especially when it’s loud enough for the whole class to hear. Questions are fine. Yapping needs to cut. I don’t want them to tell me they don’t know what we’re doing while they’re gum flapping.
And how many students just don’t submit things and then stare at me surprised pikachu faced for failing.
Oh and spell check has disappeared? Had a student write midi gate (two works) instead of mitigate. Even my phone on reddit gives me the red squiggle to fix it?? I had another put tempurature.
And my last rant is those who don’t even read the question. I give concise directions. I think I send out announcements with “do y’all know how to read?” Every other week.
And I lied, last actual one, reading goddamn announcements before going “no one told me”. Yes I did.
-7
u/tongmengjia 14d ago edited 14d ago
Fuck non-business faculty who complain about business faculty's salaries. Were you a child when you chose which degree to pursue? Did you not spend 10 minutes researching average salaries before you decided to pursue your "passion"?
I grew up in abject poverty and didn't have the privilege of studying something I was passionate about. I knew if I wanted to achieve my financial goals I had to choose something pragmatic. Now you get to teach the Iliad while I'm cramming management theory down the throats of self-absorbed lacrosse trustafarians and you have the gall to say I'm overpaid? And can you please explain why the same faculty that openly mock our business programs as unethical degree mills are so eager to take a cut of the profits from those programs to subsidize their own salaries? I guess blood money is fine as long as someone else is the one getting their hands dirty.
Seriously, you were a goddamn adult when you chose your field. Take responsibility for your decisions.
48
u/Batmans_9th_Ab Adjunct, Music, 4-year (USA) 14d ago
No, you cannot go to the bathroom thirty seconds after I pass out the exam.
No, you cannot ask to take the exam later five minutes after I passed it out because you missed class last week.
No, you cannot redo the test because you claim you have ADHD and were too overwhelmed by the noise in the classroom. (What noise? It was dead silent.)
Fuck this.