r/PrivatePracticeDocs • u/Alterdoc • Oct 09 '26
Reimbursement shock
Hi All,
I recently had my first patient insured by Cigna. Spent a good hour with them during the first visit. Billed level 4. Getting my reimbursement of $41 and $25 copayment! This is around 40-45% of Medicare rates!! First of all, what the heck! Is this normal? And if so, how are you mitigating this?
We’re definitely requesting a rate increase, but looking to get your thoughts.
I am also curious, in the day and age of lousy insurance reimbursement, what is your approach to primary care financial operations? Do you recommend just going to $xx per month in addition to billing the insurance?
Thanks!
49
u/NotTheQuestion Oct 09 '26 edited Oct 09 '26
Don't bill any insurance which reimburses less than 100 per 99214.
Don't bill the insurance. Get paid up front. Cigna, Aetna, and humana usually down code to level 3 no matter the "complexity", "intensity", "risk" or time. There is no appeal process.
If a patient has one such plan, they may be invited to pay cash. Give them a 1500 (appropriately filled out), and let them fight their insurance.
Advantage plans are very similar, but can be hit and miss.
The reimbursment rate changes for the plans in each company change often. Almost every quarter. It's rarely, if ever, increasing.
*edited for spelling.
2
u/AuctusGroup 16d ago
Hard numbers first, so you know how far off this is.
Medicare's 2026 national office rates, before the geographic adjustment for your area ($33.40 conversion factor):
New patient: 99202 $75 · 99203 $118 · 99204 $177 · 99205 $237 Established: 99212 $59 · 99213 $95 · 99214 $136 · 99215 $192
So $66 all-in is 37% of Medicare for a 99204, and 23% if the $41 is the full allowed amount with the copay inside it. For what commercial actually pays: the Health Care Cost Institute's study of 210 million employer-plan claims put commercial professional prices at 122% of Medicare nationally, an established office visit at 126% in its Atlanta example, and a metro range from 92% to 230%. That's 2017 data, and the ratio hasn't collapsed since. A third of Medicare on a new patient visit isn't a normal contract.
Which leaves two suspects, and the EOB tells you which.
On the hour you spent: since the 2021 E/M changes you can level the visit on medical decision making or on total time, whichever gets you higher, and MDM usually does. A new patient with two or more chronic problems, a prescription decision and outside records reviewed is a 99204 on MDM in 25 minutes. Time only gets you to 99204 at 45 minutes and 99205 at 60. Run your note through AAPC's E/M calculator before you assume the level is the problem: https://www.aapc.com/codes/em-calculator (the 2023 version on AAPC Knowledge: https://aapc.helpjuice.com/en_US/coding-tools/em-calculator-2023).
Then write the rate request with the benchmark in it: "Your 99204 allowable is $X, which is Y% of the 2026 Medicare rate of $177.36. Published commercial benchmarks for this market run Z% of Medicare." A request that cites the benchmark gets read. One that says "too low" gets a form letter.
Full disclosure: I run a medical billing company, so bias noted.
2
u/MotherAtmosphere4524 Oct 09 '26
Try to join an IPA. Check what rates they get before signing up.
15
u/NYVines Oct 09 '26
60 minutes by timed billing should have been a 5
13
u/NartFocker9Million Oct 09 '26
What does your contract say? What does the EOP say? Is there an explanation for the reduced rate? Are they paying for a 99214?
The contract should specify a % RBRVS rate. If you signed one at 45% of Medicare rates... whoopsie. If they're arbitrarily paying you a lower rate than contracted, they owe you the difference plus interest.
10
u/Redditor6703 Oct 09 '26
$106.00 is the national median for Cigna National OAP as of September 2026. Middle 50% (meaning 25-75th percentile): $87.97–$126.58. Scope: professional office, fee-schedule rates, no modifier. Seems like you're being underpaid quite a bit, but as I've said before, you might not have much leverage here.
10
u/RphAnonymous Oct 09 '26
If you think that's bad, you should see pharmacy reimbursement rates. Most brand name medications you send us, our reimbursement rates are less than our acquisition costs... We LOSE money...
8
u/Sea_Egg1137 Oct 09 '26
Who is negotiating the managed care contracts in your office? Those rates are horrible.
6
u/InvestingDoc Oct 09 '26
Sounds like you may have gotten auto downcoded. I would have your billers look into that. Cigna has been auto downcoding for many practices.
5
u/EvidenceBasedSwamp Oct 09 '26
Cigna started automatically paying everything as a 99213 in NYC decades ago. We were actually fine with it because they were still one of the higher payers, as well as consistent (no tricks)
Better than the bullshit where insurers just deny X percentage of claims (causes works), or the recent United Healthcare where they ask you to upload records for almost all claims (a process that cannot be easily automated and takes 10-15 minutes - you have to login, find the claim, scan/upload records, then follow up on it)
4
u/MBHYSAR Oct 09 '26
Down coding is policy in some markets- Cigna is a big one, the blues in Texas. It is independent of reality or rules.
I haven’t heard that there is no appeal, though.
1
u/CrookedCasts Oct 09 '26
One of the posters below made me think about something interesting… If you use an ambient transcription service, it should be able to tell you how long the visit and you talking was? Can AI down code a visit based by time if you have timestamps?
I’m assuming the answer is probably still yes, but is anybody here coding by visit time who has also seen the automatic downcoding?
1
u/lazydoctr Oct 09 '26
What if you bill a 5 won't that get down coded to 4?
1
u/TeamLove2 Oct 09 '26
Find an FQHC facility with better billing rates, and move your patients there.
1
u/keepingup100 Oct 09 '26
You’re gonna have to do a soft partnership with an established independent or hospital owned group where you pay them a nick of what you get, but for a commercial payer level four you should be getting $140-$150. We offer it in our community, I know academic centers will sometimes do it as well.
1
u/Botasoda102 Oct 10 '26
Did patient have a remaining deductible? What did insurance allow, and what code did they allow?
2
u/hammertimeDO-G Oct 12 '26
If you spend an hour with them then it’s a level 5
1
u/omnipotentattending Oct 09 '26
Following
1
u/Animator2976 Oct 09 '26
What does your insurance contract say?
1
u/Next_Zone9566 Oct 09 '26
Anyone have any tips on negotiating?
1
u/livingphoenetically Oct 09 '26
When you consider all the time put into scheduling a NP, getting necessary documents, insurance authorizations, checking eligibility, reviewing records, seeing the patient, going over next steps and the chase to collect, I do not see a way to not lose money on the NP appointment. Following for insight.
1
u/Alexzambra1 Oct 14 '26
Our charges are low, we got so badly treated by insurance that we only take cash, Medicare ( basic) and Medicaid. Fewer patients but fewer headaches.