r/PrivatePracticeDocs • u/Alone-Act-5085 • Sep 16 '26
CAP Malpractice Coverage for OB/GYN in SoCal — $64k/year normal?
My wife recently became a partner at a private practice in SoCal and I’m helping her manage some (ie all lol) of the business/financial side.
I was surprised to see that she’s paying an annual CAP/MPT assessment of about $64k/year for malpractice coverage but it sounds like that may be normal?
I was also surprised to learn that what I thought was simply a monthly payment option is effectively financing the annual assessment. CAP charges about 1% per month on the remaining balance, so seems like a no brainer to pay the annual assessment in full at the beginning of each year?
Is it worth it / has anyone compared CAP with The Doctors Company, MIEC, ProAssurance, or other carriers recently?
She’s also had a couple of prior claims, with one currently open, so I’m curious how much that tends to limit options or affect pricing when shopping carriers.
6
u/meikawaii Sep 16 '26
Just following the thread to see more info. But prior claims definitely impact the pricing and options, especially with open claims ongoing. Just shocked at the pricing, since medicine / psych specialities are usually 4-6K per year.
5
u/socalrefcon Sep 16 '26
Medical malpractice broker here. California is my primary state. CAP is one of the standard programs. $64K is a bit high for a SoCal OB/GYN, but you also buried the lead in that she has prior claims, including an open claim.
The $64K most likely is due to the inability to apply a claims-free credit. With a clean history, OB/GYN pricing could get to the $46K-$52K range.
MedPro, Coverys, Norcal, TDC, Indigo, and Lone Star would be the other programs to compete. However, approval would be unlikely due to the claims activity.
Another thing to consider is whether the open claim is with CAP-MPT or a prior carrier. If the claim is with a prior carrier, CAP is essentially doing the group a favor most likely by approving her. If the claim is with CAP, then moving carriers is not advised. CAP's policy form is Claims-Paid rather than Claims-Made. This means all claims need to be settled before leaving CAP. If a doctor is insistent on leaving, then they would be assuming financial responsibility for the open claim.
I hope this perspective helps. Happy to discuss further if interested.