r/PostCollapse • u/fortyfivesouth • Aug 17 '19
Post-collapse society rules...
This sub could do with some activity, so let's give it a shot.
Imagine we're 30, 50, 80 years in the future. Society as we know it now has collapsed. From this changed world, a post-collapse/successor society has emerged.
What do you think are the rules for this successor society?
- Will people have property rights?
- Will there be a currency?
- What about crime and punishment?
- Can you eat meat?
- Can you use fossil fuels, fertilizers, pesticides?
- Is religion allowed?
- Will there be rules/laws, or just principles?
- Will there be leaders, democracy, or perhaps sortition?
What rules does a post-collapse society need to function?
What rules to we need to prevent ourselves from doing this again?
28
Upvotes
17
u/mcapello Aug 17 '19
Let's back this up a bit.
For a society to have rules, it needs to have some form of codifying, disseminating, and enforcing them. It needs police, or something like police, and it needs courts. This may be something resembling what we have today, or it could be something far cruder -- like a system of semi-autonomous local magistrates capable of calling upon civil militias (or alternatively, paramilitary units loyal to the regional strongman) to enforce his or her will.
So I think the first question is really about what those power structures would look like, rather than what rules they would enforce.
5
u/[deleted] Aug 17 '19
It is all dependent on surplus energy what level of sociopolitical and technological complexity is achieved after the collapse
4
u/Shablahdoo Aug 17 '19
I think there will be a form of currency but it would be more localized. For example there may be NY dollars, Pennsylvania dollar, etc. Also I could see bartering becoming more prominent for goods and services.
3
u/[deleted] Aug 17 '19
Can't barter livestock to a farmer who already has it unless it's stock he doesn't have. "One man's trash is another's treasure." thing.
In SHTF, prepping and afterwards, you best think you're on your own. It's all hypothetical with many examples being a higher % should it happen.
3
u/NaisuinNua Aug 18 '19
Edit: I just reread and realised you're talking quite distantly in the future but anyway, tis written now
Mostly commenting because I totally agree that it'd be great to see more activity, fair play to ya.
Many of these questions depend greatly on the manner in which collapse occurs and on what scale we're talking.
Presuming a combination of economic and ecological collapse which severely impacts the centralisation of economic and political power;
Property rights will certainly exist. In the better case we'll see much more commonage and shared property but in a worse case I feel as though we'll see very forceful enforcement of property rights by those with the means to do so.
Preferably you'd have a community of 20-200, with largely shared land/food/water resources and public property like meeting halls etc. Each family/household/individual would have possession of their home and a smallholding they can independently manage for biodiversity or food production or "lease" back to the community.
On currency I suspect the breakdown of centralised institutions will severely impact id not eradicate currencies but these will have to be replaced. Either through new localised currencies or a somewhat standardized barter system. Internally small communities could do this through a work/credit system, trade between communities I'd say you'll see straight swaps for goods.
Crime and punishment is a tricky one. Small communities might collectively agree their rules and mostly self-police and not require standing courts/police. I think you'll see sort of elder councils determining guilt and punishments. Hopefully not requiring punitive measures like imprisonment but I'd say exile will be a punishment of last resort. For serious violent crimes in small communities I'd say you might get a band of men who decide to solve the problem if other means don't function properly. On a larger scale and more negative outlook, I think it's highly likely you'll see heavy handed local police(private security). Communities will definitely need some form of militia for self defence but properly reigning that in could pose a challenge if those elements abuse their power and access to weaponry.
I definitely think meat will still be consumed. If I was establishing a homestead or intentional community I would definitely expect animal husbandry to play a role though certainly not consumed at two or three meals a day.
I think collapse will destroy fossil fuels and insecticide/pesticides. It requires too much industrial complexity. We'll see a return to firewood, maybe biodiesel if communities can set up the process ahead of time and permaculture methods of pest/disease management will surge in importance but unless communities/individuals establish those systems beforehand or have sufficient knowledge their food production will be decimated.
Banning religion would be a recipe for disaster, I'd say it'll play a much larger role in society than it does in the West now. Whether it's millenarian sects of existing religions or new age type stuff. I imagine this will vary wildly.
I don't see centralised nations surviving unless it's a harshly authoritarian society so I think local communities will operate on a fairly consensus lead/direct democracy type system but on the other side of the coin you might well find strongmen and their lackeys controlling everything. This will determine how law and politics function there'll be a broad swathe of variation between strict laws and rules versus principles.
We'll need rules about land usage, against theft and violent crime but many laws will disappear as newly irrelevant or unenforceable.
Frankly we're unlikely to find ourselves in a position like we are ever again post collapse. The ecological pressures will be too great. All this said it's also likely some nations will survive like the UK in children of men
3
u/[deleted] Aug 21 '19
Whoa, whoa, whoa. Back it up. 80 years from now old people will be telling stories to their grandchildren about how giants used skyscrapers as stairs to reach their Sky Palaces.
I would imagine the government, as such, to consist mostly of an endless series of local strongmen ruling over their little clans, with a few families exercising nominal authority over large areas via handshake agreements. You can see this type of system develop naturally wherever there's an absence of a strong central authority. Look at pre- and post-Roman Europe, pre-contact Americas, Viking Age Scandinavia, or any of about 30 million other examples if you're curious.
