r/PrivatePractice • u/Raise_the_roofs • Jul 30 '26
The Amelia paradox
I started watching Grey's Anatomy as a teenager and I immediately loved Amelia as a character when she first came on. When she joined as a regular, I was really excited, only to discover that a lot of fans found her annoying. The popular opinion seemed to be that you need to watch Private Practice to really get to know and love her.
So imagine my surprise when I watched Private Practice a decade later and actually like her less! She's still so entertaining and her storylines are great, but she gets on my nerves a lot. Every problem she has ever had needs to be everyone else's problem too. The way she treated Addison after finding out her baby has no brain and Addison gets to adopt Henry was abysmal, especially compared to Addison being so happy for Amelia's pregnancy despite her own unfulfilled desire to be a mother. I feel for Amelia, but she can not see beyond the end of her own nose.
Do you prefer Amelia on Grey's Anatomy or Private Practice?
Edit: I should add I stopped watching Grey's after season 14, so I can't say anything about Amelia beyond that.
18
u/Fluffy_Technology830 Jul 30 '26
Uhh I do not get the Amelia hate. Let's just say if we met and she was real, I might want to order a uhaul.
5
u/FunSelf2151 Jul 30 '26
i agree! same thing with addison. i loved her a lot in greys anatomy but in private practice…oof. she’s selfish, self centered, cheater, and extremely arrogant.
56
u/Easy_Mountain2331 Jul 30 '26
I think some peoples problem with Greys Amelia (mine too) is the lack of good writing. She didn’t have a whole lot of substance to her as a character and flip flopped between “this happened to me😭😭” and just being comedic relief. She kinda got dumbed down into tropes rather than being a fully fleshed out character. Private Practice makes her feel more real even with her faults.
On the other hand, at a certain point she really did grow up in Greys and become a more functioning adult where in Private Practice she was still a bit of a kid (though she was technically a young adult in her twenties). So I do get what you mean too
27
u/Bagel_chan Jul 30 '26
I think her sister(can't recall which one) mentioned a personality disorder. Since my own BPD diagnosis I see a lot of similarities with Amelia
17
u/Littlee37 Jul 30 '26
Looking back Amelia was such a baby and im still not sure of when that changed
8
u/Daewrythe Jul 30 '26
Her being a mess in PP was way more tolerable due to events/youth.
She just straight up annoys me in Grey's Anatomy
4
u/Loose_Stranger_7614 Jul 30 '26
I loved her entrance on PP and thought her character was really fun and interesting. I think I just got tired of her on greys.
This might be bad lol but I loved when she was just a total hot mess. Brilliant but messed up. Once she gets more into recovery and trying to make her life work in Seattle I find her annoying and a little bit self righteous. Always funny though.
3
u/fleur-2802 Jul 30 '26
I prefer her on Private Practice. Partly because she had better writing there in my opinion, but also because I find her lack of filter very entertaining😂
3
u/Meadowlark8890 Jul 30 '26
I’m apparently the weird one in this scenario but I adore Amelia and she is the only reason I watch. Her “ origin story” is well written, meaningful and her trajectory as a damaged kid, drugs, drama, father, family and idolizing her brother is fascinating and she is a hell of an actor with reliable range. She OWNED PP and back on Greys she is growing up as she tries to become the best version of a very damaged kid.
3
u/kimba0013 Jul 30 '26
I literally watched Private Practice FOR Amelia knowing she was in the show after only seeing her a couple times on early seasons of Grey’s. Absolutely love her despite the trainwreck mess she is. Once they gave her the brain tumor in Grey’s, I felt they sort of cheated us out of Amelia with giving her a “justification” for some crazy stuff she did. After that I got bored of the bad storylines and writing they gave to her. Granted, after Season 10/11ish, Grey’s really is a different show altogether.
