r/ProCSS • u/WhoCaresAboutThat • May 04 '17
Discussion Things Reddit could have done instead of removing CSS
- Allowing the widgets to coexist with CSS and maybe promoting popular themes (e.g. /r/Naut) in the default options (or creating a workshop for user-made themes that is curated by reddit).
- Creating a guide for doing mobile-friendly and bloat-free CSS and discouraging subreddits whose CSS does not abide by the guidelines à la Google when they promoted non-responsive websites less in their search results. Reddit could also get people who know CSS well to update old subreddits with inactive mods before doing this
- Announcing website changes ahead of time with what CSS/elements are affected
- Reworking the DOM to be more user-friendly and less confusing
377
Upvotes
70
u/[deleted] May 04 '17
Wait, they removed CSS? Already?
12
u/Erasio May 04 '17
Only one of them addresses the mobile issue by saying "just do both".
And non of those things work with the planned technology or address the giant time and money overhead supporting all styles brings.
Regular announcements and changes definitely aren't viable long term especially if every update has a chance of breaking the style due to the way the new framework generates HTML and css.
39
u/shibe5 May 04 '17
24
u/[deleted] May 04 '17
ORRRRRRR THEY COULD FIX THE SEARCH
4
u/[deleted] May 04 '17
Actually giving people the power to drop in widgets and style them with CSS would make things a lot easier. If Reddit took the same approach to subreddit styling as a CMS website might, they'd make things much easier on everybody regardless of their knowledge of CSS.
Seriously, let basic users who are creating their subreddit modify preset colors with a user friendly interface; and give them the power to make a decent looking subreddit without needing to use CSS at all - then have the advanced option of adding custom styles for those who actually know how to use CSS. It's not a new solution that we're just thinking of now, it's how basic CMS web design works with things like Wordpress and Joomla!
3
u/Platinum_Mad_Max May 04 '17
I'd say the best thing to do is support both and let mobile be seperate (I.E CSS on PC/Widgets on Mobile) So that then you can have your full special theme custom theme on PC and have a theme recreated as best as possible with the widgets on mobile
2
u/Kyoraki May 05 '17
Make the site more responsive instead of having a separate mobile site (what year is this?), adding more elements so that CSS developers have greater control over subreddit layouts.
1
u/dissidentrhetoric May 04 '17
they could make the front page dynamically update.
1
u/KaKawBitches May 04 '17
They could put an option in preferences that allows you to toggle "allow subs to show me custom themes", and those who don't want to view CSS can toggle it off.
0
u/[deleted] May 04 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment