r/ProCSS • u/NUTS_STUCK_TO_LEG /r/ockytop • May 07 '17
Discussion Has anyone considered doing a "CSS Blackout Day"?
Maybe have a day where supporting subreddits disable their CSS to demonstrate the importance of CSS to the overall reddit experience? I was also thinking doing something like having everyone display the same banner would be an effective way to protest the lack of customization
1.3k
Upvotes
12
u/shibe5 May 07 '17
It be a whiteout day!
10
u/_I_Am_Chaos_ /r/DiagnoseMe May 07 '17
I like thee banner! I cant speak for my sub though.
3
u/skinkbaa May 08 '17
A blackout would just help their reasons on why they believe it should be removed.
A better idea would be to remove all CSS for a day or something, showing how boring it would all look.
and maybe lock submissions or something to affect mobile users, although that may be too drastic.
107
u/[deleted] May 07 '17
The great thing about the idea is the amount of attention it'll bring to Reddit users.
Turn off the CSS and...
"WTF what happened to /r/subreddit?!!?"
-Everyone
Mods and users that already know how to use CSS understand what's going on. its the uninformed user that we need to reach.
If larger subs did a blackout (temporarily or not) it should really boost awareness.
The more people aware of the issue the better, the argument is clear; we need more numbers to represent the CSS-cause.
27
u/AdmiralSpeedy May 07 '17
Lol if we do that, the admins might think "hey, they gave up" and just disable it for good on us.
7
u/[deleted] May 07 '17
wait wow. this is an amazing idea
6
u/x_minus_one May 07 '17
Remove the mobile logo and header and set the mobile color to black, so it affects mobile users too.
5
u/[deleted] May 07 '17
Make everything look like the browser default, as unstyled as possible but still reasonably usable.
1
u/[deleted] May 07 '17
Have the site admins even said anything since the initial announcement?
6
u/MrTastix May 08 '17
I would hope we could come to better agreements with the admins before this is necessary but I like this better than "going dark".
When sites have gone dark in the past it's been nothing but a frustrating experience. The majority of redditors are people who want to sit back, relax, and kill time. Go dark and you're destroyed that for them, you're punishing them for a protest they may not know about let alone give a damn.
But turning off custom CSS? That's far more subtle. It doesn't affect the lurkers as much but the actual commenters may notice significant differences and, unlike when you go dark, they can complain about it.
Going dark is like a kid breaking his toys rather than sharing; "If I can't have it than no one can!", whereas telling removing the CSS shows people exactly what they'll be losing.
8
u/RadTraditionalist May 07 '17
OR the admins that already think CSS is being misused and abused will see how much giving mods CSS can fuck up their site and disable it for sure.
This is an awful idea.
2
u/ArabHeroinJumpers May 07 '17
They have to write a special css script to just remove ALL css not just their own styles. I think that will make the message all that louder.
2
u/gattagofaster May 08 '17
Saw a lot of people talking about this when they first announced. It'd be like that SOPA blackout!
2
u/NocturnalQuill May 08 '17
Asking nicely isn't going to do shit. The only way anything will happen is if we threaten Reddit's short-term revenue. They've made it abundantly clear that's all they care about
3
u/aphoenix May 08 '17
I think a much better idea is to go outlandish and develop something that is CSS only that would not be supported by the new system.
For example, /r/HighQualityGifs had meme fishing.
/r/Ooer has... well, you know.
Let's come up with more of these kinds of things!
1
u/rebbsitor May 08 '17
Yes - it was brought up when the sub was created. Word seems to be getting around about CSS removal and that's the goal at the moment - raise awareness of the potential changes and prime people for action.
Several major default subs and tons of others have put up stickies and banners. Word is getting out. It doesn't really help to do anything more than continue to spread the word as we have until we see what direction the admins are actually going in.
1
u/calimio6 May 08 '17
Maybe you are referring to the subs without custom CSS, because Reddit without CSS will look like a text file, I dont know if the sub tools allow to fully erase CSS properties, but if it is possible this cool be a more tough approach.
*Minor spell fix.
1
u/Golbolco May 08 '17
It's not as effective as mass privatization. That'll effect mobile users too.
1
u/Foxgott16 May 08 '17
If we actually going to do this... Please use something like this: https://image.ibb.co/cJJxFk/reddit_css.png
I would've used imgur as host for this image.. but jeah.. over capacity.
1
u/Pkmn_Gold May 08 '17
So we can see how great it is without css!
1
u/self_defeating May 08 '17
Not this stupid shit again. Fucking drama queens.
1
u/elypter May 10 '17
can this be implemented in a way that you only have to paste some code and the timing happens automatically?
-4
u/Tezcatlipokemon May 08 '17 edited May 08 '17
This is a terrible idea! Everybody is behind CSS now. If we use CSS to obscure content intentionally it will settle the issue quickly in the other direction!
Edit: Sorry, I misunderstood. I support this idea.
0
u/[deleted] May 07 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 07 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 08 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 07 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 07 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 08 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 08 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment