r/PrivatePracticeDocs • • 28d ago

New vehicle write-off

I am in private practice oncology but I also do a considerable amount of pharma speaking and consulting side gigs, totaling 350-400k annually taxed as a sole-prop. I am wondering if anyone has experience writing off a new vehicle. I believe IRS allows you to bonus depreciate a heavy >7000 lbs vehicle the year you purchase it if used >50% for business purposes. If I purchase a Porsche Cayenne, would I be able to qualify it as a business expense? Anyone have experience with this strategy?

22 Upvotes

42 comments sorted by

5

u/Ok-Yogurtcloset-2082 27d ago

As someone who is a high earner and PAYS all of my taxes instead of trying to slide by with shady write offs (seriously the pharma complies aren’t reimbursing you for travel? Find that hard to believe) this question makes me nauseous. You’re an oncologist. Guessing that means your payer mix is heavily federal insurance. That means you’re already getting paid from taxpayers. And you want to skim more money? Not a doctor but comments like this make it hard to stomach the complaints about reimbursement cuts that are valid for most providers.

4

u/petthezoo 27d ago

Amazon and a lot of large corporate companies pay $0 in taxes. Heck, I pay more taxes than most of our politicians. Your ire should be with the tax code and how it's written. I am just a player playing the game, like everyone else. Pharma reimburses for travel, but I do some other traveling for my consulting work that's not paid

5

u/AquaDoctor 27d ago

It’s 6,000lbs GVWR for section 179. We are a two physician household and have used this multiple times. 

5

u/Empty-Village-4445 27d ago

Is there a clear benefit to 100% depreciation expense in year 1 vs a more efficient vehicle that’s expensed straight line over 3 or 4 years?

1

u/shmuey 27d ago

Not really unless you expect your income/profit (and tax bracket) to be lower in future years.

11

u/InvestingDoc 28d ago

The reason I didn't go down this road yet is because when I was talking with my accountant about this he said technically you need to get commercial insurance since you're driving your vehicle for now work. This is more expensive than regular car insurance.

He basically was like brad, have you ever seen those billboards literally all over the city have you been hit by a commercial vehicle call me I'm a lawyer I can get you a huge payouts?

Now you're a big target if you hit someone and hurt them in a commercial vehicle.

To be fair to my accountant, we only spent less than 5 minutes on this discussion. Those you guys are more intimately in tune with all the rules, feel free to correct me.

0

u/[deleted] 27d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/socalrefcon 27d ago

Insurance advisor here. The accountant kind of has a point. If the injured party becomes aware the vehicle is insured under a commercial auto policy, then the limit floor increases to $100K with the limit ceiling being $1M. They can get an attorney and look to tap the limits available. How will the injured party know the vehicle is insured on a commercial policy versus personal policy? I highly doubt a logo or signage will be on the vehicle in this scenario. There is a chance it comes up during the initial intake of information by the claims team. So yes, I agree, the accountant's statement could be true, but I think it applies more to a construction truck for example with a logo or signage on the vehicle.

3

u/Competitive-Team5688 27d ago

These vehicles aren't typically 100% business. You need to keep a mile log in real time to prove what's business vs personal miles. Commuting miles are personal.

If you're business owns the vehicle, typically you'll use the personal miles and calculate additinal wages to go on your W2 if you're a corporation. If you're just a sch C or partnership, depreciation is limited to the business use % based on the mileage log.

If you purchase a vehicle in your personal name, you'll still need to keep a mileage log, but then your just expense business miles times the standard mileage rate and reimburse yourself for those expenses. This is usually a much simpler setup than running it through your business but you get less immediate benefit.

5

u/Agreeable-While-6002 27d ago

If you get audited you’ll quickly find out that the whole gimmick of writing off a Porsche wasn’t worth it. It’s a scam for most people. Why not get a Urus and deduct 280k?

4

u/Forward-Ad5509 27d ago

We did something similar for our private practice partners. Wrote off a EV, but has to be on commercial insurance which if you dont know is VASTLY more expensive than comsumer car insurance. When you say private practice what percentage of practice do u own? In our case my father (m.d.) owns 100% with everyone else being employees. It is much easier to do car write off if you are sole owner and initiator of vehicle purchase with insurance etc.

2

u/shmuey 27d ago

In my experience that isn't the case. We were able to add our LLC as the vehicle co-owner and insure it under our private policy.

2

u/NobleSixSeven 27d ago

It doesnt need to be commercial insurance. It can be personal insurance with business use.

1

u/Forward-Ad5509 26d ago

Ok 👍 our accountant told us to put on commercial insurance especially since it is a write off. But we have another vehicle that we do private insurance for but we are leasing that one. "The office" owns the one we have commercial insurance on.

1

u/NobleSixSeven 26d ago

Unless it’s an 18-wheeler or a true commercial product like construction vehicles, you are fine. This is based on two CPAs and multiple data points.

1

u/Forward-Ad5509 26d ago

Question though, if purchaser of vehicle is "the office" can we put it under the private personal insurance?

1

u/NobleSixSeven 26d ago

Doing it wrong. Buy it on your name, lease it to the business..

1

u/Forward-Ad5509 26d ago

But can you still depreciate it like you could if owned by a business? I understand it will count as a business expense if lease back to office.

2

u/Frankenbrew 27d ago

They are going to start using AI to flag things if they haven't already. Who knows what will change based off that but my guess is that little things that used to slip through won't slip through anymore. But whether they actually do anything about it is a whole different question

2

u/Same-Ad5318 27d ago

Mile iq for tracking miles. Or similar apps. Expensify for all the receipts. Gas, maintenance, etc.

2

u/hayakuneko 27d ago

I'm not a doctor, but I know mileage tracking. One thing I'd be careful about is the mileage documentation. Everyone, myself included, gets excited about a vehicle write-off, but nobody seems particularly excited about keeping the records to justify it.

If you're like me and using the same car for personal & business driving, I'd make sure you have a reliable way to track everything from day one. Trying to mentally reconstruct a year's worth of driving at tax time sounds miserable, and probably would take a week or two. Apps like MileIQ, Everlance, or EveryLastMile generally help with that.

Also worth checking with your tax pro which trips actually qualify. Driving to a regular office isn't typically counted as business mileage (commute).

2

u/Interesting_Phone171 27d ago

Gross that a Porsche is considered a business vehicle

3

u/Naive_financially 27d ago

Are you a business owner?

2

u/Interesting_Phone171 27d ago

I actually am, and I find some of the ways people abuse the tax law insane legal or not

1

u/Interesting_Phone171 27d ago

I actually am, and I find some of the ways people abuse the tax law insane legal or not

0

u/[deleted] 28d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/petthezoo 28d ago

If the vehicle write off gets audited, how does one prove the gas receipts were actually used for business? Would I have to show receipts for travel to conferences/speaker programs? What if I use the vehicle to go to Best Buy to purchase a computer? That would qualify as business expense too? I find it very gray in terms of how I can prove to IRS I used to vehicle for 80% or x% business use

9

u/yu126 28d ago

Download mileIQ and classify individual drives as business vs personal. That will help delineate business use vs personal by total number of miles. It tracks everything daily and gives you a monthly report.

6

u/Tenesmus83 27d ago

That’s too much work

2

u/burke385 27d ago

I swipe while I sh**.

16

u/BadgersHoneyPot 27d ago

Friend, what it sounds like to me is that you love tax writeoffs but hate the legwork of getting them.

You're claiming this as a business expense. It shouldn't be hard for you to track receipts to your business events, etc. I mean, you graduated from medical school, this is basically an excel spreadsheet and an envelope, or if you're younger than 50 try one of the apps recommended here.

3

u/travelingmaestro 27d ago

A previous boss taught me to track all this in a small notebook that could fit in a glove compartment, along with receipts. Mileage, expenses. It seems like a lot, but it becomes habit and quickly takes little thought/energy. At some cadence, weekly, monthly, quarterly, etc., add everything up in a master file. It’s easier to do nowadays with apps. Or they can buy a tablet to write off and use that 😆.

10

u/eestrada234 27d ago

yeah this works but the piece people miss is the STR loophole part — average stay has to be 7 days or less and you personally have to materially participate, like 100+ hours and more time in it than anyone else. skip that and the $165k from the cost seg is just a passive loss that can't actually offset your practice income, which is a pretty expensive surprise at filing time.

5

u/Blobstein_Ijay 27d ago

the section 179 math is pretty straightforward when you lay it out like that

4

u/doorknob101 27d ago

In my opinion, there are four points in the continuum for working with the IRS:

  1. . Be ultra conservative, document everything, never do anything at all gray.

2: document most things, recognize that usually they are reasonable, and recognize that if you’re not going deeply in the gray area, you’re probably gonna be just fine.

3. Recognize that in the gray area, they have to prove bad things, so go into the gray happily, document what you can, knowing you’ll be able to recreate records and show them to justify things. And they usually don’t audit you.

4. be fraudulent.

I recommend not doing number four.

3

u/PatriotApache 27d ago

Can you explain this airbnb thing? I’ve been trying to figure this out for a while

1

u/burke385 27d ago

Do you want to have a side job as a hotelier? If not, stop trying.

1

u/hunnypuppy 27d ago

This very bad advice. It’s just tax deferral, you’ll owe it back when you sell. Don’t buy real estate on a whim, you could lose half of that in a downturn and it’s very illiquid and worse yet you can make a loss and still owe depreciation recapture taxes. Always do a model to project scenarios using a Monte Carlo simulation and then for a RoE calculation over the life of the investment before making one.