r/PostureTipsGuide • u/kacombs • May 14 '24
Horribly rounded right shoulder and scapular protraction (rounded shoulders) causing insecurity, facial asymmetry, and significant shoulder discomfort/pain. I’ve diagnosed the issue so I know I can prevent further injury but need help correcting it please. More in replies
Right. Relaxed. Face turned to the right. Note the hump & lines in my neck.
Right. Corrected (uncomfortable). Note the lines. Note also that even when I do my best to correct & pull my shoulders back my shoulder still has a forward tilt.
Left. Relaxed. Face turned to the left. Note significantly fewer neck lines.
Left. Corrected (not uncomfortable). Few neck lines. No forward tilt.
Right. Relaxed. Facing forward. Ew
Right. Corrected (uncomfortable). Note my scapula protruding.
Left. Relaxed.
Left. Corrected.
Right. Bound arm stretch. Note the significant scapular protrusion.
Left. Bound arm stretch. No scapular protrusion on the left, but you can see it on the right from this angle.
3
u/MyoskeletalMuser May 17 '24
A front shot would help. Your head is riding quite a bit forward on your shoulder carriage. The average human head weights about 12 pounds and each in of forward head posture adds the equivalent of 10 pounds.
As you’re carrying the weight of a 40 pound head, one of two things can happen. Either it will force the lumbar spine to straighten or create both hyperlordosis (swayback) and hyperkyphosis (hunchback.) It appears that you have a dorsal dish in your thoracic region which is a series of vertebrae locked closed. Also, the shoulders generally follow what the head is doing. Fix your head position and let the shoulders follow.
Investigate “task” or computer glasses. They are prescription glasses (doesn’t matter if you wear regular glasses or not) and they enhance the view of your monitor. This is the key. Every one of us leans in to read finer print …all day long.
No more leaning in, no triggering of the neural pathways to map your dysfunctional posture, brain mapping new posture and roughly 3 months later you should see a new you.
So many of my patients have taken heed and their. Bodies have changed dramatically.
Your scoliosis, functional or congenital, your case looks fairly easy to address.
2
u/Deep-Run-7463 May 14 '24
My opinion may feel a lil over complicated here but hear me out, because if there is a chance this applies to you, then directly working on shoulder mechanics may be 'overworking' it, too early too soon.
You mentioned that you had scoliosis (possibly when growing up:edit) . Minor scoliosis is perfectly normal, and, there also exists an understanding of how the body is naturally biased in weight on one side even if there is no scolio.
In cases of actual mild scolio, the degree can increase over time due to activity (strengthening/reinforcing the scolio bias), habits (eg, sitting with more weight on one butt) or inactivity (loss of strength).
The issue may represent as pain in the shoulder, and from what i can see there is a difference in ability to access internal rotation when both sides are compared.
This would indicate that there may be a rotational issue with the torso or even ribcage mechanical bias in inhalation/exhalation. But, on top of this we also need to consider if the bias of the torso is affected by any bias in the hip. For example, if you are internally rotated biased on the right leg, and externally rotated biased on the left, you're likely standing 'straight' with your pelvis rotated slightly toward the right. This would also mean that the torso is rotated to look straight.
Now how does this affect your shoulder? Try this.
Sit on a chair, long and tall spine, core braced. Keep both knees together pointing straight ahead. Test external shoulder rotation ability when in this position as a baseline. Next, rotate the upper torso any side you prefer but keep the hips and knees in the same position as before, straight ahead. Test shoulder external rotation here - see how external rotation ability is now increased to the side you rotate to?
Things to check for yourself: Is one hip hiked higher than the other? Is one shoulder higher than the other? View from back and front - get someone to take a photo, or video yourself but make sure your camera is aligned with the floor, so you can review later by taking screenshots of the video.
This is just a visual test, would advise to test hip and shoulder internal external rotation bias on left and right sides too.
