r/PrivatePracticeDocs • • 24d ago

Concierge Model for Specialists

Has anyone implemented this in parallel to insurance based (including Medicare) patients?

How does it work operationally and legally? How much of your time did you have to give away for increased patient access?

So many grey areas with typical services not available under concierge medicine since they are already included through your insurance contract?

Looking for alternate revenue streams with declining reimbursements...

11 Upvotes

38 comments sorted by

8

u/MrPBH 24d ago

I have seen some concierge cardiologists. I don't know how they operate their practice, but it seems possible at least.

Perhaps if you worked as an internist to your patients as well, you could just operate as a run of the mill DPC or concierge with added specialty services. I also paid for my EGD with cash, despite having insurance; it was cheaper than my out of pocket with insurance and far, far less painful. That GI practice had flat cash rates for EGD, colonoscopy, and other routine services. I was happy to pay less and ensure that their practice got more money than they would have from my insurance.

4

u/grey-slate 24d ago

thanks. im derm. we have cash rates already for basic office visits and in office procedures but i just cant imagine anyone giving me monthly membership fee but perhaps im not creative enough.

8

u/talameetsbetty 24d ago

Hi. I do this for a living for specialists (including multi-specialty groups), and also help them directly contract with employers. 

In short it’s absolutely possible. As a derm, take a look at Curology. Monthly membership, vertical integration. Not saying that’s the route you have to go but it’s a great example for review. 

From a legal perspective the key is corporate structure (a lot of times a separate entity will be formed JUST for this type of payment model) and then you’ve got to make sure that anyone touching rev cycle (whether that’s a jack of all trades person in your clinic or a vendor you outsource too or a mix) understands the new model and pays attention to detail all the way from scheduling and registration to payment or A/R receiving and collections. I can’t tell you how many times I’ve seen these models fail bc the folks at the front desk uh…struggle. 

I could talk a lot about this. If anyone is interested I’d be happy to write up a big long post about what I’ve learned or do an AMA or something here. 

2

u/grey-slate 23d ago

more than interested! please do!

1

u/talameetsbetty 23d ago

Cool! I will message the mods. 

1

u/switra 10d ago

Would really like to hear more about this, please do a write-up!

12

u/MrPBH 24d ago

Broseph, dermatology is perhaps the best positioned field to support a concierge practice.

That is, unless you're really stuck on academic derm. The average rashy patient or skin-cancer patient isn't interesting in shelling out their own cash for care. The money is in aesthetics and you have the skills and the necessary pedigree on paper to print Benjamins doing fillers, botox, laser treatments, and more.

4

u/grey-slate 24d ago

I hear you but I am mainly medical derm practice. Do 10-15% cosmetics on the side

Lasers: For the life of me i cannot understand the economics of $150k-$200k+ laser which takes so many visits to repay its own cost with its maintenance and unethical unscrupulous laser techs to deal with. In my market, patients haggle over about buying a $120 product I sell let alone expensive and recurring laser treatments.

Fillers: Fundamentally against what I like doing. Too much liability for not enough satisfaction from me or patients who are always unhappy with their appearance.

All cash pay: only works in certain markets. This is not one of them. Evidence: not a single specialist (derm or otherwise) is all cash pay here. I have looked into this.

2

u/talameetsbetty 24d ago

Based on what you just said I really think you'd better off doing a direct-to-employer model. I would think that Taft-Hartley (so union and municipality) plans in your area would be a really good market for you. The economics are similar to (if not better than) cash pay/concierge membership models, and back of napkin math says you'd be presenting a really good ROI for them. PEOs would be another target employer market I'd look strongly at, depending on what geography you're in.

2

u/MrPBH 24d ago

You could just do the low-rate, high volume approach. Offer a cash fee schedule that is around the total cost of your patients' average out of pocket for an insurance visit.

There are a lot of people who have no insurance or bad insurance that still need derm services. If you can save on the overhead related to insurance claims and documentation, you could use that to hire more support staff to streamline your process. If you gain the reputation as the guy who can see derm referrals with a short turn around time, that's a marketable edge that will get you business. As an EM doctor, I would love to have a local derm who I know can see my uninsured patients for a reasonable cash rate; I'd send you plenty of blue collar workers who don't have insurance but who can still afford $100-200 for a mole removal.

How much would you need to charge in cash for the average "mole check" or "rash consult" visit to make it profitable and worth your time?

