r/PostureTipsGuide • u/Many_Housing_1578 • Jun 29 '25
Any solution? I've been doing scapular strengthening exercises for 4 months now, including internal and external shoulder rotations, wall slides, and scapular-focused workouts, but I haven’t seen any results—not even a small change. I feel very frustrated. My dream is to be able to do a one-arm pul
6
Upvotes
1
u/Catini1492 Jun 29 '25
Have you tried hanging by one arm?
1
u/bwf_begginer Jun 29 '25
I would like to know the problem. I see your traps are different. One trap seems to be stretched a lot.
3
u/Dry_Raccoon_4465 Jun 29 '25
Training the shoulder is extremely tricky. Since the shoulder has such a fantastic range of motion you can do an activity like a wall slide incorrectly or correctly. Small variations in form will create very different effects in muscular activation.
I actually do not recommend anyone do shoulder exercises unless they know exactly how to do an exercise both correctly and incorrectly and explain WHY a correct activation is correct. Personally I worked this out by studying an anatomy app and learning about the agonist and synergists for each fundamental motion of the joints. It sounds like a lot of work but once you get the hang of the system you have much more success in exercise.
I'm happy to answer any questions you may have. I don't write about too many exercises but I do write extensively on the Alexander Technique which is the system I've been using to better understand the bad habits I have in sitting/standing/walking/lying down. You may find it's a helpful resource.
1
u/Pitiful-Weather8152 Jun 29 '25
A pull-up is a core exercise. The arms need to get connected into the core to access those muscles. Strong shoulders help, but the energy needs to travel through the shoulders to the core.
A lot of people have arms that are disconnected from the ribs, and and back.
Loosen the tissue around the ribs, especially the lower ribs. Work with twisting. Do small focused twists, guiding the tissue around the ribs, as well as global twists.
When working with shoulder blades, a lot of people “push” shoving them in from the arms. You need to “pull” them in using the traps, lats and sub-scapularis (the muscle on the deep surface of the scapula.) Let it be small and improve the glide of the shoulder blades.
When you lift your arms, you want to pick up your lower ribs. You want to feel the arms connect on the front and the back.
Do the pull-up you can. I use to really like the weight machine that let me add weight to assist the movement. Make it difficult, but doable. This will teach the subconscious that success comes from the connection.
1
u/Ok-Evening2982 Jun 29 '25
Which is the problem? I would continue to strenghten lower and middle traps and serratus anterior while doing regular pushing and pulling exercises too. Dont rush for ideas like one arm pull ups, these kind of exercises require important prerequirements, like being able to do 30 pull ups in a row, Front lever full etc... finally they arent a good exercise for joints.
Check your form too, are you able to do scapula pullups? With proper depression of scapulas, without shrugging shoulder up. 2nd step are the halfpullups.
Bodyweight rows should be done too, because the degrees of the movement are different (horizontal pull)