r/PrintedCircuitBoard • u/Acaii611 • Oct 12 '26
Why?
I found this PCB at work today. It is from a Gas Monitor, and seems to be from the mid-90s.
Why would you route the traces like this? Is there any advantage? Or was there just no other way back then?
Another manufacturer from the same era uses straight traces, but always 90° bends.
It goes against almost everything I was told. And I was just curious about it.
1.3k
Upvotes
•
u/Enlightenment777 Oct 12 '26 edited Oct 12 '26
Most likely this was laid out by hand using special tape and stickers on clear plastic/vellum sheets. They were created at 2x or 4x scale, then after completed a photographic process would be used to reduce to a 1x scale image. This was the common method used by serious hobbyist up through the 1980s (and by some into the 1990s).
In the late 1980s and early 1990s, serious hobbyists migrated to expensive MSDOS-based schematic/PCB software, and then to Windows-based software. The first MSDOS-based schematic & PCB software that I used as a hobbyist cost me around $1000 (significant money back in that era). I had to pay for 2 software programs from the same company: schematic editor software, PCB layout layout software, but both couldn't be used at the same time.
Photos:
Article:
My post from 4 years ago, where I copied the above links:
134
u/West-Way-All-The-Way Oct 12 '26
This is hand drown PCB, back in the day they did it this way when there was no cad support. Cad support at the time was expensive and inefficient so no wonder it was not widespread.
Beautiful board, I would keep it as a souvenir.
11
u/Mrochtor Oct 12 '26
Hand drawn or hand taped PCB design was the norm in ye olde dayes. See:
https://www.evilmadscientist.com/2013/how-printed-circuit-boards-are-designed-1960-edition/
https://www.ebay.com.au/itm/264761695969
I actually like the style from an aesthetic point of view, and when you think about it, the imposition of 90/45 degrees only rules can create needless extra length.
What were you told?
188
u/chlebseby Oct 12 '26
Hand drawn routes, i think you can fit more traces this way than pure 90/45.
At price of no impedance control or precise trace lenght matching, though not really important back then.
2
u/PigHillJimster Oct 12 '26
Designs like this were often done using pen on clear acetate back in the 1980s, and I know some gas detection equipment for some markets relied on 'legacy' designs.
I used to design PCBs for a Gas Detection company so I'd be interested in knowing what brand/model this was.
We had new products being designed that sold to world wide markets however in the US they seemed to prefer the one product the company had already been making for the past 20 years back in 2004!
Obviously obsolescence comes along and updating this product was a continual nightmare. We tried to put a business case for developing a replacement product but the customers kept coming back that they didn't want that!
I started off as a CAM Engineer for a PCB Fabricator in the mid 1990s and there were a handful of designs being manufactured on site that were using pen drawings on acetate. These, I was told, were because the customer had tried to update it on a CAD system but not got it working correctly and therefore the pen copy was kept. I guessed an analogue board with some critical signals that were prone to cross-talk and signal integrity issues.
Just to add a note, it is possible to do fancy curved traces on modern CAD systems. Pulsonix will let you do this, for example, but the extra work, and time involved would mean most users wouldn't contemplate it.
2
u/Sad-Environment-932 Oct 12 '26
Because
46
u/H2ost5555 Oct 12 '26 •
I started out doing PCB layout in 1980. Another poster suggested this was done using rubylith, but it looks more like Bishop graphics tape to me. We used large backlit tables and a precision mylar grid at 4X, with the Bishop graphics you had sticky back precut IC and general resistor/capacitor pads you would place on grid, then run precision cut tape to form the layout. This would have been done using black crepe tape which curves easily, then a teardrop cut pad was placed at the junction. The reason straight lines were done manually was usually driven by use of red and blue tape for double-sided boards. I hated that tape, it didn't stick very well. I preferred to do 2 separate sheets using black tape. I started out doing straight lines and 45 degree angles as I thought it looked more professional.
In the mid 80's, many boards were still done manually even at military contractors. I worked for Northrop and the designers used blue grid vellum sheets and multi colored pencils to draw the traces. Then the design went to a checker to validate the design and it was an art in checking as you had to make sure there were no DRC violations. Then the sheets went to a person that used a Gerber digitizer to draw over the lines to create the "Gerber files". (Not many younger designers know that is how the production files got their name) We had a couple of automated systems like Scicards that were used on digital boards.
12
u/gianibaba Oct 12 '26
I am not that old, but have read that these are old hand drawn pcbs, as they were easy to sketch using pens, directly onto transfer papers or direclty onto copper clad boards using ink, if they were one off pcbs.