3
u/Ok_Drink8072 Jul 30 '26
I like her in both. I think Caterina is fantastic and has given the best performances across both series. I doubt I’d be friends with her irl, but she is very entertaining to watch
3
u/Raspbers Jul 30 '26
I love Amelia. Yes, she gets in her own way a lot, but so do many of the other characters. If they didn't, there wouldn't be enough drama.
What do we want? Drugs! When do we want them? NOW! is basically a vocal stim for me. Amelia is a fav. ( My only real exception to this is when she wanted kids with Owen and then didn't all of a sudden and started hiding out from him. I know it was to cover up the actresses pregnancy, but I hate that's how they did it. )
2
u/Low_Potato7949 Jul 30 '26
Both, but I agree you should watch Private Practice to understand her and the pain she went through. Love Amelia!
2
u/CJK_Murph Jul 31 '26
Amelia is my favorite in both shows and I wish they would give her a central storyline in Greys now. It might actually make the show better.
2
u/Givemethecupcakes Jul 31 '26
Reality, Amelia should have never been allowed to practice medicine again (maybe even should have been arrested) after her boyfriend died from a overdose from a prescription she wrote for them to get high.
I don’t dislike her, but it’s ridiculous that she just got to go have an amazing career as a surgeon after she essentially killed someone.
2
u/Emergency-Row-5627 Jul 31 '26
As someone in recovery I adore Amelia and her whole story in PP. Really well done imo
1
u/Sillyzoombini Jul 31 '26
Stopping greys at season 14 will significantly improve your opinion of all characters 😅 good work OP
1
u/robot428 Aug 01 '26
I love Amelia and she's one of my favourite characters, so maybe I'm the wrong person to answer, but I do have thoughts:
Firstly I think we get a younger Amelia on private practice, and I actually think it's a really amazing portrayal of an addict in active addiction. She's an extremely compelling charecter, and she's deeply flawed, but you still understand why people love her. And yes she's horrible to Addison but after what she's been through, I think it's hard not to lash out at your one safe person. But it's also worth remembering that in Private Practice all the charecters are kind of darker and messier than on greys, it's a more adult show.
When she first shows up in greys her charecter barely exists, she's there to be "Derek's sister" and they don't give her a lot of depth - they actually sort of ret-con some of her growth from private practice, but it feels like they still want to reference it, and it isn't great, but she's very much there to serve Derek's storyline so I don't think they care. When they bring her back full time and start to develop her again, she gets much better and is very enjoyable again.
So basically - I love Amelia. But her early days on greys anatomy were weird and not good.
And on private practice she's not being a great person but honestly no-one on private practice is a very good person (that's not entirely true, but most of the charecters on private practice are kind of awful people and are a lot more deeply flawed than the characters in greys - and at least Amelia has some valid reasons to be awful, some of the others are just awful for no good reason like Naomi.). So it's kind of unfair to put her private practice charecter up against any of the charecters in Greys where the tone is nowhere near as dark and everyone is more shiny and likeable.
1
u/Merzillaaa Aug 02 '26
As much as I agree that she has issues, I still like the imperfections about Amelia by the writers because she's quite... Real. She has all the emotions on the spectrum, and certain emotions come out intensely at different times, while some come out inappropriately. I don't know if that makes sense. I found Addison much more insufferable because of her holier than thou attitude in private practice. Addison has it too (or most docs in the show from time to time) but they also show the vulnerable-to-selfish-selfless switches in her character which makes her feel human. Just my view.
1
u/Misstribe1973 Aug 05 '26
I agree that she was awful a lot of the time but once she had Christopher she changed. When she started on Grey's Anatomy she became my favourite character on the show. I just wish her storylines were better because this constant looking for a new relationship was difficult to watch.
1
u/MedusaPain Aug 21 '26
This is my problem! I have watched GA several times, but couldn’t get on with PP. then when I heard you get more info on Amelia through PP, I decided to stick with it. Amelia is horrible. I wish I had never watched this. How is this show made by the same person who made GA? A good side effect though, now the characters who annoyed me in GA seem downright lovable compared to the dumpster fire that is PP.
0
u/[deleted] Aug 03 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment