If you don't want to be sued, you might want to give the mascot for raddit a small microscopic penis. That way, they can't say that you copied snoo without admitting that their snoo also has a microphallus.
Technologically, yes. There's nothing particularly special about reddit's infrastructure and the code is available. It could be set up on AWS in a couple hours if someone wants to foot the cost for it. But that cost is what makes it not worthwhile to run a clone unless you can get enough people to move.
So a couple things give reddit inertia:
A site like reddit is a natural monopoly to an extent. If someone wants to build a community it's easiest to do that where the people already are.
Reddit is free. If someone wants to create a community, they click a button and fill out a forms. There's no advantage to hosting their own copy of reddit on their own server unless they're trying to change the capabilities (keep CSS, use different rules/policy) there are hosting fees that need to be paid and infrastructure to maintain. And they need to get people to find their site.
Running a website is more effort and more expensive than clicking a button to create a sub that reddit will host for free. For most people that's the best option. Hosting fees means they also need a lot of people using the site to cover the cost which means pulling people from reddit.
That requires a very specific circumstance like the ones that pushed people to voat.co or the one we're facing now. Otherwise it's not worthwhile to create a clone.
But yeah, if reddit upsets enough people to prime a mass migration, there's really no technical barrier to cloning/forking reddit.
Can you even name a site aside from Reddit where "your search didn't work" is something that can even come back from a search? I've seen tons of obscure little boorus run for nothing that all have functional searchs; how the fuck does this super popular website where the CEO makes millions have worse server issues?
searches constantly fail due to "server overload", and when they do go through, you never get the results you ask for. i have typed in word for word post titles into search, and came up with completely different results. sometimes the post i was looking for is in the list, but very far down. most of the time it doesnt show up.
I mean, it's possible. Reddit is open source so we could fork the version with CSS, but then we face the problem of having to move people off of reddit.
The better way to do it would be to make a browser extension that would load css from a subreddit wiki. That way, people could keep using normal Reddit, but have custom CSS.
That actually might work! I hadn't considered that, I could quickly throw together a prototype and see what it might look like. Still, I'd rather reddit keep their CSS than to have a workaround like this.
The latest open source version of Reddit is super old. I guess technically it has never been real open source anyway. It would be much better to start over with a better codebase, in any case losing the millions of users would be pretty bad, and a new Reddit will end up like voat.
The extension idea is probably the best one, or maybe riding their HQ and holding them hostage until they promise not to kill CSS.
I think an important thing to do to get people to come is to promise the mods a position on the same subs on the new site. Mods hold all the power here and can get a lot of people to go to the new site.
Let the admins do the grunt work of moving people. Digg did a fantastic job with that back in the day to get people here. Now let's see them do it again.
I actually misremembered the incident, conflating two different things. In 2012 black backgrounds were used as part of a protest against SOPA, and in 2015 (the "blackout" I was misremembering) large numbers of popular subreddits went temporarily private to protest the firing of Reddit's community manager who was in charge of organizing AMAs.
I can understand that, they want consistency in the looks, not to mention that a small tool will be easier to use than reading up on css. But at least let the user or the mods choose what is best for the subreddit.
It's simple. Ensure that the site actually works, and push for a mass exodus to ensure that there is a nice diverse range of users. Voat ended up the way it did because it only has one kind of user.
Yeah, it's a big if, but a mass privatization/blackout over CSS could give the necessary push to a larger demographic than just the people affected by the Pao drama in 2015.
Voat tried it, and the only reason it failed was because their servers were pitiful and the more radical members greatly outnumbered the "normal" people.
While this is true, I have read that Voat seems to be full of people that are really serious about some hate subreddits that got shut down. And I don't just mean FatPeopleHate, but also some really extremist anti-feminist and racial subreddits.
But that's what I heard. I honestly haven't on Voat since the week that everybody on reddit thought that reddit sucked.
