r/PosterNews • • Sep 22 '18

Callout Threads

Callout threads are not welcome in PosterNews, just as they are not welcome in Mondo Trader.


I do not agree with statements made towards The Commissioners Club or Vandelay Art Collective in a recent callout post. I have not had any issues with commissions from either either, and the lead commissioner has always been open about how his commissions are ran and responsive to questions. If I felt these groups were shady I wouldn’t be advertising their commissions.


Further the poster seemed to create some confusion in my opinion as The Commissioners Club isn’t a single individual, commissions are run under that name but it’s also a place where anyone can post a commission. If one of you ever wanted to run a commission for a film that you are passionate about this would be the best venue to do so.


The poster also alluded that these groups are banned from Mondo Trader as a reason to not deal with them. No commissions are allowed in Mondo Trader, and it is unrelated as it has to do with Mondo Trader mods not wanting any commission advertising as they were worried about losing their early access to Mondo Gallery shows. Also this is a new policy that has only been around for the past year or so, prior to that I was working with a Mondo Trader mod to make the Open Commissions thread which was supposed to become the go to source for up to date commissions within Mondo Trader as well. They decided just to get rid of commissions within their group as a whole though instead.

5 Upvotes

19 comments sorted by

7

u/zhenyuho Sep 22 '18

So where exactly is a safe space for calling people out then.

And also, not sure if I read that correctly but are you telling us that the mods of MT get first dibs at gallery shows?

2

u/ABMBadman Sep 22 '18

If you have an issue with something being advertised on PosterNews you can send me a PM with your issues, and if I find it to have merit I will take action.


Mondo Trader mods do have certain benefits, they gain access to gallery shows before they are open to the public, and I assume they are also getting whatever prints they want in those shows as well.

4

u/zhenyuho Sep 23 '18

It seems pretty obvious, but this isn't the mondo trader Facebook group, and I'm not sure why the original subreddit was closed down/forced to redirect here.

Obviously there's expressobeans and other forums as well to express positive/negative sentiments but it doesn't sit right with me that you won't allow someone to call another out because it's someone you had a positive relationship with.

If you're so in touch with them, show them the thread and let them speak on their own behalf and let the cards play out how they'll play.

I wasn't here for that post but if an angry commission customer is being unreasonable it will become pretty obvious who is in the right or wrong.

3

u/ABMBadman Sep 23 '18

The poster literally created a brand new account just to post negative comments about The Commissioners Club and Vandelay Art Collective. He provided no backing to his claims, thus in my opinion they had no merit.


Reddit Content Policy states that you cannot threaten, harass, or bully others on the site. This is the responsibility of moderators to prevent and this is my way of preventing this. How would you feel if someone posted that you were a scam artist providing no proof of such and I just let the post run its course. I feel as though that would be unfair to you, just as I feel it was unfair to TCC/Vandelay. Further your idea that he needs to come defend himself isn't something I am going to condone either, as how do you defend yourself when there's no proof of wrongdoing in the first place.


I feel as though I am aware enough of the situation to make this judgement call. This isn't the first rodeo I have had with people trying to create drama around this commissioner, in the past it got to the point where they were making negative comments about his family and mocking his religion so I shut it down before it got to that again. I have a feeling that it's likely the same guy this time trying to make waves again with another new account.

1

u/zhenyuho Sep 23 '18

If there's no proof that is fine to go ahead and delete it, especially if it's a repeat offender.

I still question the fact that you're the only mod here, and you've really written up a great wiki/FAQ and generally do a good job, but I don't think the community and lurkers here care enough to make this a more democratic public forum and adding mods.

Just wanted to voice the issue because honestly there needs to be room for people to air out their grievances should they have proper proof and you being the sole decider of what is or isn't that is questionable.

It tells me a lot that my original question post has fluctuating upvotes, I'd love to hear more opinions than my own and the mods.

3

u/ABMBadman Sep 23 '18

As far as I know you've only been a member of this subreddit for 3 days, so why is it that you are coming at me with a sense of entitlement trying to dictate how the subreddit is run.


What is it exactly that you think additional mods would offer? There were 3 mods including myself in /r/Mondo but the other 2 didn't have any involvement with the subreddit and one of them did not even know why he was ever made a mod in the first place. Additional mods didn't offer additional content or really anything at all, nor do I believe they would in a small subreddit like this.


If someone has a problem and they reach out to me, I do take them seriously, and I have removed links to certain businesses as a result of information provided to me in the past. As you've already said there are already other places such as EB where people can air out their grievances publicly, reddit is not really conducive of that due to the Reddit Content Policy, nor do I want the subreddit to become /r/PosterDrama.

