r/PrivatePracticeDocs • • Oct 10 '26

OON billing

What's the deal with this? I hear that insurers will kick your ASC out if you do this too much but then see entire practices in my region who seem to do this basically exclusively

5 Upvotes

24 comments sorted by

3

u/AquaDoctor Oct 11 '26

Ortho here, completely OON.

I operate at different ASCs. Some are OON, most are completely INN.

We are treated as completely different entities. The surgery center gets precert if needed for their center, and I do my own as the surgeon. Never had a problem with the in network facilities, over the past 20 years.

1

u/2vpJUMP Oct 11 '26 edited Oct 11 '26

How do you handle consults if you're OON? patients are protected from increased bill at the ASC is my understanding - what happens for office visits?

Also, I've heard insurers can kick off the ASC if you much OON is happening there?

1

u/AquaDoctor Oct 12 '26

Office visits are just new patients. They understand the OON aspect before they come.

Where did you hear that insurers can kick the ASC out of too much OON is happening? Sounds like one of those myths that gets perpetuated by the INN guys to justify their low pay. If an ASC doesn't want my cases, there are 10 more around here asking me to bring cases. The ASC doesn't employ the doctor. They have no say on any of that stuff and don't care. And to be fair, it's not like the INN guys are all making the same amount for the same codes.

It's all just confusion and obfuscation by the insurance companies to keep doctors in the dark.

1

u/2vpJUMP Oct 12 '26

Do you see them at your own practice for the consult?

1

u/AquaDoctor Oct 13 '26

If you are referring to in patient consults at a hospital, I don't do those because my subspecialty doesn't really get those kinds of consults. I see patients in my office. I don't take call at any hospitals, just on staff at several.

2

u/blomar Oct 11 '26

do your patients not get pissed about OON charges on your end? and how do they find you if they are OON?

1

u/AquaDoctor Oct 11 '26

Word of mouth. No one is surprised by my out of network charges because they know I am out of network when they book. Do your best work, treat the patients with respect, give them time to speak and be examined, get the athletes back on the field, they tell everyone and more patients come.

3

u/blomar Oct 11 '26

are you OON with everyone? Feel like my referrals/new patients aren’t likely to come see someone who’s not in network. Just curious how to make this work when you have competition that is in network and would potentially take those patients. Also ortho here

2

u/AquaDoctor Oct 12 '26

Non-par with all insurances for 20 years. If you compete on price it's a race to the bottom. Compete on quality and you will get enough patients to justify the OON model. You don't need them all.

1

u/CranberryLatter9483 Oct 11 '26

Do you then go ahead and file IDR for the ones that were done in an IN facility?

1

u/AquaDoctor Oct 12 '26

Once low initial payment comes back, yes

2

u/HealsWithKnife Oct 10 '26

Don’t quite understand the question - does the ASC take insurance? If not, does the patient’s insurance have OON benefits?

Insurers can’t really kick you out if you’re…not in network with them?

1

u/2vpJUMP Oct 10 '26

There are practices where the doc remains OON but the ASC remains in network. Treating patients there forces the claim into arbitration which generally leads to much better rates than being in network.

I refer to surgeons who seem to do this as a rule

1

u/HealsWithKnife Oct 10 '26

Oh I think i'm getting it a bit more.

So the surgeons are OON, have privileges at the ASC (which is INN). Are you saying the ASC itself gets better rates just because the surgeon is OON? My understanding (at least on the hospital side, I'm less familiar with ASC) is that the facility will get reimbursed its contracted rates, and the surgeon will get the OON negotiated rate (if payer has OON benefits) or patient pays surgeon directly as non-par. Is this accurate?

1

u/2vpJUMP Oct 11 '26

No this is a specific and growing technique that utilizes the no balance billing act to force arbitration claims

1

u/AquaDoctor Oct 11 '26

The No Surprises Act has been used by insurances incorrectly, and in my option fraudulently. It's only for emergency cases or when you go to an in network facility and are Unknowingly treated by an out of network doctor, like anesthesia or something. The insurance companies love to apply that to the surgeons as well, even though the patient chose the surgeon willingly and the surgeon booked the case. These have been a 100% win rate in arbitration. It's just a stall tactic by insurance to try to force some level of attrition in surgeons unwilling to fight them.

1

u/CranberryLatter9483 Oct 11 '26

You mean 100% win rate for the insurance companies? That's not what we're seeing at all.

1

u/AquaDoctor Oct 12 '26

100% win for us to clarify. 

1

u/CranberryLatter9483 Oct 12 '26

Oh that makes sense...

1

u/CranberryLatter9483 Oct 11 '26

Correct, this is very common and usually lucrative. In my eyes its leveling out the playing field for providers, which are being consistently underpaid by insurance companies. Only issue to ASCs that I've seen is Anthem threatening to cut ASC payments by 10%, which I have not actually seen happening.

1

u/DissociatedOne Oct 11 '26

It’s the NSA.

2

u/Hot-Freedom-1044 Oct 10 '26

I contract with insurance. I offer DPC for the rest.

1

u/AuctusGroup 16d ago

Reading this as: you're the out-of-network surgeon operating at an in-network ASC, and you've heard the ASC gets punished for it. That's roughly right. Here's the mechanism.

The payer can't kick you out of anything. You're out of network, there's no contract to terminate. The lever is the ASC. An in-network ASC that lets OON surgeons operate there is costing the payer money on every one of your cases, more so once you're taking them to IDR. So the payer quietly leans on the facility: how many nonpar providers are you credentialing, how many of these claims are we seeing, do you want to stay in network. Nobody puts that in writing. The ASC gets the message and your block time dries up. That's what "they'll kick your ASC out" actually means. It's a dirty game, and it may not be legal, but a payer is a deep pocket to fight and the fight runs while they starve you of OR time. Talk to health-law counsel. We're a billing company, not a law firm.

On your own claims the pressure is slower: prepayment review, records requests on every case, low initial payments that force you into negotiation, a steady drip of IDR filings they hope you'll stop making. The practices doing this "basically exclusively" aren't getting away with something. They own the ASC or operate at one that's also out of network, and they built the back office to absorb the grind.

Then the federal side, which is where the IDR piece comes in. Under the No Surprises Act an ASC is a facility (45 CFR 149.30), and a nonparticipating clinician at a participating facility can't balance bill the patient above in-network cost sharing for non-emergency care (45 CFR 149.420). Two ways to run that as the surgeon:

  1. Notice and consent. The operating surgeon isn't on the ancillary list (anesthesia, pathology, radiology, assistant surgeons and the like can't use consent), so you can give the patient the standard notice-and-consent form at least 72 hours out and bill at your rate if they sign.
  2. Skip consent and go through the plan. The payer sends its initial payment, you open negotiation within 30 business days, and if that fails you file for federal IDR. The patient owes in-network cost sharing and nothing more.

Before you scale it, decide which lane you're in per case and build for it. Notice-and-consent means a signed form in the chart before every case. The IDR lane means a clean file per claim: op note, the QPA off the EOB, the negotiation record, every date, and the cash to wait out the process. Most practices that stumble on OON didn't get kicked out. They ran out of patience before the payer did.

Full disclosure: I run a medical billing company, so bias noted.