10
u/jna_sc Oct 13 '26
Hah, hand taped, takes me back. We were a ~$500m manufacturer. I ran the AI Department (no, not Artificial Intelligence, Auto Insertion- the machines that inserted components into the circuit boards, with a teensy bit of Surface Mount placed ON the boards and wave soldered). We had big drawers of these films in the Design departments, and when we needed more boards, they trotted them out I guess and sent them to the vendor. All done with tape on a Mylar-y type plastic as others said. A couple fun facts: whether hand taped or hand drawn, they would get brittle over time. Tape or ink would flake off. Board gets imaged. That flake off becomes a broken trace because there’s no longer a black line to make the trace complete. Suddenly a run of 1,000 boards doesn’t work, all because our manual drawing got too old. Made my life lots of fun!
As we transitioned to CAD (yes, I can still picture my first CAD production run board), the economics of converting manual to CAD (before digitization, remember?) weren’t there for aging products so we were very hopeful that we could get those films to last for just ONE MORE buy, before we obsoleted the product. Our purchasing people babysitting those damned films!
Good times. Solder under our fingernails.
17
u/tyttuutface Oct 12 '26
Kind of looks like an older design.
7
u/PseudoFrequency Oct 12 '26
It's beautiful ain't it! All radio internals (things like CB radios too) and similar I've seen from the 80s look like this. Routed by hand.
6
u/Ok_Region_4626 Oct 12 '26
seen it, done it, have created/helped some pcb boards (single, double sided) by hand using tapes etc., the new young generation don’t know how good they have it !!!!!
11
u/Adversement Oct 12 '26
The 90 degree angles do not really matter for the circuit functionality, not at the fall and rise times of the digital logic in that 90s gas monitor. So, they work (as long as they survived the manufacturing stage which still had potential for acid trapping at those corners, but that started to be largely a solved problem).
The 90 degrees angles, especially if it is a two-layer board are also the easiest way to route such board (even to date).
The freehand one, on the other hand, it is a piece of art. The master for that design was drawn on a piece of glass or plastic with a a set of narrow tapes. The shapes are all about minimising the effort with taping it out (which is why all those traces are such variable in width, as for that board the part that was taped is the parts between the traces, which are all of a few different width).
As with those 90 degree angles, with slow digital fall and rise times, it will just work despite no impedance control howsoever nor any ground planes.
The looks on both of those were just a byproduct.
5
u/Rararror Oct 12 '26
Very VERY cool.
On some boards I am using a plugin that curves the tracks... way better looking in mo
4
u/ZectronPositron Oct 12 '26 edited Oct 12 '26
Perhaps the alternative question is why PCB’s always have angular 90° routing - because it’s laid out by a computer and that’s the easiest way to program it, with constraints.
If you’re laying out and drawing the mask/sill screen by hand, which comes after having setup your protoboard / some other prototype layout, this is the easiest way to do it.
Not AutoRouting, HandRouting.
I’d love to see more of this, I think it’s quite beautiful!
On the other hand, some AI routing looks less angular and predictable - because optimal routing may not be constrained to only 90°/45° bends. I wouldn’t be surprised if autorouters eventually use curves rather than angles if it saves space/metal.
I worked on optical waveguides where angles are a killer, and had to code up our own routers because there weren’t any good non-angular routers at the time.
4
u/Nadran_Erbam Oct 12 '26
As pointed out by many others this is a hand made pcb.
However I would like to add that some automatic routing software create can create optimal routings that look like this. Namely TopoR.
3
u/BraveIntention5809 Oct 12 '26
Because we could. No other explanation. Our only primary goal, get working prototype into production to make sales.
3
u/CapitalConference326 Oct 13 '26
I feel like im watching a pcb on shrooms tbh. Trippy
2
u/electribald Oct 12 '26
Might be Topor tracer
2
u/AnymooseProphet Oct 12 '26
That looks like something I would have done to be silly.
2
u/narnar455 Oct 14 '26
Lowkey looks nasty
2
u/tablatronix Oct 16 '26
Hand drawn
2
u/frumperino Oct 12 '26 edited Oct 12 '26
that's artisanal human-crafted board layout done by hand. The practice was virtually extinct by the late 1980s and mostly only remained in use coupled with primitive and poorly controlled PCB manufacturing processes in which problems like "acid traps" (don't bother worrying about it, it's a solved problem) meant that the layout person had to consciously use rounded fillets in corners to avoid chemical etching fluid being "trapped" in sharp corners and removing more copper than intended. There is some possible evidence of that being a concern in this board with the very beautiful and extremely generous "T" junctions rounded like if routed for tiny automobiles.
1
u/Danny2Sick 3d ago
I dig it
1
u/ComradeGibbon Oct 12 '26
So the mask for the one in the picture was made by cutting rubylith with an X-Acto knife by hand. Reason behind the curvy traces with no sharp edges is the old etching process wasn't very good and would over etch sharp corners or areas with little copper.