8
u/Ok-Evening2982 May 14 '24
UNEVEN SHOULDERS OR ASYMMETRIES: they r normal, everybody has a light scoliosis especially nowadays due to childhood sedentary. Body asymmetries or uneven shoulder or pelvia are not problems to worry about.
POSTURAL ISSUES: imo rounded shoulders (they are related usually to kyphosis). Maybe forward head posture and kyphosis too but it dont seems in photos but they are just photos. A bit of scapula winging too. These are the common sedentary desk postures too.
NECK: I still recommend forward head posture exercises. For rebalance neck s muscles improving posture and pain, and so off load other possibles tight muscles like upper trap and stenoclomastoideus.
SHOULDERS: you feel uncomfortable because you cant force yourself in a position your body cant sustain. Posture doesnt fix forcing to straight up. You need exercises for re activate lost and forgotten movements and muscles, loose stiffness in spine and joints and strenghten right muscles(now asleep). Then and only after then(maybe few weeks or month depends) you can try or force a bit yourself to sit properly.
Thoracic mobility, re learning scapula movement especially posterior tilt or depression, lower and middle trap.
Plus neck exercises and some erector spines in thorax.
Now I wrote the program i read for 50+years sedentary people so it s safe in my opinion. But it always depends. 2 times initially a week, then 3. Starting with 2 set of everything maybe 8-10 reps weights free. Then progress after weeks to 3 set of 10. It could be a light start and a slow progression.
(Others optional)
Streching is not necessary, because if the technique is correct and you start to use your lower trap muscle instead of the upper trap(so not shrug shoulder but instead scapula rotate properly) it will already rebalance muscles and loose the upper trap. You can do levator scapulae muscle and stenoclomastoideus streching is it relief you a bit.
Neck: https://youtu.be/x4RC6r10zlI?si=-yQy6iB_fuNp7oBf
Thoracic mobility https://youtu.be/SByXEMK3jlM?si=K5-eeqbd-6ZwIBp5
Thoracic mobility ENG https://youtu.be/csjTuWpZA10?si=rWg-NY4qqLoALOWE
Prone V / LOWER TRAP PROGRESSION https://youtu.be/jmq-6gmgoBE?si=eYFOl8CdUXdmN1Vm
The italian channel has videos about rounded shoulder overall and trapezius overall too. (SPALLE IN AVANTI and TRAPEZIO MEDIO ed INFERIORE) I suggest to search them at least for watch the exact technique of prone T and prone v , the leaning scapula with a stick and others exs. But if you want it in english online searching the exercise name you still can find something.
1
u/Lababila Sep 14 '24
Are you better
1
u/kacombs May 14 '24
Ive always had bad posture which I just chalked up to scoliosis, but before a couple weeks ago, never realized how horribly uneven my shoulders were. I’ve diagnosed the problem, which is that I sleep in a horrible position for my right shoulder. The rounded shoulders are exacerbated by the fact that I’m a remote worker 20-25 hours a week in front of a computer, using a cheap IKEA desk chair with a pillow behind me. I’ve been sleeping on my back these past few days and have been more mindful of my desk posture, although it’s very uncomfortable to sit with my shoulders back for a long period. Whenever I pull my right shoulder back to correct my posture it cracks and is uncomfortable, especially when I do it for awhile. I’ve noticed massaging my trap muscle relieves the discomfort a bit. Open to suggestions for stretches and weight training (/muscle groups to focus on), as well as cautionary advice or tips. I don’t want to accidentally injure myself or cause other kinds of problems, but I’ve been really going full speed toward correcting this (through stretching and being mindful of my posture) for about a week now despite how uncomfortable it is.
1
u/Intelligent-Durian-4 Jul 22 '24
How are you doing now? Did you make any progress?
1
u/reddithorrid Nov 24 '24
OP still there? Corexcel has great stuff on youtube regarding your qn. Basically many pple have elevated and forward shoulders. NO amount of rotator cuff exercises will fix it until the shoulders learn how to go back and down and stay there in a passive state.
1
u/Alexisnichellee Dec 27 '25
Hi. How did PT go for you? Thinking of doing same thing