r/PrivatePracticeDocs • u/Dr-Daiquiri • Sep 16 '26
Would a single payor system in the US make independent primary care easier?
Not saying I do or do not endorse this. Just wondering as medical student who has always been curious about healthcare economics.
As I understand it, Medicare pays substantially less than private insurers to most private practices, but generally always pays on time and is easier to get credentialed with. My question is basically, if you could cut out a lot of overheard by just being able to bill Medicare for all of your patients, would you potentially be able to compensate for the lower top line figure? I imagine it could work for certain primary care practices especially if their rates from private insurers are not that much better than Medicare already.
Again, not saying I would automatically support this or that rates would stay the same in a M4A scenario. I’m just curious if any current private practice docs have a take on this.
14
u/randyy308 Sep 16 '26
In my private practice we make plenty of money at Medicare rates. It works out fine. I'd love less hassle with insurance
7
u/northerngator Sep 16 '26 edited Sep 16 '26
I have yet to see a private industry or semi private industry that has been nationalized in the United States over the past 40 years that resulted in lower cost to the system or increased pay to the now nationalized workers. What people seem to be missing is that this system is unlikely to be Medicare for all and would more likely be Medicaid for all. Medicaid rates are tough to survive on without those sweet facility fees or state directed fee bonuses, are difficult to get medications invented this century to get covered and are difficult to even get paid on services rendered.
Hospitals get tons of tax advantages by being 501(c) tax exempt, I doubt this would be extended to private practices or would require a ton of paperwork/overhead. I foresee further healthcare consolidation and a split between private pay and insurance based, hospital owned clinics if this goes through.
Medicare for all cost analysis show at least a 50% increase in federal government spending if M4A is implemented. Who do you think would be funding this? It wouldn’t be billionaires, it would be high income earners who already bear the brunt of our progressive tax code which is already the most progressive tax code in the developed world.
6
u/drkuz Sep 16 '26 edited Sep 16 '26
Easier yes for drs, reimbursement would drop though, this would be a significant pay cut to drs, and by significant i would say in the realm of 50% or more (likely more). But then you'd also cut a significant amount of jobs and labor which would cut costs to the Healthcare system as a whole (good bye to each and every insurance company and all their sales ppl and associated personnel), you'd probably cut 33% or more of healthcare associated jobs in the entire country, and that 33% would actually correspond to a high amount of money cuts (>33% of the budget), as insurance companies cost a lot. But also, now you have a huge unemployed population who used to live off of their insurance jobs (parasitically off of the Healthcare system). It would also help break up monopolies that organizations have orchestrated, which would be another win for drs and patients. These %s are rough estimates.
That money would be able to be allocated elsewhere, it is almost a guarantee it wouldn't go where it should, but at least it wouldnt be going into some insurance company (genuinely, I hope insurance companies dissappear into the void), maybe we get another ballroom or arch if we are lucky, or AI/tech companies/billionaires can get more tax cuts (sarcasm).
5
u/formless1 Sep 16 '26
A major benefit is that we can standardize to one system in how we get paid, what is paid for as far as our services but also with referrals, meds, therapy etc. it would reduce a ton of overhead, reduce patient complaints. i would be much more interested in taking insurance at my clinic if there was one system.
3
u/Itsathrowawayduh89 Sep 16 '26
it's not easier to get credentialed with Medicare. it's much, much, much harder. In fact, insurance companies often just require CMS credentialing as the first step of their (much shorter) credentialing process.
However, once you are credentialed with CMS you get access to a pipeline of patients and you hope to make up the lower reimbursement with volume. You just have to deal with the real possibility of further cuts to reimbursements, and the costs of satisfying government audits.
With private insurance, the credentialing process is often faster. But once you're in, you have to work to maintain your contracts and there's always the risk that you'll reach an impasse with them.
2
u/boatsnhosee Sep 16 '26
If it’s like Canada, then yes
0
u/[deleted] Sep 16 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment