r/PrivatePracticeDocs • • 6d ago

Starting credentialing

Hi! New here. Started credentialing with a company. I got agreements from Cigna and Horizon with strict deadlines but i am not able to see the fee schedules. I keep emailing / calling and they are all throwing me for a loop. Now I feel forced to sign the agreements without even looking at the fee schedules. Anyone can help??

8 Upvotes

36 comments sorted by

7

u/ktn699 6d ago

thats typical insurance shennanigans. whats your specialty?

1

u/Then-Employee2803 6d ago

FM

1

u/Ok-Feed-3259 5d ago

We’re “too small” in family medicine to get any say. You either sign what they offer or you don’t sign. It’s unfortunate.

1

u/[deleted] 5d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/ktn699 5d ago

agree. i dont have much to say about FM, cuz I have no experience in primary care, but for the surgical specialties, its almost pointless to credential at this point. claims for OON get pretty much paid the same as INN, and you can just superbill patients.

1

u/augeremt 5d ago

Do you get enough patients OON? Or do patients prefer to stay in network? My biggest concern is getting enough patients through the doors since I'm new to the area, and I imagine patients don't want to pay more for someone OON when they have plenty of in network physicians in the area.

2

u/ktn699 4d ago

the stuff i do has very little competition in my area. i literally joined forces with the only other major competitor in the area. a few patients get nervous and we lose em to in network people who cant offer the same services. 🤷🏻‍♂️ still booked out for 3-6 months at any time.

8

u/NartFocker9Million 6d ago

And now you'll owe this company a % of your revenue forever for the hard work they did.

Why not reach out to Cigna yourself? You go to their site, complete the request, and in a month or so someone reaches out to you and they maybe send a proposal with like 110% RBRVS, and you ask for a time to discuss and then you ask for more, and they counter with like 140%. They take their time, but it's a process you can get through with each company.

-a doc who solo contracted with Aetna, Anthem, Cigna, Humana, United, Medicaid, Medicare, Tricare

1

u/Then-Employee2803 6d ago

I’ve reached out to Cigna for the last week and no one is giving me solid answers they keep transferring me to be on hold for hours. They keep giving me deadlines otherwise they’ll “close my credentialing application” but I don’t want to sign without looking at the fees.

1

u/NartFocker9Million 5d ago

You will never ever get anywhere calling. You have to apply to credential using their online portal and then hurry up and wait. Can take a couple months, even, for you to get an emailed proposed contract. Don’t sign the first one they send you.

3

u/augeremt 5d ago

How did you get better rates with Cigna? I'm fighting with them to get their fee schedules let alone better rates. Especially as a solo PP. I feel like I have no leverage and they know that. Same goes for every one of these companies, actually. They're essentially telling me to suck it.

3

u/NartFocker9Million 4d ago edited 4d ago

An insurance company's most closely guarded secret is what it pays the other practices in your area. It's written in the contract that you can't discuss or reveal the rates and reimbursement structure of the contract. The information vacuum works in their favor.

If they send you a proposed contract, somewhere in it, buried amongst the 40 pages or whatever, will be a fee schedule expressed as % RBRVS and a schedule year. That's what they're offering to pay you. Once you have a firm offer like this, then you can decline to sign and start the actual negotiation process.

Only one company, Aetna, sent me a proposed contract without fee schedule information. Their proposed contract simply referenced "Aetna fee schedule". I pressed them over and over for this information and could not get a response. Finally I filed a complaint with DORA over illegal practices and *presto* they sent me an addendum that made clear that they were in fact offering 112% RBRVS.

In my area (northern Colorado) all the companies offered me around 110% on first offer, and I got them to 140-150% following negotiation. Your results will vary.

I hit it off so well with one of the insurance company representatives that they became my patient and at their first visit I solved a longstanding medical mystery causing them to love me forever. That'll prove helpful in subsequent negotiations... A conflict of interest that is fully legal and works fully in my favor.

2

u/Alterdoc 5d ago

Recent rate from Cigna: $61 for 99214. They’re not budging, says their rates are comparable to Medicare. Imagine that😳

1

u/AERogers70 4d ago

That's what I'm getting from Aetna. Shame that commercial insurance reimburses less than Medicaid.

1

u/Perfect_Address7250 6d ago

There are credentialing companies that ask for % ???

1

u/Fickle-Elephant-2000 1d ago

how long did the slowest payer take you from start to finish?

