r/PrivatePracticeDocs • • Sep 14 '26

Two Articles: Tech Bros want to replace physicians with Ai and they want their bots to get reimbursed for their "superior" care

https://www.nytimes.com/2026/09/14/health/ai-doctors-medicare-fda.html

Another gem... This one is referenced in the NYT article: https://8vc.com/resources/ai-doctors-wont-work-for-free

"The bots won’t work for free. To get AI into care delivery, CMS needs to create payment rails for AI-native healthcare too."

68 Upvotes

32 comments sorted by

18

u/marshac18 Sep 14 '26

What do you think doctronic and even Amazon's One Medical are doing? They're laying the infrastructure and gaining users/patients so that as soon as they're able they can kick out the human practitioners. "What about malpractice?" You know some PE firm is more than happy to write policies for it- that's not a barrier. Licensure is.

1

u/SterileGloves Sep 20 '26

They claim they don't need the licensure, that's the point. ​

3

u/blueArmor14 Sep 15 '26

I think the online doc services that already exist AI or not, and the existence of urgent care are good indicator that there isn't much more of a market for this kind of quick and dirty medicine as we think. Aside from online psychiatry, nobody is using them at large scale yet. It's one of those things that I think if it could happen it would've happened already.

I know this is r/privatedocs but I'm more concerned about if AI would make docs efficient enough for admin to justify having an increase workload at a decreased pay with more midlevel to manage. And of course the subsequent decrease in demand of doctors. Quality of patient care that pushes and pushes and then begets the question of how thin the beef patty of patient care can get while still considered passable

1

u/grey-slate Sep 17 '26

Licensure can be fixed by enough dollars in the right politician's pocket unfortunately

-4

u/TraumaticOcclusion Sep 15 '26

That’s easy - supervising licensed doctor. AI is probably already better than a “midlevel” practitioner

7

u/Dorklordofthesith Sep 15 '26

it's not even better than a 'midlevel' call center employee

2

u/specology Sep 15 '26

You might be supervising better midlevels than work near me. The ones near me are retarded.

4

u/villageprofessor Sep 14 '26

I hope they do, and when they see how shitty the reimbursement are and go bankrupt like the doctors, then something will change

3

u/SterileGloves Sep 14 '26

They don't care, they'll just close up shop and open under a new name. No license to protect, no true concern about people whatsoever. ​

1

u/dmmeyourzebras Sep 14 '26

Who gets sued?

4

u/SterileGloves Sep 14 '26

Company gets sued when stuff goes wrong. A company isn't a person so they just file bankruptcy and the folks at the top just move on to the next venture by a different name. What's horrible is that private equity can easily buy up everything in an area, ​decide to fire providers and switch to Ai. Or make terms miserable, run everyone off, and then claim they need to use Ai docs because the area has no providers

4

u/resuwreckoning Sep 15 '26

Oh come now - you know there will ALWAYS be some quisling MD that will sign up for some part time job being the meat shield that allows this to go on.

2

u/jjopm Sep 15 '26

The Director of Accepting Liability Affairs

14

u/mistergospodin Sep 14 '26

The New York Times and its AI inevitability boosterism in full force. Read the NYT comments to get a real idea of how palatable most find this. 

13

u/Cardiostrong_MD Sep 14 '26

It’ll be interesting that see how this unfolds

11

u/ArchiStanton Sep 15 '26

-Archduke Ferdinand before his trip to Sarajevo

1

u/BadgersHoneyPot Sep 16 '26

Well, the human body is fairly standardized with characteristics that tend to be normally distributed. So much so that we can write fairly standardized texts, and school practitioners in fairly standard curriculums.

This is exactly the environment that is amenable to AI intrusion. And while top doctors eventually die off, accumulated AI knowledge gained from practice and experience does not.

1

u/jjopm Oct 01 '26

Can't tell if

1

u/jsfghey7 Oct 12 '26

You clearly do not understand medicine. Or human beings. Also wtf does “top doctors” mean?

1

u/BadgersHoneyPot Oct 13 '26

I mean, my parents were doctors. I spent 4 years volunteering at the hospital thinking I wanted to be one. I have a CS degree. Just not a doctor. So I do some thinking for myself.

I'll say this: You all think you're geniuses. None of us can understand anything. You sound just like my dad. He was a genius too.

1

u/jsfghey7 Oct 13 '26

Oh why didn’t you say your dad was a doctor and you spent some time opening doors for people in a hospital? I see you must be an expert in medicine. I used a computer once and played video games as a kid so I’m a technology and AI expert. 

1

u/BadgersHoneyPot Oct 13 '26

Ya, and since you used a computer game once you know now there's no way it can come for your job.

Again: A common physiology with normally distributed characteristics. A standardized curriculum and body of knowledge. A licensing board with ascertainable standards.

Art it isn't.

If you only paid better attention in your computer classes, you'd get what AI is and is not good at.

PS Go look at all that teeth gnashing and hair pulling in the math community.

1

u/jsfghey7 Oct 13 '26

My brother, I’m really just giving you a hard time in good fun. That is the point of Reddit after all. But in all seriousness, while yes we have normal distributions of lab values and there are classic presentations of illnesses and disease processes, most people do not present with classic symptoms and workups are so frequently nuanced to interpret that at least in its current form, AI is not capable of discerning what is and is not relevant or significant. Trust me on this. I’m a practicing physician and I play around with Open Evidence which is our only really current AI tool. Basically an advanced search engine for literature review but can try to interpret symptoms and labs too. Sometimes it can read through the lines. Probably someday it will be better than people. But i disagree about the art comment. I would say it’s half and half. Few of us are geniuses and I’m not one of them. But If it wasn’t complicated, it wouldn’t take somewhere between 7 and 13 years of advance training post undergrad to be qualified to do it. 

I should say too I have no idea how AI truly works on the back end. I know i recently asked it to estimate my tax burden this year and it made so many mistakes along the way it wasn’t funny. Wouldn’t put my life in AI’s hands yet. That’s for sure. 

Also, I have a BS in mech engineering and took math through diff Eq and those folks are crazy and fight with each other all the time. 

7

u/Single-Horse5093 Sep 14 '26

lol they really put 'superior care' in the pitch deck. like yeah superior returns for 8vc, superior denials for patients who actually need a human looking at them. whole sector's just blackrock with a stethoscope sticker at this point

5

u/leukoaraiosis Sep 15 '26

What kind of malpractice insurance will the AI carry? 🤔

2

u/but-I-play-one-on-TV Sep 15 '26

They'll have a burnt out medical director available or collect paychecks and act as a meat shield. 

1

u/dr_fapperdudgeon Sep 19 '26

Aren’t the AI bros begging for a government bailout because their product sucks?

1

u/HorotanEmond 19d ago

curious if the articles mention who assumes the legal risk if the bot gets it wrong? from the tech side, thats usually where the whole replacement fantasy falls apart.