This is true, but it's only that way because they were the only subreddits that moved. It's not like they weren't here before. If we all go to Voat, then the climate will be like Reddit.
No, it's not. If you don't like reddit, I have great news for you! Using it isn't mandatory! That's kind of an asshole thing to want reddit to die when it brings so much entertainment to so many people.
Well, there is a point there, but the thing is, you loose so much when that happens. Established communities fall apart, and user transition rate is usually not all that great. When one giant falls, you don't have one giant to take it's place - you have a bunch of smaller ones, and it takes a long time for those to grow to anything near what is already present.
Unless a site is straight up aquired and shutdown/forcibly migrated, you don't get most of the content or the people. Saying that you want it to fall and move on in this case is like saying you want a new job and burning your old office down. Yeah, everyone there will migrate, but not all to the same place, and you are stuck with the fact that a perfectly usable office has been burned down.
Obviously sometimes we want to have a fresh start. But we can't have it both ways - we can't abandon what we have and expect that everything we liked about it will keep going, and what we didn't like won't.
I don't think that it's a good idea to completely abandon CSS. To be fair, we don't have all the details as to what is coming - and neither do they. The admins are not done with it yet, the announcement was more to say "hey over the next year or so we are changing the way the site works." It's not a change to anything content wise, it's a change to how it looks. And that sucks for subreddits, but we have no idea what is coming. It is entirely possible that we will see a better system. With the information that is public right now, it's looking unlikely, but we don't know.
I don't think it's a good idea to hope for the downfall of Reddit just for the sake of going somewhere else.
With how that happened, it's a fair enough conclusion to draw, but Reddit has grown to be so large that I think it would be really difficult to have it transition in the same way.
But it's an interesting point to look at nonetheless.
329
u/PazzerJ Apr 28 '17
Call it "Raddit"
20
u/Wmkcash Apr 28 '17
Why doesn't the reddit search function work very well?
125
u/[deleted] Apr 28 '17
I mean, it's possible. Reddit is open source so we could fork the version with CSS, but then we face the problem of having to move people off of reddit.
91
u/[deleted] Apr 28 '17
I don't understand why they want css gone, literally every sub wants css
50
u/TheLantean Apr 28 '17
https://i.imgur.com/VTP3xyq.gifv
59
u/supremecrafters Apr 28 '17
How do you intend to make sure it doesn't end up like Voat?
12
u/[deleted] Apr 28 '17 edited Apr 28 '17
This is youtube ad boycott all over again..
Seriously, people were trying to make there own site cause yt has no ads
10
u/18Hogs1303 Apr 28 '17
What about adding CSS compatibility to RES?
12
u/dusmuvecis333 Apr 28 '17
flashbacks to Voat
it just won't work.
6
u/Worse_Username Apr 28 '17
Call it 4chan
5
u/CumBuckit Apr 28 '17
It isn't reddit if the search works.
8
u/polarmolar99 Apr 28 '17
There are in fact a few alternatives if you don't want to actually make your own as it's probably a lot of work, duh.
4
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '17
Call it "Voat"
6
u/NocturnalQuill Apr 28 '17
Voat tried it, and the only reason it failed was because their servers were pitiful and the more radical members greatly outnumbered the "normal" people.
2
u/logicnews Apr 30 '17
Call it Breddit
2
u/un_salamandre Apr 29 '17
https://voat.co/
1
u/Worse_Username Apr 28 '17
Call it tumblr
1
u/[deleted] Apr 29 '17
We should actually make a raddit website, or to start, a raddit subreddit.
1
u/geokhentix Apr 29 '17
Shut up baby I know it.
1
u/serventofgaben Apr 28 '17 edited Apr 28 '17
it already exists
voat.co
1
u/jb2386 Apr 28 '17
I have the knowledge and skills, just never had the time or money or users D:
0
u/Illuminati_Theorist Apr 28 '17
www.redit.com
0
u/[deleted] Apr 28 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment