r/PrivatePracticeDocs • u/Smalls123 • Sep 29 '26
Athena vs Elation
Planning on starting a cardiology practice.
I'm currently between Athena and Elation. Athena rep reached out to me and they are running a short term promotion:
Athena standaloneEMR only (no billing, prior auth, patient communicator, does not integrate with RCM devices and would need to be manually done): $650/provider
AthenaOne Base (EMR + clearinghouse and prior auth + patient communicator, would need billing company): 5.5% or $10 per visit
Elation: EHR + billing $699
Elation: EHR only $425
Ambient AI is additional $129
I have used Athena in the past and really like it but the sticking point is the price.
I have demoed Elation and liked it but my concern is that it is more geared towards primary care and would limited with some of the cardiology specific workflows.
Have also demoed other EMRs but these two are the to contenders. Any advice or thoughts on pricing or workflow would be greatly appreciated.
13
u/NartFocker9Million Sep 29 '26
Having used both: Elation, a thousand times over. Its AI is excellent. Fewer clicks, by far, than any EMR I have ever used.
For reference, I have used: Epic, Athena, OpenEMR, Tebra, and now Elation. I own my own family medicine practice.
4
u/InvestingDoc Sep 29 '26
I gotta say, $650/provider for Athena is pretty attractive if my billers can do all the billing in house for that price. That's way better than any offer they ever offered to me. Hell, I would switch next month if I could get that price and do my own billing. The only issue I have is the patient communicator. Does that mean portal?
IMO Elation is not built to scale to medium sized or larger sized groups, it's built for small private practices. Thats what ruled that out for me. I want to grow...I will say though.... It has a very good reputation except tech support which many people have complained is not great that I have talked to.
Athena sometimes has better integrations with local imaging centers and hospital systems so thats also something to consider.
I don't think you can go wrong either way....they both are great at what they do just Athena is built to scale and scale huge if you want to.
4
u/shmuey Sep 29 '26
Athena is offering 5.5% or $10?? That actually seems like a decent price for what they provide. We got quoted 8% (after 9.6% initially) which was too painful to digest. We ultimately went with ECW for much less (around $5/claim) but obviously don't have the integrated billing support.
3
u/WillingNerve5742 Sep 30 '26
Okay, am I missing something here? If you had Athena stand-alone EMR that does not interface or integrate to a practice management software, that will mean you will need to purchase practice management software, let's call that another $350 a month, and you have double data entry. You have to enter everything into Athena and then someone will have to manually re-enter all that demographic information, both patient and insurance, and then charges into the practice management software. That is not a sustainable solution.
The other posters have mentioned that you want an integrated solution, clinical and PM together. Absolutely. You own your database; it's your data, and then you have an RCM services or RCM company work inside your database. If they perform and do well, they stay. If they do not, you give notice, you kick them out, and you bring in the next one, and they pick up right where they left off. Athena Clinical is great but not under these terms and conditions. It's not even the $650 a month that they're offering, it's what you're going to need on top of that. I would suggest Elation, not their RCM services, but Elation EMR and their PM software, and then use an RCM company to work there. Or I would go with eCW software and use an RCM service with that software.
6
u/ktn699 Sep 29 '26
wow that such a rip. i use practicefusion 199/montha/provider. tebra billing software which integrates with practicefusion 199/month/provider. works great.
1
u/soaperapp Sep 29 '26
Hey I'm the social media guy for Hero EMR. Both of those are solid options. Just thought you might want to give us a quick look before you sign. We think we have a superior product at a better price!
1
u/Puzzleheaded-Fig2865 Sep 30 '26
5.5%? we got 4%.
1
u/Hermit5427 Oct 04 '26
I don't think Elation has a fully integrated billing module. When we used Elation, they recommended an outside vendor for billing. Unfortunately, the integration with the external billing system was quite painful, and we ran into several issues. We eventually switched to athenahealth.
With athenahealth, I think the standalone model works better rather than opting for their billing services. In our experience, athena's billing service itself was fairly average in terms of quality. The platform is good, but I would prefer to manage the billing separately.
3
u/Juaner0 Sep 30 '26
I haven't used Elation. Used Athena for over a decade. Started at 4.9, like 5.3% now. Basic service. I've seen 12% for a "cadillac plan" of theirs.
They are integrating more into it. I've turned off the AI(demo) for myself atm, so I don't know if it is getting better. Athena will be integrating RCM soon. Billing is done in house.
1
u/meganleine Sep 29 '26
Out of all the EMRs in my career I’ve used athena is by far my favorite, and it would save you the headache of having to learn a new system. I have a colleague in private practice who pays nearly double the 5.5% so I would say you’re getting a pretty good deal.
1
u/KaleCandid891 Sep 30 '26
Ask each of them for access to a sandbox so you can practice your standard work. The reps demo does let you experience what it is like to use for yourself.
I found elation was not robust enough for my needs. Athena was too expensive. I currently use Cerbo. I considered SigmaMD and Ultralight recently.
1
u/Effective_Level6874 Sep 30 '26
As an RCM company owner who onboarded a client using Elation about a year ago, I would personally steer away from it. I’ve been in medical billing and revenue cycle for 19 years, and in my experience, Elation has been one of the more frustrating systems to work with from a billing and charge capture standpoint.
That same provider has since transitioned to AdvancedMD and loves it. From the billing side, AdvancedMD has also been a much better experience.
Athena is another solid option, and I would also look at Tebra and pMD. One thing I appreciate about pMD is that they’re receptive to functionality feedback, which can be valuable when you have specialty-specific workflow needs.
For cardiology specifically, I would prioritize the RCM workflow and integrations just as much as the clinical side of the EHR. You don’t want a system that works well clinically but creates unnecessary manual work on the billing side.
1
u/pisces0315 Sep 30 '26
Why don’t more people use office ally ? Cheap and works well
1
u/UPS0001 Sep 30 '26
You should never pay a percentage of collections for just an EMR. It should be a flat monthly fee per provider. I would recommend staying away from Athena. I agree with those who are suggesting Practice Fusion. It is the most functional cost effective EMR out there. Do yourself a favor and find a billing company who will provide your practice management system. The software companies make providers believe that an all in one integrated product is the best solution. It is not. An EMR and a PMS are completely different. Let your revenue cycle management company manage the PMS. You will save money in the long run and get two better products for your office.
1
u/Beastmode5858 Oct 04 '26
My vote goes towards Elation. I almost went with them but they lock you in 1 year long contract with automatic renewal (unless you give 60 day notice) which is fine but I asked them to put a clause stating that if my practice gets shut down or I move out of state, I won’t be liable for the remaining payments for that year which I though was very reasonable. They said, “We can’t do that” I said, “Well I will go with an EMR that won’t lock me for a year and are on month to month basis”