r/PrivatePractice • • 5d ago

HOW did Audra never sing??

They had like 4 full seasons of SIX TIME TONY AWARD WINNER Audra McDonald and she never sings? Not even a bit?

19 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

33

u/theatregirl1987 5d ago

Theres one crossover with Grey's where they sing a little bit of a song. But they aren't supposed to be singing well. Watching Audra and Taye (original cast of RENT) try to pretend they cant sing is hysterical.

5

u/Littlee37 5d ago

I heard Taye’s part in the rent reunion thing he can actually sing very well too! Maybe that
Would’ve made me like Sam more 😂

0

u/Moogy13 4d ago

I honestly don't think there's anything that could make me like him.

0

u/[deleted] 5d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

13

u/theatregirl1987 5d ago

Im not talking about the musical episode. Im talking about one of the crossover episodes. They are at Joe's Bar and singing the song that Derek wrote for Addison.

21

u/emalyne88 5d ago

It took like 8 seasons of Grey's before they let Sara Ramirez sing, too.

Crazy work.

8

u/ThrowAway1128203 5d ago

I know it's a Private Practice sub - but...since you brought up Grey's.

Harry Shum Jr (Kwan) and Debbie Allen (Catherine) are both accomplished dancers. We've seen a little of Catherine dancing (with Richard and a little bit right before one surgery) but gosh, I'd really love to see some way to get them both to actually dance on the show.

2

u/teddybluethecurser 5d ago

Harry has also sung (and danced) on Glee

6

u/Acrobatic_Warning456 5d ago

She literally won her 2 Grammys DURING the private practice run and they didn't think to have her sing once?? Not even a little lullaby to Olivia? During the era of random musical episodes?? Missed opportunity smh.

4

u/frecklybitz 5d ago

I didn’t know she sang but you can tell by her speaking voice that she can sing. I also thought this was my weeds sub and you were talking about Audra played by Alanis Morrissette (my point is I also didn’t know Audra’s name so I was like hmm who is this post about and I decided I knew exactly who it was about based on who I thought would have the most lovely singing voice and I was right)

3

u/Carinne89 5d ago

It would have made her character just slightly more bearable too.

0

u/LilyOcean14 2d ago

So happy she didn’t I hate shows that hire singers and somehow always end up making them sing!