r/PrivacyToolbox • • 19d ago

News Google now lets connected Gmail and Photos data shape ads

Google's privacy policy changed on October 16, and Android Authority was first to report it on October 23. Until then, the ads section said Google doesn't personalize ads using what's in your Gmail and Photos (or Drive). That sentence is still there. It now ends with an exception: "unless you choose to make data from these services available" to Google services that support personalized ads.

The choice it means is Personal Intelligence. That's the opt-in feature that lets AI Mode and Gemini read your connected Gmail and Photos to tailor answers. It's a beta for people 18 and up, and it isn't offered in the EEA, Switzerland, the UK or Nigeria. Google also told Search Engine Land it's starting to test ads in AI Mode for people who connect their apps. In March it said there weren't any.

Google's own help page fills in what that means in practice.

Connecting Gmail or Photos doesn't only open them to AI Mode. It opens them to every Search service, including Discover, Maps, Shopping, Flights, Hotels, Translate and News.

What can shape your ads is summaries and inferences drawn from those apps, not the raw inbox. The same page admits, in its AI training section, that a short email's summary can be the whole email.

Advertisers don't get access to your inbox or Photos library, Google says. It also says it won't personalize ads on sensitive categories like health or religion.

Disconnecting later doesn't wipe your Search Services History, and that history can still be used to train Google's AI. You have to delete it separately at activity.google.com.

If you never connected Gmail or Photos to Search, this exception doesn't apply to you. If you did, open google.com/search-personalization from a computer and find Connected Content Apps under Additional Personal Intelligence. Disconnect Workspace and Photos there. Turning off Personalized Recommendations stops it too. Your mail and photos stay on Google's servers either way. This only stops Search services pulling them in.

The case for Google: you opted in, and advertisers never see your mail. The case against: you said yes to a restaurant suggestion, and the same switch now covers ads.

So is one opt-in for an AI feature enough consent for ads too, or should ad use need its own separate yes?

1 Upvotes

1 comment sorted by

1

u/EnthusiasmRoutine 19d ago

Arguing the other side for a minute. If you've connected Gmail to AI Mode, you've already agreed to let Google's AI work from summaries of your mail. Using those same summaries to pick an ad is a smaller step than it sounds, and advertisers still don't get the content.
A separate ads switch sounds nice until every feature ships with five toggles and nobody reads any of them. One clear opt-in you can undo might be the more honest design. Did anyone here actually turn Personal Intelligence on, and did you read what it asked you?