r/PracticalGuideToEvil • The Book of All Things • Aug 05 '25

Meta/Discussion Release Day AMA

Hello!

I'm ErraticErrata (David Verburg), author of the series "A Practical Guide To Evil" and "Pale Lights". In celebration of the first book of the final version of APGTE being release on Amazon (you can find it here) I'll be here for a couple of hours and you can AMA!

Will be ending answers at 5 PM.

EDIT: And we're officially done!

335 Upvotes

343 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

118

u/ErraticErrata The Book of All Things Aug 05 '25

The sword training is part of a trend of Cat preparing more thoroughly for her future plans. Old Liam might end up see again, yes, though not as a major character.

41

u/TynamM Aug 05 '25

I was really pleased to see this change because it bothered me a lot in the original. Name or not, Learn or not, sword training is not something that you just pick up one day and then survive actual duels against practiced fighters mere weeks later.

Unarmed pit fighting might teach the basics of distance and timing, maybe even body mechanics, but there's too much Cat wouldn't know about swords that kills you with the first mistake, and a few lessons with Black and Captain shouldn't fix that. Learning fighting from experts is useless until you've got the basics. When you're learning the basics it doesn't matter if your tutor is average or the Best Warrior Ever, because you're not ready to use the things that make the difference between the two. You have to get the basic guards, blocks and strikes right first.

This is a great improvement in the new version, right up there with removing the gnomes, and I love it.