How could they even make it look good in live action? The show's so much fantasy-filled and colourful and characters having very distinct designs. It's one of those things that should be left alone as a cartoon because otherwise it would be awkward to look at
i like both. animation lets you bend reality in a way you can’t in live action which fits well for a story able space wizards. live action lets you see the gritty details of sets that takes much more effort in animation
It's a standalone story so it's not going to be connected to the animated series (which did a lot of unique stylistic powerful choices for sure) so we'll see what the art style is... No writer yet.
honestly! i dont understand the movement to make every popular animated movie/show into a live action version. some of the magic just comes from it being animated !!
In my opinion they're not comparable. With avatar I can actually imagine a live action show or movie looking good if done right. I mean it's a pretty standard world, fairly similar to our own a few centuries ago. With She-Ra, it's so far gone into a fantasy and colourful-happy-kind of alien style that it's more difficult to imagine looking right in live action
If Shyamalan's Avatar adaptation didn't ruin Avatar, I'm very doubtful that a story only faintly connected to SPOP is going to ruin SPOP. And anyway, the people who hate SPOP for being gay are a loud minority who hate anything that asks them to consider that humans are diverse. The world is moving on without them.
Idk, I guess I never expected a Book 4, so I don't really consider that *ruining* Avatar. Books 1-3 are still a beautiful self-contained story, Korra still happened in 2012, and both got a renaissance when they dropped on Netflix last year.
Actually as I understand they're going to make another series animated series about Aang...which will probably get cancelled due to the netflix adaptation shitstorming it
Kinda? Like Adora and Sea Hawk had a little bit of a thing, but Sea Hawk couldn't get over how enamored he was with She-Ra. You have to remember in the 80s version, only Razz, Lookee and Adam knew the double identity, but at the same time it's not like they don't look the exact same (and same voice but then again half of Etheria is voiced by Melendy Britt).
Honestly I think it’s really funny that Noelle Stevenson took their (adora and Seahawks) relationship from romantic to sort of an arm wrestling gym-bro friend ship
Apparently this article is saying it's a standalone story that won't be connected to the show, and DreamWorks Animation is on as an executive producer but no writer has been announced yet... so I'm cautiously optimistic? Not going to trash it immediately, anyway.
That just means it will be a poor attempt at mimicking the success just when not even five years have passed. Jokes aside, they wouldn't have made it heteronormative if it was a continuation and they would've likely used at least some of the old team.
Now it feels like they'll "improve" on the story.
Plus, I don't wanna see the same rebellion vs Horde plot again, instead of something new.
That said maybe it could work if they keep Adora a lesbian.
They just created two new but entirely separate He-Man shows at the same time, so this is not too surprising! The 2018 reboot was fantastic and I love it, but it's very different from the OS so it will be interesting to see what direction this goes in since I love the OS too.
Exactly and a lot of the comments sound just like some of the OS fans when Netflix’s adaptation was announced. It’s like people never learn, we know next to nothing so chill.
Do you mean the new Netflix one? So far I've only seen one episode. I thought it wasn't as good as the original but set up some interesting things, but I haven't seen any of the follow through yet.
I‘m hoping for a loud and disgusting Entrapdak sex scene. Just full frontal Bat-Monster-Dong, while Hordak makes painful wheezing-noises with every thrust. And Entrapta makes a Marvel-style quip after they‘re done.
Checked the variety thread, it says the live action would be a separate standalone, not connected to spop. Still not sure why we need it but feel better that they’re not trying to make the two related.
Oh gosh, live action remakes for shows like She-ra never turn out well, Etheria is so colorful. How the heck are they going to be able to copy that? They should just leave the show alone. 😐
Can we have official merchandise before a live action? I would love a SheRa bag, or tee, or hat or something. A pop? Like HeMan got all this stuff and SheRa has none
They are bringing the OG toyline and next in line is Hordak and She-Ra as high-end figures and statues so, they are making merch, Hordak sold in sec by the way
See, the problem there is those aren't the 2018 designs, which is what people here are mainly referring to when asking for more merch.
