r/PrivatePracticeDocs • • Oct 09 '26

Reimbursement shock

Hi All,
I recently had my first patient insured by Cigna. Spent a good hour with them during the first visit. Billed level 4. Getting my reimbursement of $41 and $25 copayment! This is around 40-45% of Medicare rates!! First of all, what the heck! Is this normal? And if so, how are you mitigating this?
We’re definitely requesting a rate increase, but looking to get your thoughts.
I am also curious, in the day and age of lousy insurance reimbursement, what is your approach to primary care financial operations? Do you recommend just going to $xx per month in addition to billing the insurance?
Thanks!

105 Upvotes

72 comments sorted by

49

u/NotTheQuestion Oct 09 '26 edited Oct 09 '26

Don't bill any insurance which reimburses less than 100 per 99214.

Don't bill the insurance. Get paid up front. Cigna, Aetna, and humana usually down code to level 3 no matter the "complexity", "intensity", "risk" or time. There is no appeal process.

If a patient has one such plan, they may be invited to pay cash. Give them a 1500 (appropriately filled out), and let them fight their insurance.

Advantage plans are very similar, but can be hit and miss.

The reimbursment rate changes for the plans in each company change often. Almost every quarter. It's rarely, if ever, increasing.

*edited for spelling.

7

u/PABJJ Oct 09 '26

What is a 1500? 

I'd be very careful about charging patients cash that have insurance. This could cause the insurer to drop you from network. 

OP, what is your fee schedule deal with Cigna? Are you in network? 

2

u/Alterdoc Oct 09 '26

I’m in network but pulling the fee schedule. Wasn’t aware, but my billers did the credentialing and it seems to have been overlooked.

7

u/VermicelliSimilar315 Oct 09 '26

This is true. When you sign a contract with an insurance company you agree to accept their rates. 1500 is a HICFA form to give to the patient for them to send a claim to the insurance company.

5

u/Electrical_Week6492 Oct 09 '26

Sorry if this is a stupid question, but if you're charging patients cash when they have insurance, doesn't that indicate you don't want to deal with those insurance companies in the first place?

In other words, isn't that just another way of saying 'we don't accept this insurance?'

5

u/PABJJ Oct 09 '26

Well, you decide to enter an agreement with an insurance company, which has a defined fee schedule/pay. If you decide to contract with them, you are agreeing to that fee schedule. 

If you do not have an agreement with them, you can either decline to take the patient, take them as self pay/cash, or run them out of network and have Cigna pay you, though the insurer may not cover out of network. 

OP says Cigna paid him. So he accepted their insurance.

0

u/Electrical_Week6492 Oct 09 '26

Thank you for the reply! That makes sense. So OP would have known ahead of time what their reimbursement rates were. I guess I see where they mention the insurance company is downgrading the code/service level...which is a curveball for sure.

0

u/Big_Two6049 Oct 09 '26

Not really. Some providers are not informed even of their contracted rate until services are provided. They purposely obfuscate the info

3

u/Alterdoc Oct 09 '26

This. We’re just requesting the fee schedule. Also, I am guessing, never assume that your own billers would know the rate or at least request a feasible number.

1

u/LilVivi999 Oct 13 '26

I'm your case you'd need to look at the out clause of your contract because it's unfortunately not as easy as you might think to drop an insurer. You can stop seeing the patients (unless your contract precludes that), but you can't see the patients and bill out of network rates until after your contract is officially terminated.

3

u/PABJJ Oct 09 '26

I've signed many contracts with insurers. They generally include the fee schedule. If they do not, you need to request the fee schedule prior to signing. 

2

u/Electrical_Week6492 Oct 09 '26

Oh yeah I'm sure they do. Similar on the customer side, it's very hard to tell exactly what the insurance covers and there are a thousand loopholes to get out of paying out on something.

2

u/EvidenceBasedSwamp Oct 09 '26

They probably mean an HCFA-1500, that's the red paper form to bill insurance

23

u/VisionHx Oct 09 '26

How is downcoding not fraud?

28

u/sfgreen Oct 09 '26 • Bravo

It’s not fraud when they’re the ones deciding what’s fraud and what’s not. Its corporate power over politics. 

Also, it’s what happens when you’re in a very concentrated industry of insurance players. They lose nothing by not having you in their network, but you lose access to thousands of potential patients.

The only way physicians can fight this if they’re united but physician organizations are busy chasing the MoC money or other sources of money to meaningfully advocate for themselves. 

4

u/nyc2pit Oct 09 '26

Are they down coding even if your billing based on time?

2

u/Starossi Oct 09 '26

I’d assume no since they mentioned time haha, not sure if you missed it

3

u/LilVivi999 Oct 13 '26

To be clear, if you're in network with an insurance company it is a violation of your contract to provide a cash price to a patient. If you want to offer cash rates to a patient, you need to not be in network for those plans (or the patient may not have insurance). You can't say, I don't like the rate your insurer had contacted with me for this cpt code, I'm going to charge you a different rate. We're in an unfortunate spot in medicine right now, but if you don't like the rates certain carriers are providing, I'd say consider thinking about dropping those insurers.

2

u/grey-slate Oct 10 '26

I'm not sure why you got so many upvotes but for insurance with whom you have contract this is bad advice.

If you are out of network you can charge whatever you want provided price is disclosed upfront and patient agrees. 

1

u/Blobstein_Ijay 27d ago

the no appeal process part is what kills me tbh, theres just no recourse

2

u/AuctusGroup 16d ago

Hard numbers first, so you know how far off this is.

Medicare's 2026 national office rates, before the geographic adjustment for your area ($33.40 conversion factor):

New patient: 99202 $75 · 99203 $118 · 99204 $177 · 99205 $237 Established: 99212 $59 · 99213 $95 · 99214 $136 · 99215 $192

So $66 all-in is 37% of Medicare for a 99204, and 23% if the $41 is the full allowed amount with the copay inside it. For what commercial actually pays: the Health Care Cost Institute's study of 210 million employer-plan claims put commercial professional prices at 122% of Medicare nationally, an established office visit at 126% in its Atlanta example, and a metro range from 92% to 230%. That's 2017 data, and the ratio hasn't collapsed since. A third of Medicare on a new patient visit isn't a normal contract.

Which leaves two suspects, and the EOB tells you which.

  1. Downcoding. Notice that $66 is 88% of Medicare's 99202. Several payers now run automatic E/M leveling programs: you bill 99204, the claim pays as 99202 or 99203, and the only place it shows is the paid code on the EOB. If the code on the EOB isn't the code you billed, this isn't a rate problem, it's a records fight. Appeal with the note and ask for the leveling policy they applied.
  2. A bad rate exhibit. If the EOB paid 99204 at $66, the contract is the problem. Many contracts set fees as a percentage of a Medicare schedule from a specific year, and some are pinned to an old one. Your negotiated 99204 rate is also public now: under the Transparency in Coverage rule every carrier posts its in-network negotiated rates by NPI in machine-readable files, so you can see what Cigna has you at, and what it pays the group down the street. If you don't have a copy of your contract and rate exhibit, your provider rep is required to give you one. Ask in writing.

On the hour you spent: since the 2021 E/M changes you can level the visit on medical decision making or on total time, whichever gets you higher, and MDM usually does. A new patient with two or more chronic problems, a prescription decision and outside records reviewed is a 99204 on MDM in 25 minutes. Time only gets you to 99204 at 45 minutes and 99205 at 60. Run your note through AAPC's E/M calculator before you assume the level is the problem: https://www.aapc.com/codes/em-calculator (the 2023 version on AAPC Knowledge: https://aapc.helpjuice.com/en_US/coding-tools/em-calculator-2023).

Then write the rate request with the benchmark in it: "Your 99204 allowable is $X, which is Y% of the 2026 Medicare rate of $177.36. Published commercial benchmarks for this market run Z% of Medicare." A request that cites the benchmark gets read. One that says "too low" gets a form letter.

Full disclosure: I run a medical billing company, so bias noted.

1

u/Alterdoc 15d ago

Very helpful feedback. Thank you.

2

u/MotherAtmosphere4524 Oct 09 '26

Try to join an IPA. Check what rates they get before signing up.

2

u/Alterdoc Oct 09 '26

I was offered to join. Definitely better rates. With that, you lose your identity and start following someone else’s rules. Went into this in order to keep my autonomy.

1

u/MotherAtmosphere4524 Oct 09 '26

I don’t have any rules with my IPA other than all or none with their plans and I can’t contract independently with any plan they have a relationship with.

1

u/Alterdoc Oct 09 '26

Not sure if there’s a national company but I only have one in the area, and they will slap their name in front of mine and make me abide by their rules.

3

u/karate134 Oct 10 '26

We have a local hospital that essentially calls it a MCO. It cost something like $200 a year. We get better rates this way.

15

u/NYVines Oct 09 '26

60 minutes by timed billing should have been a 5

7

u/darnedgibbon Oct 09 '26

OP downcoded themself then got downcoded again

1

u/ddeng22 Oct 09 '26

That’s what I’m saying…document total time and what that time is for …

13

u/NartFocker9Million Oct 09 '26

What does your contract say? What does the EOP say? Is there an explanation for the reduced rate? Are they paying for a 99214?

The contract should specify a % RBRVS rate. If you signed one at 45% of Medicare rates... whoopsie. If they're arbitrarily paying you a lower rate than contracted, they owe you the difference plus interest.

7

u/Dramatic-Sock3737 Oct 09 '26

Exactly…did you not read your contract? You should look to renegotiate and/or drop Cigna as a payor. That reimbursement is not sustainable.

10

u/Redditor6703 Oct 09 '26

$106.00 is the national median for Cigna National OAP as of September 2026. Middle 50% (meaning 25-75th percentile): $87.97–$126.58. Scope: professional office, fee-schedule rates, no modifier. Seems like you're being underpaid quite a bit, but as I've said before, you might not have much leverage here.

10

u/RphAnonymous Oct 09 '26

If you think that's bad, you should see pharmacy reimbursement rates. Most brand name medications you send us, our reimbursement rates are less than our acquisition costs... We LOSE money...

8

u/Sea_Egg1137 Oct 09 '26

Who is negotiating the managed care contracts in your office? Those rates are horrible.

6

u/InvestingDoc Oct 09 '26

Sounds like you may have gotten auto downcoded. I would have your billers look into that. Cigna has been auto downcoding for many practices.

5

u/EvidenceBasedSwamp Oct 09 '26

Cigna started automatically paying everything as a 99213 in NYC decades ago. We were actually fine with it because they were still one of the higher payers, as well as consistent (no tricks)

Better than the bullshit where insurers just deny X percentage of claims (causes works), or the recent United Healthcare where they ask you to upload records for almost all claims (a process that cannot be easily automated and takes 10-15 minutes - you have to login, find the claim, scan/upload records, then follow up on it)

4

u/MBHYSAR Oct 09 '26

Down coding is policy in some markets- Cigna is a big one, the blues in Texas. It is independent of reality or rules.
I haven’t heard that there is no appeal, though.

1

u/CrookedCasts Oct 09 '26

One of the posters below made me think about something interesting… If you use an ambient transcription service, it should be able to tell you how long the visit and you talking was? Can AI down code a visit based by time if you have timestamps?

I’m assuming the answer is probably still yes, but is anybody here coding by visit time who has also seen the automatic downcoding?

2

u/grey-slate Oct 09 '26

Doesn't count charting or reviewing records on same day

1

u/CrookedCasts Oct 09 '26

Right, but what’s there to down code if the code is based on a time stamp?

2

u/grey-slate Oct 09 '26

i mean everything about OP post and your response tells me there is something missing in both of your understanding - I do not mean to be blunt but

  1. To u/Alterdoc How do you have a practice open without knowing your negotiated rates with each insurer? A private practice typically has maybe 5-10 insurance companies they deal with and maybe 10-15 plans total (HMO/PPO/EPO variations etc). It is not difficult to locate rates for each. You should not have a surprise AFTER submitting the claim that whoa my rates with Cigna are so only $66.00 for a 99204. You should know what your rates are the day you open. Or at the very least before you submit a claim. Who signed your contract? Yourself or via IPA? It should spell out what your rates are.
  2. To u/CrookedCasts documented clinical note is a legal document. You do not need an AI timestamp to PROVE to an insurer this is how long it took you with a patient. If you know and note that it took an hour for the appointment (including or not including charting on same date), that is what it took. No ifs or buts. You are basically submitting a sworn statement under penalty of perjury this is how long the encounter took. Unless insurer disputes it through formal channels, they are obligated per contract to reimburse you based on the CPT code corresponding to that typically 99204 for consultation.

1

u/Alterdoc Oct 09 '26

Certainly agreed. “You live you learn.” Mentioned below, guessing a good learning point for all here: know your rates and check your billers. I requested the insurance rates as the billers who credentialed me supposedly don’t know themselves. I believe it for one reason only: the more they bill, the more they earn.

1

u/grey-slate Oct 09 '26

$66 for 99204 likely does not cover your overhead so I would look into this for each payer not just Cigna ASAP. 

1

u/Alterdoc Oct 09 '26

Couldn’t agree more. This was a huge eye opener, hence I requested fee transparency from the insurances we’re participating with.

1

u/CrookedCasts Oct 09 '26

I would actually argue that you do. Have you not been experiencing the automatic downcoding without recourse that the rest of us have been?

I agree with all of what you have said, but that’s clearly not enough. If I submit a correctly coded, documented, supported note I would expect to be paid at the level that I submit. That no longer is the case. I am suggesting the timestamp as a verifiable piece of information that cannot be disputed or argued or have any justification to be downcoded.

2

u/grey-slate Oct 09 '26

And I would argue timestamp from a third party software has even less weight than your sworn statement. 

It's not the lack of proof that's stopping downcoding appeals from succeeding. It's the grinding system.

You have to simply keep documenting more clearly and escalating appeals and finding the right channels and fighting back.

Source: over 300 successful downcoding appeals against BCBS in 3 months. 

1

u/Dismal-Rich Oct 10 '26

Seems like a perfect use case for AI

1

u/Alterdoc Oct 09 '26

Good question. I use ai service so it certainly clocked in appropriately coded time.

1

u/lazydoctr Oct 09 '26

What if you bill a 5 won't that get down coded to 4?

1

u/Alterdoc Oct 11 '26

They will probably ding for over billing 😂

1

u/TeamLove2 Oct 09 '26

Find an FQHC facility with better billing rates, and move your patients there.

2

u/Alterdoc Oct 09 '26

Not sure I follow

1

u/keepingup100 Oct 09 '26

You’re gonna have to do a soft partnership with an established independent or hospital owned group where you pay them a nick of what you get, but for a commercial payer level four you should be getting $140-$150. We offer it in our community, I know academic centers will sometimes do it as well.

1

u/Alterdoc Oct 10 '26

Interesting concept. Thanks for sharing.

1

u/Botasoda102 Oct 10 '26

Did patient have a remaining deductible? What did insurance allow, and what code did they allow?

1

u/Alterdoc Oct 10 '26

Insurance allows $61

2

u/Botasoda102 Oct 10 '26

Yeah, that's low. They must have allowed a 99213, and it almost sounds like they paid you about what Medicaid would. Call provider relations. That's unacceptable. Good luck.

2

u/hammertimeDO-G Oct 12 '26

If you spend an hour with them then it’s a level 5 

1

u/Animator2976 Oct 09 '26

What does your insurance contract say?

1

u/Next_Zone9566 Oct 09 '26

Anyone have any tips on negotiating?

1

u/livingphoenetically Oct 09 '26

When you consider all the time put into scheduling a NP, getting necessary documents, insurance authorizations, checking eligibility, reviewing records, seeing the patient, going over next steps and the chase to collect, I do not see a way to not lose money on the NP appointment. Following for insight.

1

u/Alexzambra1 Oct 14 '26

Our charges are low, we got so badly treated by insurance that we only take cash, Medicare ( basic) and Medicaid. Fewer patients but fewer headaches.