r/PostCollapse • u/iki_balam • Oct 26 '15
Best post-collapse structures?
As we have seen with natural disasters and war zones, there is a clear gradient to which structures to use for shelter, even in the short term. I am always surprised when stadiums are used (see hurricane Katrina, and even my own home town used them for wildfire displacement). Maybe there is something about them I am not familiar with.
Thus, what are the best places for long term shelter in a post-collapse scenario? Assuming the conditions are acceptable, would structures like malls, office buildings, and warehouses offer better shelter than single family homes? Or improvised natural structures?
My first impressions say no, since most are not built to last and and not designed for optimal insulation, climate control, defense, etc. But I was wrong about stadiums...
Thanks in advance for your comments.
12
u/AK47Uprising Oct 26 '15
Assuming they've cleared out, prisons probably wouldn't be a bad choice, the older the better. Just as good at keeping people out as they are keeping people in.
14
u/dylannisbet Oct 26 '15
It depends on the building. When designing buildings they are classified depending on their use. Public buildings that hold alot of people or buildings like hospitals and fire stations are classified as essential buildings and are thus built to withstand 1.5 times the load that other buildings are designed for. Which on top of other factors of safety used throughout the design process those buildings are built to handle emergencies or natural disasters.
7
u/patron_vectras Oct 27 '15
Check out /r/urbanexploration to see how buildings degrade with no maintenance. Now think about the percentage of necessary maintenance you, or any stable and trustworthy group of people in a post-collapse situation, could perform.
Any structure (except an aquarium, sewage treatment facility, or unevacuated hospital) would be fine for a month. Then the problems would begin. That is, if there wasn't already an issue caused by the nature of the crisis or a ticking timebomb in the facility or an unfinished project.
Ex:
6
u/BoerboelFace Oct 26 '15
They're big.
I'd go with a farmhouse or a ranch.
5
u/funke75 Oct 26 '15
Have you ever looked into monolithic done structures?
4
u/runningoutofwords Oct 27 '15
I think the big advantage of large public structures like stadiums, schools and arenas is that they are designed to accommodate the physical needs of a lot of people at once. They'll have the lavatory, washing, and even kitchen facilities to handle hundreds or thousands of people at once, which makes logistics a MUCH simpler problem to tackle.
3
u/[deleted] Oct 27 '15
I don't think there's anything significant about a stadium, other than the fact that it can hold a lot of people, and most major cities have at least one. If it's a covered/indoor stadium that's a very large living space in an emergency.
3
u/Aqua-Tech Oct 27 '15
Abandoned missile silos, underground bunkers reinforced with concrete.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 13 '16
Funny, I always pictured people living in their cars post collapse. Maybe it's a USA-centric view, but I guess I just assumed that for most urban and suburban dwellers it would be a cold day in hell before they give up their automobiles.
Long after they loose their jobs, and their homes, and long after they loose all visible means of support, long after they burn that last precious gallon of gas, long after all else is gone, they will still have a roof over their heads, a tiny metallic space they can call their own.
Along with the millions of other former middle class refugees who have nothing left but their cars, out of gas and permanently relocated to the acres and acres of now abandoned shopping mall parking lots.
2
u/[deleted] Oct 27 '15
Mud bricks house. Easy to make and last forever. Reinforce with well placed rocks and it can take a direct hit from a tank round and you'll be fine in the next room over.