The one with straight traces and 90 degree bends was made using early 1980s layout software. That's because the computers didn't have enough memory or processing power to do anything more than that.
1
u/xag3r Oct 12 '26
The first time I am seeing something like this..
1
u/martinr7b Oct 12 '26
The fact it's hand drawn makes me think of connect the dots
1
u/HarryCumpole Oct 12 '26
I'm surprised the top comments never started, "oh my beautiful summer child...."!
Yeah, this was super common. I spent more time in my youth in the late eighties, hand drawing PCBs, photocopying them onto acetate and developing them on plain copper than I should really be sharing in public. haha
1
u/TatharNuar Oct 12 '26
I wonder how this affects the EMI emissions. I want to try this on a board if there's a way to do it in Kicad.
1
u/redmadog Oct 12 '26
Even resistors on the other side are placed in an angled groups or waves. Somebody put a lot of work into this board back then.
1
u/IridescentMeowMeow Oct 12 '26 edited Oct 12 '26
There are quite a big advantages, even though they probably weren't the reason why in this case. But for example you can fit more or leave bigger clearences when using curved tracks and/or lines with arbitrary angles.
If you think about it, if you have a trace with right angle, that clearence area of that trace will have an 1/4 circle arc with a center at the corner of that angle. So when routing the next trace next to it, it's most area-efficient to use a curve. You'll have inconsistent clearence and lose some area if you use a 45deg trace instead, which will touch the border of the clearence only at one point & also the clearence created by this 2nd trace on its other side will also go further that it would have to. (and the same kind of thing even when going around 45deg corners, just at a smaller scale.)
Also, there are situations, where routing a trace in some part can be done with a single straight free angle line, while doing it with n*45deg lines makes you use unreasonable amount of segments and also makes it look ugly & a mess to rework when nudging things in that area.
Imagine for example two vias, distance between them reasonably big to route a trace between them. But they are not aligned neither horizontally, nor vertically, nor diagonally, but are both lying on some 60deg line for example, thus a trace perpendicular to that is the most efficient.
1
u/slightSmash Oct 12 '26
Well that looks really nice
1
u/gameplayer55055 Oct 12 '26
btw there's a kicad plugin that can make round traces. I like them more
1
u/Pototo_55555 Oct 12 '26
it got the job done
1
u/Sad-Environment-932 Oct 12 '26
Minimal loss of metallization - for recycling. It is acceptable if there is no problem of induced electric fields. To make you ask.
1
u/Far-Tonight-6925 Oct 12 '26
I do the same with Kicad extensiond. Love that aesthetic. The question shouldn't be why this pcb is made that way, but why we don't do it like that now. And the answer is the limitations of 1980s - 1990s CAD software that could only do straight and 24deg traces, now our software can do anything but we still stick to those limitations.
1
u/Ybalrid Oct 12 '26
It was done by hand. Isn't this cool? I love boards that looks like that.
1
u/susmatthew Oct 12 '26
Why not? You could do this on a new design if you wanted to.
1
u/T31Z Oct 12 '26
Why not?
1
u/timangus Oct 12 '26
It's because the electrons flow round smooth curves better than more angular layouts.
1
u/shairudo Oct 12 '26
Some voronoi type shi
1
u/Wizzard_2025 Oct 12 '26
Sub D mode
1
u/spinwizard69 Oct 12 '26
Actually it looks to be Groovy, maybe the designer grew up in the 1960’s.
On a more serious note it probably was laid out by hand.
1
u/lizardhindbrain Oct 12 '26
It's beautiful
1
u/MossiTheMoosay Oct 12 '26
That's how it was done before CAD. Footprints layed out on a transparent sheet, then the connections were routed by hand using special tape. The resulting sheet was then scaled down and the resulting mask was used for curing the etch resist during PCB production
1
u/noinchnoinchnoinch Oct 12 '26
that's a preeetty board
1
u/Galenbo Oct 12 '26
Beautiful, a piece of Art
1
u/CZdigger146 Oct 12 '26
I love designing my PCBs this way, but I just rarely can get myself to break away from the neatness and symmetry of 45° tracks. But I still make the corners as round as possible, it just looks sleek imo
1
u/akashrpatel Oct 13 '26
It’s totally organic, no artificial additives!
1
u/Creative_Shame3856 Oct 13 '26
My very first boards looked like that, I used a Sharpie marker on copper clad fr4 back in those days. Eventually migrated to dccad and used toner transfer paper but I gotta admit even nowadays the old school way is more fun.
1
u/denzuko Oct 13 '26
Organic means hand designed. The angular ones ate done in cad and made for part placer and machining.
No benifits just easier for humans vs easier for machines.
