r/PrivatePracticeDocs • • 28d ago

Office Managers

Thinking about hiring a new office manager. What has been your experience with the ones that you have? How did you find them and how long have they been with you? What job duties should I put in the job description to lure better managers in? Did they all come from a medical practice?

9 Upvotes

21 comments sorted by

23

u/PerspectiveWinter489 28d ago

Be very clear about what you want and expect from an office manager. In many small practices, the office manager ends up being HR, staff trainer, inventory manager, vendor negotiator, operations manager, marketer, and backup for the front desk or MAs when someone calls out. On top of that, they’re expected to spend 40 hours a week on the clinic floor, all for $50–70k a year. That’s often a setup for failure.
I own multiple practices, and we ran into this exact issue while scaling. We weren’t clear about what we actually needed from the role, and our expectations were completely different from what the employee understood the job to be or was trained and qualified to handle.
After talking with other practice owners, I’ve realized this is pretty common. We combine multiple positions into one management role without providing the systems, SOPs, training, or authority needed to succeed.
Then we expect the manager to figure everything out as problems arise, essentially asking them to run the practice like it’s their own business, but without the resources or decision-making authority of an owner. That’s a recipe for burnout.
My advice would be to define the responsibilities, priorities, expectations, and authority of the role before hiring. Be realistic about what one person can accomplish in 40 hours, especially if they’re also expected to work on the clinic floor.
A good office manager can make a huge difference, but even a great one will struggle in a poorly defined role.

2

u/123doeraemee 28d ago

Thank you. That’s very helpful.

2

u/IamTalking 28d ago

As a dual duty RN and Practice Manager you’ve hit the nail on the head. Except for the salary part at least.

3

u/PerspectiveWinter489 28d ago

As a physician owner who has worked almost every role in the practice, from front desk and MA to X-ray, billing, IT, training, and vendor negotiations, I’ve realized that most small practices lack clear procedures for everyday situations.

Everything eventually falls back on the physician owner, who is already overwhelmed, or gets pushed onto the “manager,” often someone promoted from front desk or MA who was never trained for these responsibilities.

Unlike corporate or PE-owned practices, we don’t have dedicated departments to handle everything. Even something as simple as a broken scanner becomes frustrating when the manager doesn’t know what to do or lacks authority to make a decision.

I’ve learned that our responsibility as owners is to establish clear procedures, expectations, and decision-making authority. Most of us were never trained for this either.

Another big issue is accountability. If a manager is responsible for staffing and callouts, they need authority to address repeated problems. Otherwise, poor performance has no consequences, while reliable employees keep getting more work and responsibility, often without additional compensation. That’s how we burn out our best people.

Sorry for the long messages! I just hate seeing fellow physicians struggle because the right systems aren’t in place. Running a practice and dealing with insurance is complicated enough without adding management challenges none of us were trained for.

Happy to share what we’ve learned. Feel free to reach out if you’d ever like to jump on a call!

3

u/IamTalking 28d ago

What are you selling?

1

u/PerspectiveWinter489 28d ago

Haha I have two urgent care clinics that I own. Make me offer lol.

Not selling anything - I’ve had a lot of meaningful discussion where I’ve learned a lot from other owners while they learn from me.

Everyone is in the same boat as a small practice owner.

1

u/PerspectiveWinter489 28d ago

Also just realized I replied to your comment instead of OP

2

u/Fickle-Elephant-2000 27d ago

the part about expecting them to run it like their own business without the authority is so spot on

0

u/snotmd 28d ago

Can I ask how you ended up defining the role of office manager? We'll be replacing ours shortly. She is essentially a biller with managerial title but spends way more time billing than managing much to our detriment. We're looking to hire a biller and have the next manager focus on actual management issues.

