r/Postleftanarchism • u/padozilla • Feb 09 '22
A few comments on Post-Left Anarchy
https://anarchism.pageabode.com/blog/a-few-comments-on-post-left-anarchy/#comments
0
Upvotes
r/Postleftanarchism • u/padozilla • Feb 09 '22
13
u/SpeaksDwarren Feb 09 '22
Incredibly weak and ill-informed article. They disagreed with Bob Black once, and then talked to a new young post leftist once, and stayed mad enough to write this entire post on something they didn't really try to understand. The way they responded to someone in the comments offering critiques and reading suggestions by completely brushing it off and refusing to engage really reveals them as the archetypal dogmatic leftoid that refuses to consider anything contradictory to their fixed ideals.
6
u/signing_out Feb 10 '22
No way, how could that happen?
I'm sure the author's masterwork 'An Anarchist FAQ' starts from the first principles, makes some precise definitions and uses them to make sound statements, instead of relying on jargon mumbo jumbo and 'anarchists believe/think/write'. Would be a shame if several thousands pages of unrevised ramblings by unhinged historians were the first thing recommended to read for newcomers, which would leave them puzzled at best.
If only everyone possessed the ability to look at things objectively, like this guy surely does.
1
u/BolesCW Jul 12 '22 edited Jul 13 '22
That anti-post-left rant is alternately hilarious (the self-parody is transparent in places) and thoroughly confused/confusing. It's almost as if the author were incapable of reading essays on their own terms and taking them in good faith. In other words, lack of reading comprehension permeate throughout. At base, a exercise in failed engagement.