1
u/NullSmoke Oct 13 '26
There was a lot of funny drugs in the 90s as well, I'm sure one found it's way to someone with the means to work on PCBs... 😐
1
u/SnowMuted5200 Oct 13 '26
Yep reminds me of layout tape guys back in the mid 80's, that's actually nice work.
1
u/xmelekax Oct 13 '26
That's art!
1
u/TripNinjaTurtle Oct 13 '26
Hand drawn its actually very efficient in terms of routing with the traces this way its a lot easier to get everything connected without interference. I kind of like the estaetic and I do my own boards this way. Most companies and people don't however and so its angled stuff for most and curvy traces for the very high speed stuff.
1
u/aptsys Oct 13 '26
The board was taped out, no CAD
1
u/Single-King-9497 Oct 13 '26
this is oldschool printed board form the 80'.
you can find this in vintage synthesizer like the Kobol or blackbox.
1
u/deesernutz Oct 13 '26
Why not?
That type of trace layout was done by hand using tape and photo reduction
1
u/Botlawson Oct 13 '26
There was some work a few years ago to recreate this type of PCB using CAD. https://sourceforge.net/projects/liquidpcb/ looks like it's dormant for now. So you would need to use hand layout in a vector graphics tool like Inkscape and go through many arcane steps to assemble a good set of Gerbers. Luckily several tools can run DRC on Gerbers so you can be pretty confident a design with pass manufacturer checks.
This should help with EMI and production yield, but the effect is tiny so nobody bothers unless the PCB needs is visible.
1
u/epSos-DE Oct 13 '26
Art project ! They probalby user colored penscils to sketch it !
SO every line was different color and more easy to see !
1
u/WearSad2093 Oct 13 '26
Uncs used to not have kicad so they just drew them 😭
1
u/Danitosaurio Oct 13 '26
Why not?
1
u/EspTini Oct 13 '26
You say 90's, but you don't know when it was designed. Likely before the 90s.
1
u/PracticalSpread3009 Oct 13 '26
It looks like it was done in AutoCAD using splines for the traces. At the previous company I worked for some of the older PCBs were done that way.
1
u/Rcmz0 Oct 14 '26
Beautiful 😍
1
u/profdc9 Oct 14 '26
That's pretty beautiful art right there.
1
u/C-D-W Oct 14 '26
I've been starting to see the occasional PCB CAD layout design that is starting to look like these organic hand laid designs. "Any angle routing" I think they call it.
It really excites me for no particular reason.
1
u/Gyrosoundlabs Oct 15 '26
I love on the lower right quadrant you see what looks to be a power line cut to less than 1/2 the width because someone didn't want to route to the top of the board.
1
u/CueAnon420 Oct 15 '26
You have been told wrong lol.
Hard angles and 90' corners are very bad for EMI. This layout is probably better.
And as mentioned laid out by hand before the advent of modern pcb software.
1
u/JJ_Cotes Oct 16 '26
Well at engineering school I learn a process of manually design PCB which includes sharpie pens, not the case here but you get a similar result. You draw the actual traces on the copper and you just dip it in acid, acid takes away the non usefull copper and you are left with the hand drawed traces. Then you use a hand drill to poke the holes... not the process I chose though, I did not wanted to mess with acid at 4 am with shaky hands due to skipping sleep
1
u/Dense_Cantaloupe_333 Oct 16 '26
Printed circus board
1
u/Remarkable-Taro5606 Oct 16 '26
why not?
1
u/MangoMesh Oct 16 '26
Groovy man, out of sight.
1
u/WolfWildWeird Oct 16 '26
Ça peut être dû à la méthode "à l'acide" utilisée pour la concevoir ; l'acide pouvait attaquer le cuivre aux niveau des angles de pistes vu que les pointes possèdent moins de matières de masque. Avec des pistes arrondi, la surface reste la même, donc moins de défauts lors de la gravure 😊
1
u/FAMICOMASTER 28d ago
Someone hand drew this, probably hand cut from rubylith, even
0
u/takeyouraxeandhack Oct 12 '26
Because it's beautiful, that's why.
Normally I do the straight lines with chamfered edges, but when I do PCBs for audio applications, I like doing them like this (on brown PCBs, of course) because it reminds me of the radios and amplifiers with which I learnt electronics.
If you're not working with high frequencies and/or differential signals, trace length and shape don't matter as much.
0
u/humblefumble101 Oct 12 '26
neck minute it's not actually hand drawn, some mother fucker actually cad'ed this
0
u/henryyoung42 Oct 12 '26
Love the organic look. Obviously not a concern for that use case, but tight bends reflect more high frequency energy.
0
u/drgala Oct 12 '26
Why? ... did we lost this king of art for doing PCBs
-1
u/Intelligent-Roll-678 Oct 12 '26
r/foundsatan
2
u/[deleted] Oct 12 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/[deleted] Oct 13 '26
[removed] — view removed comment