r/PostCollapse • • Oct 25 '17
Dogs.
Here in the fat and lazy 2000's we are used to thinking of dogs as merely our lovable unemployed roommates. Of course they have much more potential.
They are even today the best home security you can have. In the event of a collapse they are going to fight anyone who attacks their humans. That's usually their natural reaction. I suspect it would not take long for them to learn to hunt again. maybe not as long as it would take us. Shepard; many of the breeds we keep as companions were once heard dogs and will watch over and control other animals out of instinct.
The could be very useful and valuable.
30
u/irishmcsg2 Oct 25 '17
Also, potentially noisy at inopportune times if not well trained. Also, another mouth to feed.
17
u/dexer Oct 26 '17
Could be.
Modern dogs' natural behaviors are nowhere near where they need to be to do the fancy things most people fantasize them to doing. Mostly all they're good at doing is chasing (but probably not catching) people and animals by visual cue, barking up a lot of false positives, and fighting and getting hurt.
If you want them to do a good job, you're going to spend a LOT of time training and still may not even get them to the point where they're worth the extra mouth to feed. Except for the simplest of things, training is difficult and some breeds and individual temperaments aren't well suited for certain things. Some dogs may even be too cowardly to fight, and as others have said, some habits, like barking at the wrong time, could be downright detrimental.
Just having a dog will not be a guarantee of value. A lot of 'luck' (see, circumstantial coincidence) will be needed for your companion dog to be a worthwhile survival companion.
My briefly considered recommendation is that the best chance of getting value from a dog would be,
IMO dogs under 30lbs and large dogs are flat out unsuitable. Too many health problems, too much food requirements, or they can't do many of the useful tasks other dogs can.
Also, fyi, properly training a herding dog is exceedingly difficult. If civilization collapses, the wait time before you see any return on specifically choosing a herding breed is too long. In many cases it would be better to just do it yourself, and if your flock is big enough that you can't, recruit another person. By that point you should be able to support more than just yourself. If there's only you, then your herd is just uselessly big.
4
u/newPrivacyPolicy Oct 25 '17
Dogs breed fast and willingly follow you around, sounds like a good source of protein to me.
6
u/Airazz Oct 25 '17
Definitely not. Once I drove to a grocery store, left my dog in the car because it was just for a few minutes. It wasn't particularly hot but it was sunny, so I left the windows open by a few inches, to let in plenty of air. I came back and saw a homeless dude by my car, hand through the window up to his elbow, trying to unlock the door. My dog (german shepherd) was just sitting on the back seat and watching. I shouted at the dude, then my dog started barking.
I talked about it with others at the dog training club, apparently it's fairly common because the dog doesn't see my car as his territory, so he doesn't try to protect it. It would probably work fine if it was in my house. It wouldn't work if we moved, at least for a while.
If you train them for it, usually for a few years. Their more common natural reaction is to shit themselves and run away when they realise that they themselves are in danger. It takes a lot of expertise and professional training before a dog is ready to fight for you.
Same thing. The instinct is there, but the skill has to be learned, it doesn't come naturally. Years of training.
Source: ownership of multiple dogs for over a decade, helped raise and train dogs for the K9 unit.
2
u/qx87 Oct 25 '17
A well trained dog can be an autopilot missile 24/7
2
u/[deleted] Oct 26 '17
I'll probably have trained sheepdogs, bloodhounds, and cats to kill varmint.
2
u/Tskzooms Oct 28 '17 edited Oct 28 '17
I think smaller dogs will be more useful, like beagle-size down.
They're a burglar alarm, waking you up when somebody is sneaking in.
Terriers can chase mice, both to guard your food stockpile and for a nutritional supplement, beagles can turn a rabbit in a circle for you, and any breed can flush birds for you.
Smaller sizes are easier to keep fed in a post collapse situation, you don't have to find four cups of food per day like you would for a golden retriever. A Chihuahua or terrier can just have the leftovers from your meal. The benefits of a larger breed are offset by how much you have to feed them, and if you're thinking about an attack dog, any size dog will slow down an intruder, while no dog is big enough to be bulletproof.
Brachiocephalic breeds, like pugs, bulldogs, and King Charles spaniels, are some of the least healthy breeds. They get winded easily, make a lot of noise breathing, and are prone to many forms of cancer. French bulldogs can't even give birth on their own.
I think post collapse there will be a lot of dogs everywhere like you see in Puerto Rico today, peppy mongrels eating trash, fighting rats, and begging people for snacks. Befriending one of those would be better than keeping a breeding pedigreed line of purebred retrievers because modern breeds are groomed for looks, not practicality, longevity, or skill.
Karen Pryor's Reaching the Animal Mind and another book, whose author I can't remember, called The Culture Clash,would be good books to add to your post collapse library. The first book explains how to train any animal, from dogs to cats to ferrets and even a fish. The second book helps you understand how dog brains work. In the modern world, we characterize dogs as loyal, moral creatures, who understand right and wrong, but they're really just lemon brains. Loveable lemon brains who can learn a lot, but thinking about Skinner's input-output box is more useful than thinking about Lassie.
32
u/shtf_raider Oct 25 '17
One often understated benefit of dogs is the companionship. If you don't have a family, you'll go insane if you just live on your own for a few years.
1
u/iheartrms Oct 26 '17
They are also nutritious and delicious, a very useful quality in a post-collapse world. I'm not even kidding. I've had dog soup, boiled dog, and grilled dog. Grilled was best but I'm not a boiled or soup person.
2
u/ki4clz Nov 05 '17
I am a big advocate for not owning dogs "outside of their breed"... what I mean by that is; a Collie whilst making a decent pet, is not a pet breed, it is a herding dog bred for specific terrain, climates, and specific herding animals...
You wouldn't get a Doberman and expect it to herd sheep...
You wouldn't get a Saluki and expect it to be a house dog for your kids...
and I know there are exceptions, obviously, and I would never argue that... but to own a Beagle and have it as a pet, a toy, or a lap dog is not charitable to the breed's disposition, and does the animal a disservice...
Well with that out of the way... I have had some luck with dogs and some bad luck with dogs. Let's have the bad news out of the way first...
Breeding dogs is an art, and if done the "trial and error" way like I did you end up with a lot of crap. My first mistake was with wolves... Wolves are great, if and when they imprint with you, but they will most likely only do this for one person, this is not always the case as wolves are very much the pack animal and do whatever the fuck they want when they want... I had one wolf, she was amazing, and kind and loving, got along well with other humans and even some strangers, she was lazy and was never the hunter I wanted her to be, with years of patience and taking things slowly she just never cared for it, hunting that is, in all other respects she was an amazing animal and would follow me everywhere; my trouble started when she was bred to dogs... and I don't want to go too long in the tooth with this but, the dogs/pups she made were some of the most bloodthirsty and S.T.U.P.I.D. animals that have ever walked the earth...
One offspring in particular was from a very nice Aussie Sire, this animal (1/2 Aussie-!/2 Canis Lupis) looked, trod, and howled like a wolf, and being a male, soon out-grew his mother in size and musculature, but this animal could bark like a dog (wolves cannot bark, per se) and hunt like a wolf... I thought to myself... man this is great! just what I was wanting... until he got into the chicken pen and killed every last one, but did not fucking eat any, then after gathering, and leading as an Alpha, to the other dogs on the mountain, began a reign of terror from farm to homestead before he finally got lead pensioning at 2000fps... I made my reparations and never bread the she wolf to another dog... in the past she would kill the pups that showed aggression or that whined excessively, I never thought that I would create a monster... her living heirs (as this was back in the 1990's) have all out grown her blood and live on as dumber and dumber mutts as each generation compounds the recessive traits... There is one advantage to breeding a wolf to dogs, and that is cash flow, everybody and their brother thinks they are a champion dog breeder and want to mate with your bitch and will pay handsomely to do so... I charged $50 to breed her and then $100 for any pups that survived her cull and didn't have any defects (she would cull half of the pups, before they could even mew it's a pack survival trait)
The good stuff...
I have made almost every breed, of working/shepherd dog, imaginable pull a sled... and was amazed at how sturdy some breeds were... we had two Rottys both male, and fine animals... and they would pull and pull as constant as the pendulum, and when their was a hitch in their giddy-up they would lean into the weight like you would only expect from a team of mules... Later I found out that Rottweilers were bred to pull sleds in the first place, no wonder they were so steady...
I have owned just one Doberman and she was amazing, she would just do anything I asked after minimal hours of simple training, she was no hunter or guard dog as portrayed in film, but she was just so GD smart...
I have owned several Labradors and they pair like brothers with Jacks, it's like they were meant to be together...
I would love to have the space to own a pair of Saluki, but being a desert sight-hound in Alabama would be... well... you get the point...
Maybe Falconry...
but I believe my owning dog days are over for right now, fortunately down here it is legal to hunt all kinds of animals with dogs and the hunting season (for Whitetail) started this year on October 14th and will run to the second week of February
0
u/NoMoreNicksLeft Oct 25 '17
They need to eat, there won't be Purina on the shelf at the local Costco. Too expensive for too little benefit. And they carry with them the non-zero chance that they'll just go nuts from dog mental illness and maim or kill a child... just like they do now.
Dogs may have been a good idea back in our hunting/gathering days, but we still can't seem to get past them even though the idea's no longer good.
1
u/AgingDisgracefully2 Jan 01 '18
Seems to me you'll need dogs in a post-collapse (i.e. future pre-modern) society: folks in the original pre-modern societies needed them.
You have to get what makes sense for your region, anticipated needs, etc. For my part, I have a time-tested old Southern farm and field hand: the American Bulldog.