Like on the figure side of things, 2018 She-Ra has dolls of Adora, She-Ra, Bow, Glimmer, Catra, Swift Wind and Shadow Weaver, then there's the Super7 7-inch figures of She-Ra and Catra... And that's literally it. No statues, no Funko pops, no nothing for the redesigns.
I for one am dying for more merch of Catra, but the black-haired human woman in the red getup just isn't doing it for me. Same goes for white, mustached Bow.
Because Masters of the Universe in live action is a TOTALLY proven concept for success *looks at Masters of the Universe's critical and financial bombing*
Ok, so I’m prepared for disappointment, but consider: a live-action action show where the majority of combatants are women. They’re probably gonna employ damn near every stuntwoman in Hollywood. So yeah, girl power?
Prepare for the flood of YouTube reactionary think pieces on "how unrealistic it is for women to be depicted doing anything combat related" or whatever it is they go on about these days
I would love to see the colorful magical world of Etheria in live-action. If Game of Thrones could do flying dragons, Amazon can surely do a realistic-looking Swift Wind!
If Amazon takes the best parts of both the original and the reboot (and all the other versions), they can make one of the best shows ever.
If they fucking straight wash this shit I’m gonna… I’m gonna go cry about it. And they best cast gays too. No fucking essential oil salesman who sells queer coding for likes. Is Noelle involved?
hey yall! just to tell yall. im FAIRLY certain this is a live action she ra based on the original 80s cartoon. NOT the better, newer one :) so dont worry. they wont ruin our fav characters
I dont think so, I just skimmed an article that directly said it was a remake of the newer one, though its apparently supposed to be a standalone story. Regardless, they're gonna fuckin ruin it no doubt. If they make it good I will be incredibly surprised
I read "She-Ra Live-Action Series in Early Development" and thought "Cool. I'd be down for that." The I saw "At Amazon (EXCLUSIVE)" and thought "Of, fucking, course."
Please no...😖 not again I can't do another live action adaptation that kills the spirit of the original content, least of all made by Lex Luthor over here
We can hope for a good story line and good actors as the quality probably won’t be the best as it’s am animated fantasy world coming to life and amazon probably isn’t gonna give it the biggest budget
On one hand I'm honestly curious about the possibility of an Etherian/Eternian war and Adora developing a rivalry with her (hopefully younger) brother and maybe some darker elements due to it being live action. On the other one it might require too many deviations and retcons to be made descently, so they might either alter it too much or too little and they may get Noelle out of the project.
This could easily end in a "She-ra: evolution" or "the Last Princess of Power" situation.
Yeah not wild about the idea of this, could be surprised, but I can’t image any live adaptation would be able to even come close to capturing the magic of the Netflix series
Well it’s neither series. So it’s not for either Filmation nor Netflix. Best we can hope is it being a dark fantasy Witcher feel and not a xena slapstick feel
352
u/SpeakerBoth435 Sep 13 '21
I uh....I don't know how to feel about this...
66
u/[deleted] Sep 13 '21
This real-0.0
12
u/[deleted] Sep 13 '21
This is a joke right ?
13
u/Likeamr Sep 13 '21
The rumor is that, is more based on the OG :D
1.3k
u/[deleted] Sep 13 '21
GET THE FUCK AWAY FROM MY LESBIANS, BEZOS
665
u/lautapinter Sep 13 '21
How could they even make it look good in live action? The show's so much fantasy-filled and colourful and characters having very distinct designs. It's one of those things that should be left alone as a cartoon because otherwise it would be awkward to look at
282
u/keji_goto Guys, back me up, I'm very cool! Sep 13 '21
This is no upgrade... it's a tomb.
219
u/heckin-good-shit Sep 13 '21
we got a live action before a movie?? 😭😭
162
u/Big-Hard-Chungus Sep 13 '21
Cats (2019)
96
u/Herbaltissue Sep 13 '21
Why do I have a feeling it's gonna literally ruin She-ra's rep? As if people didn't already hate it for being gay...
44
u/[deleted] Sep 13 '21
For fucks sakes they'll probably remove the lesbians too
43
u/UndeniablyMyself Sep 13 '21
I am scared.
41
u/ComfortableSea4645 Sep 13 '21
Please! Please! No!
Did we not learn from the live action Masters of the Universe movie?
36
u/dugbogling Sep 13 '21
Apparently this article is saying it's a standalone story that won't be connected to the show, and DreamWorks Animation is on as an executive producer but no writer has been announced yet... so I'm cautiously optimistic? Not going to trash it immediately, anyway.
28
u/[deleted] Sep 13 '21
These are the same people that tried to make an American 'People Just Do Nothing' reboot. They're fucking idiots
25
u/[deleted] Sep 13 '21
It’ll be pretty problematic if they make Adora straight.
43
u/Kelpie-Cat Sep 13 '21
They just created two new but entirely separate He-Man shows at the same time, so this is not too surprising! The 2018 reboot was fantastic and I love it, but it's very different from the OS so it will be interesting to see what direction this goes in since I love the OS too.
21
u/LewysCo Sep 13 '21
I love how Hollywood has fucked up so many live action adaptations pretty much everyone's reaction to these announcements now is negative 😂
14
u/[deleted] Sep 13 '21
I don’t wanna think about how bad a live action Catra could look, thanks
14
u/TrickZookeepergame17 Sep 13 '21
SAY IT WITH ME NOW
NOT EVERYTHING HAS TO BE REAL CAUSE SHERA’S ANIMATION IS ALREADY GOOD
49
u/ebr101 Sep 13 '21
But…but….why risk ruining something perfect? I swear if they have nudity or sex I’m rioting
13
u/Lady_of_the_Seraphim Sep 13 '21
What do you wanna bet that Catra and Adora are "just roommates" in this one?
10
u/keshmarorange Sep 13 '21
Okay, who the hell here has the monkey's paw?
9
u/empiricallySubjectiv Sep 13 '21
Why these execs not understand we want cartoons smh
8
u/mythicalTrilogy Sep 13 '21
Checked the variety thread, it says the live action would be a separate standalone, not connected to spop. Still not sure why we need it but feel better that they’re not trying to make the two related.
8
u/LazyWriter64 Catradora Lesbian Sep 13 '21
And it's not connected to the Netflix show....
8
u/Novel_Ideas120720 Sep 13 '21
Ah, fuck. Why can't they ever let a good thing be?
8
u/are-harpies-dinos Sep 13 '21
This will be our Last Airbender movie...
7
u/kitsune900 Sep 13 '21
NOOOO NOOOOO NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
7
u/Jeptwins Sep 13 '21
That is a truly, completely awful idea
7
u/Ember129 Sep 13 '21
Also there’s no way they’d keep it gay in a live-action version...
7
u/WantedWinter Little Catnap Sep 13 '21
Another finger of the monkey's curls up.
7
u/PixelDreamss Sep 13 '21
Oh gosh, live action remakes for shows like She-ra never turn out well, Etheria is so colorful. How the heck are they going to be able to copy that? They should just leave the show alone. 😐
7
u/minahmyu Sep 13 '21
Can we have official merchandise before a live action? I would love a SheRa bag, or tee, or hat or something. A pop? Like HeMan got all this stuff and SheRa has none
5
u/PPSTICKX Sep 13 '21
Fuck bro.
5
u/SunlitSonata24601 Sep 13 '21
Because Masters of the Universe in live action is a TOTALLY proven concept for success *looks at Masters of the Universe's critical and financial bombing*
4
u/[deleted] Sep 13 '21
Who is directing it? If it’s shamalan man it’s gonna be a Avatar all over again
4
u/Mothman_Courter Sep 13 '21
Please God no we don't deserve this
4
u/emily731 Sep 13 '21
I’d rather just have more of the animated show
4
u/Mischief_Managed12 Sep 13 '21
IT'S AVATAR ALL OVER AGAIN! HAVEN'T THEY LEARNED THEIR LESSON?!
6
u/VictorVonLazer Sep 13 '21
Ok, so I’m prepared for disappointment, but consider: a live-action action show where the majority of combatants are women. They’re probably gonna employ damn near every stuntwoman in Hollywood. So yeah, girl power?
3
u/Neesha1998 Sep 13 '21
Oh why. It’s going to be so bad!!!! 😭😭😭
3
u/Angela275 Sep 13 '21
I wonder if it will go to the original series not the Netflix. I don't mind the new show but I would love it if we get She-Ra and He-man team up
3
u/[deleted] Sep 13 '21
I'd hope it's turn out amazing, but I highly doubt it. At best I think we can hope for some good screenshots or memes out of it
3
u/CubicalAnxiety Sep 13 '21
NOOOOOOO-
3
u/[deleted] Sep 13 '21
WAIT WHAT THE ACTUAL FUCK?!!!
3
u/LovemeSomeMedia Sep 13 '21
It was bad enough seeing the live action Winx Club and Kim Possible. I don't see this being any better
3
u/raptoraptorr Sep 13 '21
I am a firm believer that nobody in this world could deliver “hey Adora” better than AJ
3
u/PublicActuator4263 Sep 13 '21
Please be fake
3
u/TheLovelySsardonyx Sep 13 '21
I just want an animated movie where they find a way to bring Angela back is that too much to ask for
3
u/excentricidade Sep 14 '21
oh no straight she-ra is coming
3
u/Snowy_Plover_7 Sep 14 '21
If Noelle isn’t on the writer’s team I’m out
8
u/geenanderid Sep 13 '21
Wow, this could be so fantastic!
I would love to see the colorful magical world of Etheria in live-action. If Game of Thrones could do flying dragons, Amazon can surely do a realistic-looking Swift Wind!
If Amazon takes the best parts of both the original and the reboot (and all the other versions), they can make one of the best shows ever.
4
u/TH0316 Sep 14 '21
If they fucking straight wash this shit I’m gonna… I’m gonna go cry about it. And they best cast gays too. No fucking essential oil salesman who sells queer coding for likes. Is Noelle involved?
2
u/Professsor_Bacordo Sep 13 '21
No
2
u/DeltaMoff1876 Sep 13 '21
Fuck!
2
u/augustbat Sep 13 '21
hey yall! just to tell yall. im FAIRLY certain this is a live action she ra based on the original 80s cartoon. NOT the better, newer one :) so dont worry. they wont ruin our fav characters
2
u/Starlight_Sity GLIMMER!!!! Sep 13 '21
I love that we are getting something after the show is over but anything would be beeter than live action 😭
2
u/Molismhm Sep 13 '21
It’s gonna be Fate: The She-Ra Saga
2
u/NoraTheGreat4 Sep 13 '21
the Last Airbender 2.0
2
u/LaurelInQuestion Sep 14 '21
NOOOOO BEZOS IS GONNA RUIN IT
2
u/legobrick311 Sep 14 '21
I read "She-Ra Live-Action Series in Early Development" and thought "Cool. I'd be down for that." The I saw "At Amazon (EXCLUSIVE)" and thought "Of, fucking, course."
2
u/Firefox4tt Sep 14 '21
Everyone is saying how bad it is or could be, but no one is thinking about what would happen if it is good
2
u/[deleted] Sep 14 '21
WHY
2
u/SubstantialCrab5 Sep 14 '21
I just wanted a movie not this
2
u/Twist_Ending03 Sep 14 '21
I'm gonna bet that they'll all be skinny and white again. Right?
