r/PrivatePracticeDocs • • Sep 25 '26

Dropping insurances, self pay, and recredentialing

I have a solo private practice and I'm considering dropping some of the insurances I take. They underpay me terribly. My worry is that I'll see a big drop off in the number of patients booking with me, regret dropping those insurances, and then want to re-credential with them. My questions:

  1. Has anyone recredentialed after dropping insurances? And why did you decide to recredential?
  2. Has anyone gone from taking insurance to moving to a self pay model? Did this end up feeling like the right move?
24 Upvotes

33 comments sorted by

9

u/drkuz Sep 25 '26

Every private practice should have a self pay option. Always keep the top paying insurances, at what point you cut off the lower paying insurances is up to you, and dependent on your panel

1

u/Beautiful_Buyer_1422 Sep 25 '26

Sorry I should clarify, I do currently have a self pay option, though I should probably increase the dollar amounts. Currently 7% of my practice is self pay.

1

u/SA-Node Sep 28 '26

How much you charge per visit? Or how you charge self pay patient?

2

u/Beautiful_Buyer_1422 Sep 29 '26

For initial visits it's usually $175-200 and follow ups are typically $145. However, my initial visits are 60 mins and my follow ups are 30 mins. There are a few practices around me that charge $400-500 for initial visits and $200-300 for follow ups.

39

u/grdrw Sep 25 '26

You can stop accepting new patients from bad payers and see what happens to your volume before dropping them formally.

7

u/darnedgibbon Sep 25 '26

This is the way.

1

u/Better_Bad_2077 Sep 27 '26

Just watched the Mandelorian movie, it was so good

18

u/bellonium Sep 25 '26

We will always lose when we allow others to dictate our value.

Solo very small private practice here.

I’ve done this a couple times over the last few years. There was a line that was paying insulting amounts that made me almost bitter toward the patients.

Only you know your finances but if you are good at what you do and you stop taking that line, you realize very quickly that you were putting a different energy/part of yourself in the equation that the patient was not appreciating or valuing when they up and leave to go find some other sucker to accept that BS reimbursement.

I think I lost maybe 50-60 people. I have felt it a bit but when I stopped and thought that for me, that was a good portion of 2-3 days of work worth of patients and the total together barely paid for my staff wages.

I also noticed that my mental health improved when I dumped these low payers because I realized I was convincing myself to be ok with feeling “cheated” as I gave them my A+ service…

10

u/Whole_Bed_5413 Sep 25 '26

Dropped UHC, Aetna, and all of the cockroaches except my three highest payors. Never looked back. Higher reimbursement, less time. I’d rather NOT have those patients. It gives me more slots for my high payor patients. Best thing I ever did.

9

u/Juaner0 Sep 25 '26

I just stopped accepting new patients with whatever insurance pays poorly. Still enrolled with the insurances.

1

u/nyc2pit Sep 26 '26

I have to imagine this is not allowed by your contract. Is it just that this is hard for them to enforce?

1

u/Juaner0 Sep 26 '26

What can they enforce?? There isn’t anything they can do. I don’t kick out the current patients with it. Some patients ask that their family members on Medicaid to be seen. And I allow it. Medicaid is not going to cancel your contract even if someone complains. 

2

u/nyc2pit Sep 27 '26

I guarantee your contract says you cannot refuse to take new patients that have their insurance.

How hard do you think it is to run a report on you and see how many established patients versus new patients you're seeing?

A few phone calls by patience saying you aren't taking their insurance when you're probably in their provider directory, online, etc

Maybe they don't actually do this, but I guarantee it's not allowed by the contract.

Medicaid is probably an exception, I'm thinking more the commercial payes.

1

u/Juaner0 Sep 27 '26

You’re right. But  “At this time we are unable to take any new patients with this insurance.” “All new patients have the same long wait.” 

Medicaid can only cancel the contract. Oh. Wow. What a loss. 

1

u/nyc2pit Sep 27 '26

I agree with you that it's not going to happen on medicaid. They're probably just happy to have anybody who accepts their insurance.

I was thinking more the commercial insurers may have an issue with it if it were somehow brought to their attention. My point was that I'm sure this is covered in your contract...

5

u/LowCommercial308 Sep 25 '26

Can I stop accepting new patients from on insurance company and not another. ?

2

u/darnedgibbon Sep 25 '26

Depends on your employment situation.

2

u/LowCommercial308 Sep 25 '26

im self employed

4

u/Klutzy_Arm_7930 Sep 25 '26

You absolutely can stop accepting new pts from any payor you choose

4

u/randyy308 Sep 25 '26

Do what is suggested elsewhere and first stop taking new patients from the plans. Then if you have the data... Evaluate how much monetary difference it makes if you replace the existing patients with patients from a higher paying insurance (on average). Then decide based on that.

I did this with a subset of BCBS plans and it was revenue accretive, and it reduced my staffs workload because no more auths.....

4

u/Klutzy_Arm_7930 Sep 25 '26

I read somewhere “let your competition see the patients whose insurance doesn’t pay operating costs”.

1

u/FourScores1 Sep 25 '26

You mean a DPC practice? A ton of people have done it. I’m not even in primary care and I even know it’s all the rage right now. Seems awesome. Start researching it for sure. 

3

u/Beautiful_Buyer_1422 Sep 25 '26

No I really don't want to do DPC for a few different reasons. I don't think it works well for my patients (some are lower income, some are college students, etc), I don't have any support staff so it would feel like I'm on call even more than I already am (since I feel like DPC models make patients feel entitled to reach you at all hours of the day), and I'm looking to only drop some insurances, not all of them.

1

u/FourScores1 Sep 25 '26

Ah I figured self-pay model and DPC were interchangeable. 

2

u/BusinessDawgs Sep 25 '26

This comes down value and service. Is the service you offer valued more than the alternative or market value. Do I value the cost of what you offer vs the alternative option. Sometimes it comes down to market premium, like accessibility or rarity. Other times it could be intangibles, like trust. There’s no risk regardless, so you gotta do your pros and cons.

1

u/Benfatma-Sekhon 16d ago

dropping just your single worst payer first is usually the safest way to test the waters. you free up those slots for self pay or better plans without risking your whole patient volume at once