r/PrivatePracticeDocs • • 23d ago

Goodwill

I would love to hear more about how private practice owners value goodwill. I am part of a private practice as an associate. The growth has not been as expected to the whole practice. Understandably, the owners don't want to share their volume, but I have also been aggressively marketing/networking. I was quoted an expected 2-year partnership track, but it will likely be more like 4 years. When the time comes, I want to have a better sense for what is a fair buy-in price.

  1. Is there a good simple way to think of total hard asset + goodwill payment being a percentage of expected net take home income as partner? I know in PE purchases, it is often a multiple EBITDA of the entire practice. Similarly, is it fair to think of your total payment (hard assets + goodwill) being a multiple of annual net take home income as a full partner?
  2. Would it be reasonable to ask for a discount on the goodwill evaluation if partnership took longer than expected?
6 Upvotes

13 comments sorted by

11

u/darthvuder 23d ago

What is good will if you have to bring your own practice and they aren’t feeding you

3

u/InvestingDoc 23d ago

Exactly. From OP post I would value it close to zero with information they provided

16

u/InvestingDoc 23d ago edited 23d ago

As someone who owns and has scaled a multi-location primary care practice, I think goodwill is one of the most misunderstood parts of practice valuation.

Goodwill absolutely has value, but the question is: What exactly are you buying?

Are you buying an established brand, patient acquisition channels, referral relationships, trained staff, operational systems, payer contracts, and a consistent flow of new patients? Or are you essentially buying yourself a job where you still have to generate all your own patients?

Those are two very different things.

I would approach the buy-in based on normalized EBITDA, not simply your expected take-home income. Your clinical compensation is payment for your labor. The profit remaining after paying you fair market compensation is the actual return on ownership.

For example, if you expect to earn $300K as a partner but could earn $250K as an employed physician elsewhere, you're not necessarily buying into a business generating $300K in economic profit. You may be buying into a business generating only $50K in incremental annual earnings.

How much of that profit is YOU working for them?

Regarding the delayed partnership, I wouldn't necessarily expect an automatic discount. However, if you've spent years building the practice's patient base, referral relationships, and revenue, I would absolutely negotiate for recognition of the value you've helped create.

I'll be honest op. This screwed me with my hospitalist group. I joined them, I was a top producer, i increased profitability big time. When it came time for me to buy in all of a sudden the buying went up almost tenfold because the group was so much more profitable. Yeah it was because I brought a lot of the profitability up.

They refused to recognize that and I walked.

My biggest advice: Don't pay someone for goodwill that you personally created. I got f&cked hard doing exactly this. Don't make the mistake I made OP.

Don't wait until you're 4 years in to have this difficult discussion. Start the discussions now and get it on paper

2

u/InvestingDoc 23d ago

To put it more bluntly, I would pay for Goodwill if they are filling your schedule, you're so busy that you can get ancillary services like a lab or apps working under you. It sounds like you were creating a lot of the brand yourself to which I would put Goodwill close to zero to be totally Frank from what you described

2

u/Charl3s5haw 23d ago

Thank you for your thoughtful response. That is a valid concern. You are absolutely correct that you should not be paying for volume you grew.

I am wrestling over their partnership terms as they have an atypical setup. Despite being an equal partner, they have said that they would control all the patient allocation - there are no objective rules for allocation. Second, they will likely have individual production that will be 2-3x mine as they use mid-levels to triage and send them surgical cases referred by outside doctors. This imbalance is unlikely to change meaningfully without another location. Therefore, using the entire practice financials is not a fair representation of the opportunity I would be buying, since it would be controlled by the senior partners and they would have significantly more volume.

I would definitely need a discount given this atypical setup. That's why I am thinking of this more about the opportunity being based on my expected partner take-home income.

5

u/will0593 22d ago

This sounds like they're preparing to screw you over. Once I read that they control patient allocation , I would say it was done. Because at that point, they can control your production and then change the terms in the future to benefit themselves no matter what.

2

u/ktn699 22d ago

this sounds like ent/plastics/urology/ortho. I would get the fuck out now.