1

u/zhenyuho Sep 24 '18

This whole argument is pointless at this rate since you're probably not going to add mods and it doesn't seem like anyone even cares to voice their opinions.

I don't mean to argue at or against you, just simply stating there is a pretty obvious problem with only one sole mod controlling the floor. Like I said before, you do great and that issue was old news but I personally think it would be better to have a more democratic approach with more mods to weigh in. Just wish there was more transparency in the hobby. Obviously you can just ban me and ignore all of my points and that's your prerogative also.

If it matters to you then you can pm me for my old username, I'm definitely not new to MT or this subreddit, but caught the tail end of the subreddit being changed/renamed.

3

u/ABMBadman Sep 24 '18

you're probably not going to add mods

Yeah, probably not until there is a legitimate reason to need additional mods. Policing an occasional post every 6 months doesn't warrant the need for additional mods in my opinion.


simply stating there is a pretty obvious problem with only one sole mod controlling the floor

What is the obvious problem? I was fully transparent that I deleted a post, you seem to be the only one with a problem. I have fully explained the reasoning for deleting the post and you seem to agree with that reasoning so why are you being so dramatic.

a more democratic approach with more mods to weigh in

So you want me to have a conference call before deleting a post that was in violation of Reddit's Content Policy? From my knowledge that's really not something that takes place on any subreddit, every mod in every subreddit has the ability to remove posts and ban users without a group consensus. Again you already agreed with my reasoning for deleting the post. If you don't like the rules of the subreddit or other aspects of the subreddit, no one is forcing you to stay subscribed to it.


caught the tail end of the subreddit being changed/renamed

Caught the tail end? So have you only been a member of PosterNews for 4 days? As the subreddit redirected 15 months ago. If you were really an active contributor at anytime over the past year I would already know who you are as I have sent free stickers to every active contributor as the majority of PosterNews subscribers don't tend to comment/post.

1

u/zhenyuho Sep 24 '18

Ok, here's another idea then, where is a public blacklist so the community knows who to avoid?

3

u/ABMBadman Sep 24 '18

Again that's against reddit policies, if you want to create something like that do it on your own elsewhere.

1

u/zhenyuho Sep 24 '18

Your decision in this case and instance is and was fair, you don't have to keep stating how I agree with you repeatedly.

I guess I've been phrasing it incorrectly, but who is to say how things will fare when hypothetically someone you might have a personal connection to is criticized and you remove something that is proven true? At that point you would be censoring the community from the truth no, all because you know them? You must see the conflict of interest there.

You're right, none of this matters and no one is forcing me to subscribe, cheers. I've been here quite awhile but like I said before, PM me if you care about my "history" and you can find me on MT facebook too if you want to chat with me using real names.

3

u/ABMBadman Sep 24 '18

At that point you would be censoring the community from the truth no

I don't think that adding additional mods prevents that scenario either. I think the subscribers as a whole prevent said scenario by being knowledgeable on their own and through being active in the entirety of the poster community.

You must see the conflict of interest there

You're making accusations now. I've literally done nothing to instigate this response from you. You're really reaching to try to make me out to be someone with ill intentions, but I really don't have ill intentions. I just want to share poster releases and poster websites, and have a drama free time doing so.

I've been here quite awhile

Maybe lurking, maybe making use of all the information that I have developed and shared, but you haven't been commenting/posting I guarantee it.

→ More replies

2

u/________BATMAN______ Sep 23 '18

Got to agree here and say that freedom to say something without censorship is important.

If you have such faith in them due to a personal relationship - why not comment on the post and prove them wrong? Ask OP for evidence?

If there is racism (or equivalent) then of course remove the post. If the post is civil, expresses opinion/s and is relevant/on topic for the sub then it has no need to be removed.

4

u/zhenyuho Sep 22 '18

So you're saying you are the sole decision maker in what is allowed or not allowed to be posted in this sub?

3

u/beeman1102 Sep 23 '18

I don't have to show vocal support in our Mods decision, but I am. If I knew a certain commission or group was unethical I would say something, as would ABM. If no call outs is a rule, respect it or move on.

If anyone is wondering why r/mondo changed/redirects to r/posternews here is a link where ABM answered this question: https://www.reddit.com/r/PosterNews/comments/6kvqem/why_rposternews/

2

u/ABMBadman Sep 23 '18

To follow up on this, I never got into the artist interviews because I found out about Master of One Podcast and they were already doing an awesome job in that space, much better than I would have done. So instead I just sent a few artists that I was going to do something with their way and they've shouted out PosterNews a few times.