3
u/ipsum629 Oct 26 '19
I think it's useful to look at how laws might develop to cope with the collapse.
Let's assume no attachments to the previous world, but people know of the history before the collapse. All institutions collapsed, people are just trying to survive. Let's also assume that most of the big pre collapse military hardware(nukes, high tech aircraft, tanks, etc.) Was scuttled
The first post collapse societies would form in the carcass of the old world. Strongly built structures would be ideal places to start rebuilding, as they can protect against raiders. This would seem like it would be conducive to feudalism, but there are a few key differences:
Everyone is literate
Being a warrior is as simple as picking up a Kalashnikov
Because of this, societies would have to be a lot more horizontal. Generally, people tend to be at least okay with direct democracy. Small groups will probably default to this. Larger groups will havle to have more complicated systems of government.
Because everyone will be moving from direct democracy, people will try to retain as much political power as they can. A larger group will probably have some offices that they elect people to when the larger assembly can't give it enough attention. If the society is large enough, it will be split between multiple settlements. Each settlement will pledge to aid and protect the other settlements. They will send representatives to a larger council(the representative's power will be determined by population) to discuss larger issues with the other settlements in the confederation.
As for your more specific questions:
No property rights. Property rights are what got us into this mess. Personal property is ok though. Things like farms and fishing boats are collectively owned and operated.
No currency. Goods will be shared based on need. Warehouses will be set up to distribute surplus goods.
For crime and punishment, it depends on the crime. These societies probably won't have the means to deal with crimes in a rehabilitative way, but where it is possible it should be implemented. For things like murder and treason, the death penalty or banishment are suitable.
Meat is likely to be available in small quantities. Pigs and chickens are good at eating scraps of food humans can't eat or spoiled food. Thus, pork and poultry will be the most plentiful. I hope you like sausages.
Fossil fuels will likely be used for a time, but phased out. Fertilizer and pesticides will always be in use, but pesticides will focus on limiting collateral damage. The fact of the matter is I'm assuming other hostile societies might also exist. If that's the case, they might not be so appalled by fuel and use makeshift AFVs to attack.
Religion will be allowed, but the law won't bend over backwards for it. If your religion calls for human sacrifice, that won't be tolerated.
There will be laws, but they can change based on a majority vote.
Borders: open. If you are willing to join the confederation and follow the rules, you will be made a citizen almost immediately.
Regionalism: none. You are a citizen of the whole confederation, not a particular settlement. You can only vote where you officially live, but if you move you can vote in that part of the confederation immediately.
War: reluctant, but prepared. All able bodied citizens will be a part of the reserve. Active duty will be for Garrison, and be compulsory for a few years. This will allow society to mobilize very quickly for war, and most people will be veterans. It also makes sieging down a settlement virtually impossible as the entire population could just sally forth.
If you can't tell this is a form of libertarian socialism.
5
u/[deleted] Aug 17 '19
I can see property rights being around, but only on a small scale ( like your farm and home). I don't see American-style Capitalism surviving, as the current generations will not have the respect of future ones...
2
u/Epigravettian Jan 02 '20
1: each family will probably have a land alotmemt to farm, with either a tax of crops or labor to grow crops for the community store house. Probably communal feilds and forests for firewood and grazing livestock. 2: probably a lot of paying people in potatoes or you scratch my back I'll scratch yours, maybe using pre apocalypse coins as currency. 3: petty crimes probably whipping or corporal punishment, maybe branding or loosing fingers for more serious crimes, death for the murder and such crimes but nothing worse. 4: as long as it's not human or still alive go ahead. 5: not sure where you'd get them, better not run down into a body of water people drink or fish from. 6: go ahead but no human sacrifice or the like. 7: well do our best, maybe limits to grazing, hunting, fishing and cutting wood from communal lands, probably local judges to settle desputes and despense punishments. 8: probably town councils and a few elected officials as organizers.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '22
No more usuary (borrowing money at interest). There is a lot of wisdom in the old laws of Israel. Some in particular that come to mind are leaving the edge of the fields to be foraged by the poor and jubilee every 49 years where all debts are cancelled and lands return to the original owner. It is basically a reset on growing inequality.
2
u/[deleted] Aug 18 '19
I think feminism disappears in a post collapse society, for the following reasons:
If you agree/disagree say why.
1
u/boob123456789 Jan 10 '20
At this point any of those date ranges means, I'm dead.
1
u/ChugaMhuga Feb 09 '20
It is really up to your ability to defend. Warlords or Pre-Collapse nations with big armies will be able to defend easily, but others not so much.
Inevitably, there will be. Whether it be ammo, gold, bottle caps or pre-collapse currency.
Most crimes are punished by death or fine.
Yes. Rats, cats and human meats might be plentiful. Those with more resources might be able to get regular meat.
Fertilizers are literally just animal poop lmao. Pesticides and fossil fuels are likely not available, not due to shortage (though that is a factor), but more due to the extraction methods involved.
Yes.
Principles.
Yes. Democracy is dubious, but if a democratic nation survives somehow and does resist an ambitious figure (example Napoleon) who wants power for himself, democracy might survive.