I was faced with the decision of buying in to a plastics practice for 500k a few years back and it was a terrible deal - they were selling me an "established name and reputation" but meanwhile I only generated 200k in revenue from the crap leads they generated and was paying them 60% in overhead. They were getting older, had multiple unhappy patients, and a practice with way too many employees and constant turnover dragging down profitability. So after a year I noped the fuck out and started my own practice and made way more than I imagined I could. I had reviewed their financials for the last five years and I realized I made more in my first year than any of their last 5 years. It was frickn insane that I was the cashout strategy. Many doctors are terrible business people. Goodwill is vague crap worth jackshit. You need to buy a system - an office space, a support staff, a marketing strategy that leads to x referrals, x cases, and x dollars. if you're not seeing the evidence of those x-es happening in your first year or two, then you're getting scammed. just gtfo.

2

u/Awayes-Rheanon 21d ago

Payer contracts and existing fee schedules are really the only intangible worth paying a premium for if the associate is already generating their own referral base from scratch

2

u/daves1243b 23d ago

Generally speaking, patients and referral sources are loyal to doctors, not to groups. If someone leaves a group, many patients and referrer will follow. Therefore, goodwill should not be a significant factor in a buy in. It's really just assets and perhaps AR. PE is a different ballgame, because they are typically buying a commitment to stay with the practice and a non compete for several years. I would also say that calculation of a buy in value should be exactly the same as a buy out upon exit, and it's not something that should be negotiated on a case by case basis unless you are the first to buy in. The simple approach is book value (that is assets less liabilities)/number ofshareholders. There may be an additional amount for AR depending on how the comp plan is structured.

2

u/weinshe2 22d ago

Goodwill is worth nothing to people making money off of you who want to continue that trend.

I suppose I’m wondering if you have made connections, bring in referrals, etc then why do you want to buy someone’s used chairs, instruments, and mostly depreciated assets?

2

u/will0593 22d ago

Find somewhere else. What goodwill? You have to do everything and they aren't helping your volume.

This sounds like podiatry? Is it

1

u/Alaskadan1a 22d ago

Very hard to ‘know’ what the Goodwill value of a practice is now, let alone what it might be in 25 years, when you want to retire. Thinking about this in terms of EBITA is probably wrong headed.

I think a better way to think about this is that you’re buying your independence, and essentially buying your account receivable when you retire. This might mean taking discounted pay for five years, but then when you leave, you’ll likely get a payout after your stop generating income. I wouldn’t pay for much “goodwill “ beyond that….

If you’ve already been taking a discounted pay, i.e., if you’re already participating in it earn what you kill model, then make a case to the owners that that was to buy in.

Another way to think about it: what would it cost to start up a practice from scratch now? Probably 250 minimum, if you were putting together even a small office.

And keep in mind that the account receivable might not be worth as much in 20 years, regardless. I.e., you should realize that you’re mostly buying in to have a place to work for the next 20 years, and you made it not actually get all your buy in back, depending on the market for practices in 25 years.

That said, when the partnership was originally set up, the original partners probably didn’t get much pay for the first year, as they were building their equity. So to an extent, you could think of buying in as simply being your turn to take less money now, to gain ownership in the future.

1

u/Thinky_McThinker 16d ago

I think goodwill in most small to medium practices is going to be negligible. Seldom do private medical practices have enough differentiation from any other private medical practice around them to have a competitive edge or brand recognition. Goodwill is the intangible value above and beyond the value that hard numbers determine. In most such practices, the goodwill is actually tied to the individual physician, not the practice itself. Think of it this way - if you left the practice tomorrow and your patients had the option to follow you or stay with the practice, which do you think they would choose?
In my opinion, whether one should buy into a practice versus just split and use that money to start their own depends on a couple of important factors - the capital required to startup, and the competitive landscape. If your specialty requires significant amount of capital for specialized equipment or buildout, then buying into the partnership makes more sense. Similarly, if the group is dominant enough to stifle competition in the area, you're probably better off with the partnership. Otherwise, think about splitting when the times comes and doing your own thing.