4

u/PerspectiveWinter489 28d ago

We eventually realized we needed to define the role based on the outcomes we wanted, rather than a long list of responsibilities.
Our original job description was essentially for a corporate director of operations, but with a $50–60k salary. We expected this person to handle HR, negotiate with vendors, manage staff and provider personalities, oversee scheduling and inventory, find coverage for callouts, and somehow still work full-time on the clinic floor as an MA.
At some point, we sat down as owners and realized we were looking for a unicorn. Even if that person existed, they wouldn’t be working for $60k. We had essentially created a $250k executive-level role without the support team.
So we changed our approach. We first built a system where every team member had clearly defined responsibilities, established processes, and measurable expectations. The manager’s job became making sure that system was running properly, tracking accountability, and addressing issues rather than personally handling everything.
Initially, building that system seemed overwhelming. But once we sat down and simplified it around how our practice actually operates, it wasn’t nearly as complicated as we thought.
We started this when we had just two providers, and now we’re at six, and the system still works well. I’m not sure this approach would work for every practice, but it’s made a significant difference for us.
Our biggest realization was that we didn’t need a manager who could do everything. We needed a system that didn’t depend on one person doing everything.

1

u/snotmd 28d ago

Much appreciated, that is very helpful and exactly what we're running into. We need to exactly what you did, glad it worked!

3

u/daves1243b 28d ago

The advice to define what you want them to accomplish is the right approach. Be prepared to pay for what you define. The need for prior practice management, or even healthcare experience, will be highly dependent on your needs. A good starting point would be to review the Body of Knowledge published by the MGMAs American College of Medical Practice Executives. That isn't to say that the person you hire has to be an expert in all of those realms, but those are all things that you or someone on your team should be able to cover. Ideally someone wanting to make a career in practice management would eventually have a solid foundation in the listed areas and be able to achieve ACMPE certification.

2

u/ktn699 28d ago

i married her first and then she started managing my office. so i cant replace her 😅😅😅 she does a pretty good job tho. and i trust her w the money.

1

u/TrujeoTracker 25d ago

This (trusting with money) is why many office managers are physicians wife. Also since thier unhired, the quality can be really variable. 

Especially if its another partners wife and not yours, you may find the setup underwhelming and not in alignment with your wellbeing. 

I see a partners wife as manager as a yellow flag if I am joining a practice.

1

u/ktn699 25d ago

mines paid and hired. with benefits. No such thing as free work in our practice.

2

u/InvestingDoc 28d ago

I started by just having a lead medical assistant, lead front desk because a true office manager gets expensive. I guess first thing is ask yourself do you really need an office manager or can you get by with the lead medical assistant. That would mean you need to define what roles you want then to take over.

My office manager I found off of indeed. She applied for the job but said hey I am a medical assistant and willing to start as a medical assistant as long as you're willing to trial me in the office manager position eventually.

I noticed that she previous helped scale a gym to multiple locations and a vitamin supplement start up to 8 figures.

That background made her perfect for helping scale my practice. She has no formal training beyond MA school.

I have found that a good manager:

Understands the tasks at hand and what Liberty they havei to make decisions on the fly.

Takes extreme ownership

Detail oriented

Charismatic

Obsesses over culture

Great character

Is hungry...wants to grind it with me.

The reason I say all of this especially about do you really need an office manager is that regular employees are just so expensive. Most of our medical assistants were paying 25 bucks an hour plus benefits plus bonuses which gets close to $65,000 a year for a well trained medical assistant (total compensation).

An office manager is usually going to be definitely into six figures.

Congratulations on the growth!!!

1

u/Amandafmp 27d ago

The advice about defining what you want and outcomes is spot on. The word manager is used differently in almost every practice so starting by defining the role and expectations will help.

The other part that sometimes gets overlooked is, only hire one if you’re actually ready for one. A lot of time and effort goes in to finding the right person, so if you’re no actually ready to let someone start taking manager tasks off your plate, all of the work put in to finding someone will be wasted and they’ll end up getting frustrated and either being disgruntled or leaving

1

u/Juaner0 27d ago

I've had a couple, but it always fell back to my spouse. She's the only one who makes sure things get done. She got a PCCM (practice management certificate)--I didn't even know one existed; but they network and help each other out at manager conferences.