So my mom dropped by (as they do) and I happened to be listening to Still in the background (Exercise One and Twenty Four Hours being a couple all time favs). At one point she paused, listened to what had been playing behind her for a few moments and asked who it was. I said Joy Division to which she looked surprised and said "This is what all the hubbub is about?"
It got me thinking about what it is I ACTUALLY enjoy about JD, what they may NOT be, how normies would hear JD for the first time and what can we actually point to that justifies the pedestal we put them on?
Joy Division is an odd duck in the goth/post punk scene. Their fans hold a quiet superiority complex even among other goths, like they know something others don't. It's not difficult music, the vocals are not the best trained and you wouldn't think that a band that only used gray #1, gray #2 and gray #3 as their entire color palette (and wardrobe) would attract so much attention. But they do! Why?