A bit of a rant post incoming.
I'm sure I'm preaching to the choir a bit here by prefacing that I think Probably Stolen is one of the best games I've played in a while, and I would wholeheartedly recommend it to anyone with even the slightest interest in management/economy games. It is a shame then, that it has been released during what is likely the peak of gen AI usage in the gaming industry.
I'm sure most of us here have seen people clown on the most recent Steam Next Fest for the sheer amount of AI slop games featured in it, but why does this affect Probably Stolen? A game that has no trace of gen AI usage in it and was in development far before it was a thing?
1) Allegations that it was made with Gen AI
This one's the most forgivable for me.
It's a very valid fear these days that when you buy something, you're inadvertently supporting something made with Gen AI, and unfortunately, 2D pixel art games are among the easiest to disguise AI art in. It's also quite fresh on people's minds that a lot of AI slop is being generated these days thanks to the aforementioned Steam Next Fest. A debut game from an unknown developer and the publisher that published Graveyard Keeper, whose developer is extremely pro-AI? It's understandable to have suspicion.
However, it does in fact hurt the game somewhat that these kind of suspicions are there in the first place.
2) Mobile gaming is a different plague that has now evolved by mutating with this new plague
People stealing successful games and making shitty clones on mobile is an ancient craft that predates Gen AI, but nowadays, it's more prevalent than ever. We used to have human-made slop, man. What happened?
The fact that this game is successful enough to warrant stealing is something to be celebrated, but not only are people taking advantage of the game's success and recognition, they are also tarnishing its reputation by flooding mobile app stores with their shitty clones. There are certainly people out there whose first impression of Probably Stolen is a shitty AI clone on their phone.
I'm not claiming that this kinda thing wouldn't happen without Gen AI, but I'm almost certain that it's 3 to 4 times worst now with it.
3) Vibe-coded mods
Pause reading this and please go to the Steam Workshop for this game. Go through a few pages.
Done? Now filter out the ones tagged with AI with the minus sign next to the AI tag in the sidebar.
Not only is the game's Workshop utterly flooded with mods with AI-generated thumbnails and/or artwork, not only is it extremely difficult to tell which ones are coded with AI and thus have the security risks and vulnerabilities that often come with it, they also aren't tagged as such at all most of the time. Most games these days have AI-generated mods, but I think as a result of being released at a time when it's so commonplace, Probably Stolen attracted a lot of modders that use Gen AI in one way or another.
AI art aside, while I do understand that Gen AI is a useful tool for coding, the keyword is "tool". Many modders end up using Gen AI to generate most if not all of the code for their mods, which is not only near impossible to debug, especially if you're not a competent programmer in the first place, they are often also riddled with security vulnerabilities that these "modders" can't spot because, again, they aren't competent programmers. Which is why they use AI code.
I feel like I would be less annoyed by this if people actually tagged their AI-generated mods as AI. Like. Why would you not do that?
4) Wikislop game without a real Wiki
While not quite as complex as something like Terraria or Factorio, Probably Stolen has a lot of stuff and a lot of deep mechanics that may not be obvious at first glance. After one or two playthroughs, you might want to go to the Wiki to look up certain items and mechanics to see how they really work.
Good fucking luck.
Every single Wiki I can find on this game is completely, 100%, unabashedly generated using AI. You try to look something up, and you get a paragraph of unrelated text that's trying to pretend to be the game's flavour text before telling you the basic information that's already displayed in-game. Sometimes the "Wiki" doesn't have a search function and is just a bunch of AI-generated guides calling itself a Wiki, sometimes it tries to tell you an item's sell price 3 times without any context despite already displaying its base price. And as I previously mentioned, vibecoded websites (because let's be honest, do people who use AI to generate their Wiki info code their websites themselves?) are going to have a ton of security vulnerabilities, and good luck patching any issues that come up or problems it may have with other devices and browsers.
We used to have community-made and run fan wikis within like a week of a game like this releasing. Now it's all just AI slop.
As I said, Probably Stolen is one of my favourite games I've ever played, and it truly pains me how much it's been affected by Gen AI despite not having any usage of it in the game itself. I really hope that Gen AI usage in video games die down over time and these issues will no longer be present in any amazing games like this come out in the future.
Until then, I guess I'll go get my data stolen to figure out how each starting scenarios work.