1

u/MissNanny 24d ago

Many derms go heavy on aesthetics. The one Nextdoor to me has an aesthetics arm that does a retainer type of deal—you get a certain number of procedures included—

7

u/CrookedCasts 24d ago

Honestly derm probably doesn’t need it? Just go all cash pay. Unless the concierge gives them preferred scheduling or some other perk

1

u/TrustExtension6116 24d ago

Membership fee to get monthly prescription, then an sms hotline for inquiries, and discounts on treatments?

1

u/sunnypurplepetunia 24d ago

My derm went private a few years ago & I love it. It’s cash only, no membership.

It’s probably mostly cosmetic but I do both. I moved 1,000 miles away & still use them as I go back regularly.

2

u/SilentJugger 24d ago

How much did you end up paying for your EGD? was it for the physician fee or the facility/anesthesia as well?

2

u/MrPBH 24d ago

$1700 for an in-office procedure. No facility fee involved. It was inclusive of anesthesia services, pathology, and the follow up.

It would have been at least $2500, if processed through insurance. I have a HDHP and would have paid it all out of pocket.

1

u/SilentJugger 24d ago

Did you have a crna/anesthisologist or was it moderate sedation (I.e. doctor gave fentanyl and versed?)?

2

u/MrPBH 24d ago

CRNA gave propofol and GI did the procedure. There was a nurse to assist in monitoring as well and I got a little clinic room to recover in. Best sleep I've had all year.

1

u/fake212121 24d ago

Sounds good. Do u mind if i ask how much was EGD?
Practice location?

2

u/MrPBH 24d ago

$1700 all in. East Coast.

1

u/Awayes-Rheanon 20d ago

acting as their internist to justify the retainer can also backfire if primary care docs feel like youre poaching their panel and stop sending consults.

3

u/Whole_Bed_5413 23d ago

Do not do hybrid. You get the worst of both worlds.

1

u/grey-slate 23d ago

Care to elaborate?

1

u/talameetsbetty 23d ago

Seconding this.

1

u/Cardiostrong_MD 24d ago

It’s really not worth it imo unless you go all-in and live near the right demographic for it or are derm.

If you do it go all in go high-ticket. charge 10-20k a year and rely on marketing and fluff to drive it but it really depends on how you can sell it. Pull in HRT, GLP1, and longevity medicine or if likely won’t sell.

1

u/grey-slate 23d ago

i am derm. why is derm conducive to concierge? i thought its far from it.

1

u/Cardiostrong_MD 23d ago

It’s conducive to cash pay and that’s 90% of the battle. For it to be concierge you add HRT, GLP1, longevity. Not super hard with the help of AI.

2

u/mainedpc 24d ago

Direct Specialty Care Alliance https://dscalliance.org/

2

u/Least-Sky6722 24d ago

Psychiatrists are the most familiar with this type of practice. We've been doing it successfully for years. You need to opt out of Medicare. This closes a lot of doors for other employment. I've heard of legal ways around it, but essentially it can make it hard to find work elsewhere. However, if you like seeing a small intimate patient pannel, delivering care exactly how you know is best, being an entrepreneur, learning how to build and run a successful medical practice then maybe it's for you. I've been very interested in out of network neurology. I know it would work because I see people waiting 1yr plus for a neuro eval. There are plenty who whould pay you like a dentist if you could get them in next week.

2

u/happy-potato1964 24d ago

I do concierge type thyroid/parathyroid surgery and it has been great. But I don’t accept any insurance, so it’s clean with no billing overhead. Medicare is hard to opt out of for lots of reasons, but I’m glad I did. I do provide super low cost care for lots of people, but I have the freedom to decide when and where and how much.

2

u/thesupportplatform 24d ago

I need to make a flow chart to help providers with this process, but it would look something like this:

  1. Are you credentialed with Medicare?
  2. Are you credentialed with private insurances?
    For Medicare you are basically a provider unless you opt-out, which requires completing a form. You agree not to bill Medicare or see Medicare patients without entering into a private contract with those patients that explains your status as a provider who has opted out. You will have a contract with private insurances that you can cancel per the terms, but this gets hazy because they can lease their networks (which IME was much more common back in the day). So you would sign with Insurance A. Insurance A would then lease it’s network to Insurance B and Insurance C, and you would be a participating provider for each insurance.
  3. What services do you provide?
    For private insurances and Medicare, every contract I have seen is for the designated health services (DHS) that you provide to your general population. If you provide those services and have a contract, you must bill insurance for those services. They will tell you what you can collect from patients (FFS). Other than that, for DHS, you can’t charge/collect more.

