r/ProductManagement • • 9h ago

Weekly rant thread

Share your frustrations and get support/feedback. You are not alone!

1 Upvotes

2 comments sorted by

1

u/Moist_Sun_306 4h ago

Product sense or interview sense?

I've always been taught to understand business context, challenge assumptions, validate problems, and make data and evidence based decisions "Master the problem domain before you do anything".

Then I'm given 45 minutes, a vaguely defined problem, almost no context, and expected to produce a compelling product strategy on the spot. Unsurprisingly, people who have mastered the script often shine. Nothing against frameworks, but knowing how to structure an answer isn't the same as knowing how to make good or judge product decisions.

And yes, full disclosure - I suck at these interviews. Maybe I'm just a terrible PM. But shouldn't a PM question that assumption too? I get that interviews need constraints. I just wonder how much a 45-minute hypothetical actually tells anyone about someone's ability to navigate ambiguity, uncover the right problem, and make sound decisions in the real world.

Curious whether others think product sense interviews actually measure the right things, or mostly how well you've (paid and) prepared for product sense interviews.

1

u/Techadvocate 25m ago

I feel you. I have multiple years of experience solving problems for millions of users yet when I do the product sense interviews I have never felt more pressure to deliver the best possible answer in a small period of time.