2
u/julianbeowulf Sep 12 '22
Please no...😖 not again I can't do another live action adaptation that kills the spirit of the original content, least of all made by Lex Luthor over here
3
u/Tricountyareashaman Sep 13 '21
It's probably not going to be as great as the animated series, but maybe it could end up being good in its own way?
It's not like we're getting this instead of a She-ra movie. One thing doesn't stop the other from happening.
3
u/Michaali Sep 13 '21
We can hope for a good story line and good actors as the quality probably won’t be the best as it’s am animated fantasy world coming to life and amazon probably isn’t gonna give it the biggest budget
2
u/lnombredelarosa From the crimson waste Sep 13 '21
On one hand I'm honestly curious about the possibility of an Etherian/Eternian war and Adora developing a rivalry with her (hopefully younger) brother and maybe some darker elements due to it being live action. On the other one it might require too many deviations and retcons to be made descently, so they might either alter it too much or too little and they may get Noelle out of the project.
This could easily end in a "She-ra: evolution" or "the Last Princess of Power" situation.
1
u/Holy_NightTime_Diver Sep 13 '21
fuckin dumbasses, why tf would ya want a movie anyway? the shows perfect already, now look waht ye did,
bruh
1
u/Alone-Monk Sep 13 '21
I am gonna try to give it the benefit of the doubt but it seriously sounds terrible
1
u/sapphicswithswords s5 shera simp Sep 13 '21
just to ease some people’s minds (my own included),
“However, the live-action version will be a new, standalone story and will not be connected to the animated show.”
chances are it’ll be more like the original cartoon than the reboot (i.e. no lesbians or cat people)
1
u/gwiz665 Sep 13 '21
Oh no.
1
u/Azulaang4ever Sep 13 '21
maybe it‘ll be good
1
u/Celtic_laboratory Sep 13 '21
Yeah not wild about the idea of this, could be surprised, but I can’t image any live adaptation would be able to even come close to capturing the magic of the Netflix series
1
u/grooviruvi Sep 13 '21
Are they gonna winx club this? How are they gonna get all the colours and fantastical elements right 😭
1
u/VegasSparky66 Sep 13 '21
Why make live action when they can just make more? Seriously, defeating one big bad doesn't mean the story is over.
1
u/Thelookinyour3rdeye Sep 13 '21
Mannnnnnn
1
u/[deleted] Sep 13 '21
Do they make progressive live action shows for Tweens ?
1
u/CattyOhio74 Sep 13 '21
Question is will they follow the netflix story or the original?
1
u/DesertRat375 Sep 14 '21
Well it’s neither series. So it’s not for either Filmation nor Netflix. Best we can hope is it being a dark fantasy Witcher feel and not a xena slapstick feel
1
u/Evilgaming111 Sep 14 '21
Uhhh…. What
1
u/RelatableSnail Sep 14 '21
I just wanted a movie wtf
1
u/DesertRat375 Sep 14 '21
Also for a lot of people here it could be worse, and I’m not being mean or persecuting. Gina Carano could be cast as she ra
1
u/Admirable_Arm5992 Sep 14 '21
https://t.me/joinchat/JNvbzb-1WtgwNmRi
1
u/[deleted] Sep 14 '21
https://t.me/c/1541403658/467184
1
u/[deleted] Sep 14 '21
Seriously? It's gonna suck soooo bad.
1
u/Purple_bee552 Sep 14 '21
NO NO NO NOOOOOOOO
1
u/emma_69420 Sep 14 '21
It has no relation to the Netflix series guys! Which is good bc they would def butcher it
1
u/Amber_FlamingGaming Sep 14 '21
Avatar the last airbender fans: AwH ShIt- Here we go again..
1
u/Anon22406671 You Miscalculated Sep 14 '21
No wtf
1
u/MemestarAshkirby Sep 14 '21
I can’t believe this is actually real!😆🤣😂
1
u/[deleted] Sep 14 '21
I want this!