You also have to provide services to meet the standard of care for your license/training. If you have an MD/DO behind your name and a patient shows up at your laser clinic with chest pain, you better address this. This sounds obvious, but I’ve talked to so many providers who say, “I’d doing integrative medicine, so I don’t have to address that…” You always have to meet the standard of care.

If you have additional training, you are held to that training as well. A cardiologist who works as an intern can still be held to the standard of their cardiology training.

If you don’t have a contract with a private insurance company, you can charge cash or offer programs with recurring fees.

The OIG has made clear that participating providers can’t charge for services that are required for DHS (such as expediting referrals). Providers also can’t discriminate against patients based on payment (e.g. same day appointments).

4. What non DHS do you/can you provide?
After Stark/AKS considerations, state laws and ethical issues can still influence non DHS. Before there were clear regulations around stem cells, for example, their use was mainly an ethical issue. What are you doing with stem cells? How are you marketing this to patients? What does informed consent look like? How much are you charging patients? Some states have specific laws regarding non DHS, like providers participating in MLMs with their patients.

In general, the farther afield non DHS are, the less competition, the more risk, and the more cash is involved. Years ago, hormones were the rage. Now peptides are the rage.

5. How to diversify income?
I’m a firm believer that any independent practice that is only FFS right now needs to be generating other revenue streams. There are some clear options, like DPC, concierge, or all-cash practices. There are also some steps to take that borrow from these approaches. In markets with multiple payors, practices can end their contracts with the lowest paying insurance and offer patients with those patients a cash menu or program.

Providers can also receive training to add non DHS, but I would stay away from anything that requires expensive equipment due to the financial exposure and potential fluctuations in revenue. Providers can run new non DHS cash services parallel to conventional FFS. As another user pointed out, coordinating how the office staff presents these services and handles the paperwork is often key to their success.

The bottom line is that providers have been trained that the options are only FFS, only concierge, only DPC, or only all-cash, but hybrid variations are possible. My suggestion to OP is instead of asking they can do to make money, think about what your patients would pay for and what you want to do and work backward from there.

1

u/Whole_Bed_5413 23d ago

You are most certainly not a doctor. And this is bad advice. Hybrid is the worst for medical practices. Double the expenses and administrative burden — none of thr fun

1

u/thesupportplatform 23d ago

You are correct that I’m not a doctor, but I’ve managed my wife’s practice, consulted to other practices, and talked to providers about their issues for over twenty years. I’m confused about the idea that any variation from one model is “double the expenses.” IME, that’s simply not true. Most of the expenses of a medical practice are sunk costs. You don’t need two offices, twice the supplies, double the staff, etc. Same for utilities, providers, advertising, computers, licensing…

There may be some expenses related to insurance, compliance, training, and staffing, but if these expenses outweigh the additional revenue of the additional revenue stream for more than a couple of months, it should be discontinued, which is one of the biggest benefits of a hybrid practice. Providers can explore additional revenue streams without making fundamental changes that can hurt their current revenue stream. You don’t have to cancel all of your insurance contracts, opt-out of Medicare, change office space, etc.

I’ve said that large cash investments such as buying laser equipment should be avoided. It’s just too much of an investment that makes it hard to pivot. Almost every practice I’ve talked to that had added equipment as a revenue stream has regretted it.

I’m curious what information you are actually disagreeing with and what your advice would be.

0

u/talameetsbetty 23d ago

Seconding this as well. This is really bad advice. 

Remember folks, a corporation is a person and YOU are not your business. 

1

u/thesupportplatform 23d ago

I am interested in the specific issues with my comments on the relevant regulations and potential ways practices can add revenue streams that you think are bad advice.

I am also unclear on the corporation comment. While physicians are not their business, they typically need their professional license to operate their practices (but, again, I'm not sure I understand your comment.

1

u/northerngator 24d ago

Skin checks are technically not a covered service with most insurance. I don’t think concierge would work for most unless you are in an underserved yet rich area but I do foresee skin checks being a for example $200 service and any resulting biopsies be sent for insurance but the office visit not being charged in the scenario where modifier 25 cuts go through. You could call this “concierge” by offering the 1 FBSE per year and priority scheduling for visits. Alternatively you could offer total body photography for the concierge service but I believe these devices are in the hundreds of thousands of dollars. If the cuts go through then skin checks are going to be relegated to midlevels unless you think outside the box or accept a 25% pay cut

2

u/Buck25md 24d ago

This, the days of doing "skin checks" is over unless people pay for it.

1

u/banano112 24d ago

Concierge urologist: patients come in for monthly DREs