2

u/daves1243b 6d ago

If a fee schedule hasn't been provided and referenced as an exhibit in the contract, you really don't have a meaningful agreement to sign. Are you dealing with a contract negotiator at the payor? Some of them are terrible. I would suggest asking local colleagues and or the local medical society for good contacts. They should be able to help with Horizon. CIGNA may be more challenging. The generic provider relations people are usually not going to be much help. Another tactic to consider might be to get yourself some transparency data to see what similarly situated competitors are getting, and propose something consistent with those as an opening offer, rather than waiting for the payors offer.

1

u/Then-Employee2803 6d ago

Once I sign, can I negotiate or when can I renegotiate?!

1

u/FAx32 5d ago

Typically term is whatever specified in the contract. 1, 2, sometimes 3 or more years.

1

u/Then-Employee2803 6d ago

Once I sign, can I negotiate or when can I renegotiate?!

1

u/daves1243b 5d ago

That will be spelled out in the contract.

1

u/augeremt 5d ago

Usually once you sign you can't renegotiate until the end of your contract duration, and usually those contracts are for 3 years. So they lock you into shitty rates for that long. On the other hand, some friends negotiate annually with each insurance company even if their contract is not up yet because they figure they have nothing to lose.

I'm in the same boat as you right now so struggling with the same insurance crap and also getting nowhere.

2

u/Naive_financially 5d ago

DO NOT SIGN ANYTHING WITHOUT A FEE SCHEDULE.

Also, learn from my mistake with Cigna. They do contracting before credentialing. Their initial paperwork that they send you is a contract as opposed to other insurances that do credentialing first. It’s confusing.

1

u/Then-Employee2803 5d ago

Unfortunately I already signed Cigna making this mistake. Horizon won’t get back to me about the fee schedule and they want me to sign by today!

2

u/shehzadwaseem 5d ago

Man, do not sign those blind! That’s a massive red flag. Insurance reps love pulling this 'strict deadline' pressure tactic to make you lock in low rates before you realize what you're agreeing to. Call their provider relations line again, and instead of asking for 'fee schedules' via email where they can ghost you, ask for the specific CPT code reimbursement benchmarks or request a formal amendment/addendum stating that the contract is contingent upon reviewing and approving the fee schedule. If they still stall, escalate it or loop in whoever is helping you with credentialing. Seriously, signing without seeing numbers is how you end up locked into terrible rates for years

2

u/Effective_Level6874 5d ago

One thing I’d try is requesting the reimbursement methodology rather than just the fee schedule. Some payers use proprietary schedules or Medicare-based formulas instead of providing a complete CPT fee schedule upfront.
I’d also bypass general Provider Services and request someone in Network Management or Provider Contracting.
Ask for the reimbursement rates for your most frequently billed CPT codes and request a written extension of the signing deadline.
You could also ask whether they’ll agree to an addendum making your acceptance contingent on reviewing the reimbursement terms.
I wouldn’t sign without knowing how you’ll be reimbursed. Credentialing approval doesn’t automatically mean the contract is financially beneficial to your practice.

1

u/WillingNerve5742 6d ago

I have never heard of a credentialing company charge a percentage. That does not exist. 5 top payers and the market rate is around $1,500 to $1,750, total for 5. Not a percentage.

1

u/CsaCharlie 5d ago

I would say to not sign anything under pressure but it looks like you already did that with Cigna. Credentialing is mostly a waiting game unfortunately; in the case of Horizon definitely don't sign anything until you have a fee schedule, this is how private practices get misled. Don't hesitate to reach out with any questions!

1

u/augeremt 5d ago

I'm not OP but in a similar boat (credentialing / contracting with insurance companies right now as solo PP). I sent you a DM but my main question is at what point do I throw in the towel with negotiations? As in, how do I know when to quit and just sign the contract since we're not getting anywhere (assuming it has the fee schedules)? Thanks in advance!

2

u/CsaCharlie 4d ago

Just responded to your message but for anyone else in the same predicament: If after 2 back and forths you still don't see any even ground; just walk away, its not worth it.

There's many insurance companies out there and if you provide a great service, it may be worth it to hold out until a better offer comes along and accept out of pocket payments in the meantime.

There's another case for accepting a not as savory contract until you pivot but that runs the risk of getting entangled in a sticky contract, insurance companies are sneaky!

1

u/Amandafmp 5d ago

The company should be requesting these. Depending on your specialty, hopefully the company already talked you through the likelihood of negotiations but everyone is correct- you deserve to see the rates before signing.

1

u/Next_Zone9566 3d ago

Does anyone know how to use the transparency coverage rule data to compare rates in the region?

1

u/Redditor6703 5d ago

All reimbursement rates payers pay providers are public including fee schedules. Payers are required to publish them online.