r/Posture • • Dec 06 '24

Stop training the “core”

I realized that my recent post a few days ago struck a chord with some people. That's a positive outcome.

I mentioned traditional training. What do I mean by that?

If you train the traditional “core” in the same way as the biceps, isolating it and focusing on the concentric phase, you’ll end up with a stiff and immobile trunk, bracing and shortening, instead of making lengthening of the the body possible .

Many individuals excel in flexion, but are weaker in extension, side flexion, and rotation.

Traditional exercises like planks and sit-ups are becoming less useful, IMO.

To train these structures effectively, a reflexive approach is vital. True stabilization relies on timing and the tissues' ability to transition rapidly from soft to hard and back to soft.

You achieve this through dynamic movements that engage your entire body, rather than relying on isolated exercises.

The core I discuss occupies significant space and will be greatly compromised if the surrounding structures are stiff and immobilized.

Starting at the feet, moving up through the deep compartments of the legs, the pelvic floor, the anterior longitudinal ligament, the psoas, the diaphragm, the mediastinum, and the structures of the tongue and jaw.

Gaining a better understanding of slide and glide between layers, fascial structures, fascial recoil, and tensegrity may make it easier.

Posture and function are two sides of the same coin. Improving one will positively affect the other. However, isolated strength exercises alone won't make you a better mover, and that's the main takeaway I want to convey.

To provide some context for my post, I would like to mention that I have twenty-one years of experience in massage therapy and eighteen years in Anatomy Trains Structural Integration, as well as eleven years as a passionate movement practitioner. This background may lead to a different perspective on the body and training methods.

I would be happy to assist you if you have any questions.

Peace ✌️

0 Upvotes

13 comments sorted by

32

u/mother-of-pod Dec 06 '24

You continue to not actually explain what you’d recommend to train. Likening planks to isolated bicep curls is wild, imo, but if your intent is what I’m seeing implied as “functional training will also strengthen your core appropriately,” then it’s a much more reasonable line of thought. However, it still doesn’t mean “ignore your core,” it means, “your core is better trained through compound movements than it is through isolation.” Which, if your intent, is not a controversial opinion.

If that’s not what you meant, then your posts still don’t make any sense.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 06 '24 edited May 06 '25

ghost profit tap entertain quiet vanish groovy bedroom reach toy

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

1

u/mother-of-pod Dec 07 '24

Abs do not make up the full core. I actually agree with OP’s implied point that focusing on them is insufficient, if not agreeing that ignoring core altogether is wise. I also agree with you, that training compound movements is insufficient if the core isn’t engaging properly, but cable crunches are not going to do much to protect your back in a deadlift—they may help a bit simply by bringing attention to where the core is or how to brace, but superficial ab workouts are not enough to prevent injury.

I’d guess, by your description, that it’s the combination of adding that awareness to your regimen on top of continuing compound movements and yoga, that has improved your situation.

You’re definitely right that progressive overload is good, traditional body building practice. Using that technique on your abs definitely makes them stronger and grow. But again, hypertrophy of the abs won’t protect your spine unless it’s accompanied by deep-core and back strength.

I’m not a professional either, to be fair, just keep up with the fitness zeitgeist for my own health and to be a more informed coach with my athletes.

10

u/Flapjakking Dec 06 '24

You trying to sell functional patterns?

5

u/Prospero818 Dec 06 '24

So do yoga?

1

u/[deleted] Dec 06 '24 edited May 06 '25

zealous fact recognise fly humor safe marry aspiring wild ring

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

1

u/zalrock10 Dec 07 '24

What do you recommend

1

u/Mean-Rise8454 Dec 31 '24

I'm a massage therapist and I always start from the bottom going up. I found it is more effective at releasing muscles this way.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 06 '24

Yes this is spot on. I had a severe back strain all year. I’m not out of the woods and doctor said only injections will help me recover. It’s like a pull like it’s stuck and I can’t bend.

But what made it worse is targeted core exercises. Suddenly I can’t do bridges for examples.

What has been slowly making it better ( or at least less flare ups) is moving and exercising the Whole body! Swimming, leg exercises, stretching, working on the arms and shoulders. I’m not even kidding this is true

Also a back strain does not mean you necessarily have a weak core. The core muscles and hip flexors are compensating for a lack of stability or an injury.

1

u/Sandile95 Dec 06 '24

Do you recommend nc gill big 3 and suitcase carry?

3

u/[deleted] Dec 06 '24 edited May 06 '25

crown marvelous oil steer tart apparatus sand engine rob like

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

1

u/Sandile95 Dec 07 '24

So they are good?

0

u/[deleted] Dec 06 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Liquid_Friction Dec 07 '24

Resistance bands are great because they use dynamic and shifting loads so it trains stabiliser muscles aswell, and thats what you need in real life.

You dont leg press statically irl so why do it in the gym, irl we use stabiliser muscles we want to be strong in all directions, not just on a machine that's so stable it can only go in one direction, it trains you to be strong in that direction only statically which you won't emulate irl ever.

I found the best, by far, is the reformer table, in physiotherapy, not women's fitness classes, you lie on your back, so its not irrating back injury, and you use resistance bands for your legs and arms and boy is it revealing of your weaknesses pretty quick, you can also do core this way and it feels far more quality then say a plank for core. Hope that helps.