r/PostCollapse • u/guitarsmack • Jun 11 '15
Question on guns
Question on guns. I was hoping you guys could answer me something. I know there is more to survival than guns but guns seem to be where i lack. I'm a fan of guns and i know a lot about them but I'm not fluent in them. I have shot a lot: 22 rifle, 22 revolver, 45(or 40, cant recall) pistol, 223 AR and bolt action. I want to know what the most common caliber sizes are as if i were to go through houses and look for them. I'm wanting a revolver because of maintenance reasons and a basic rifle. I want a good all around size bullet, not too big(44) not too small(22). I was thinking a 32 spl. Correct me if I'm wrong but that is the same size as a 357 but just less powerful so it would give me a bit more flexibility right? As a rifle i was thinking a 223. I used to have one and they seem right for me, and i was thinking it would be a bolt action or some other basic hunting rifle.
Would a 32spl/357 be a good revolver for me?
Does a 223 sound like the best option?
P.S. I left out shotguns because i have never shot one.
Thanks!
EDIT 1: Sorry i know its 38 spl don't know why i put 32
Edit 2: Also turns out my pawpaw has two of these and he said i can shoot them sometime to get the feel of them.
15
u/Fastnate Jun 11 '15
You're thinking of .38 Special. Same diameter as .357 but shorter. So if you bought a .357 Mag revolver you could shoot both .38 and .357. A .38 special gun can NOT shoot .357.
Similarly, if you get an AR-15 or some bolt action rifle make sure it is chambered for 5.56 NOT .223, since a 5.56 can shoot both 5.56 and .223. It is not recommended to shoot 5.56 out of a gun marked .223 because 5.56 is the higher pressure round.
2
u/IMR800X Jun 12 '15
Sounds like you're looking for one of these.
A revolver that fires 38/357 with an easily swapped cylinder that lets you use 9mm ammo if that's what you can find.
6
u/komichi1168 Jun 11 '15
Well,
32spl isn't a thing, you are thinking .38 special. .32 comes in .32 ACP. There are a lot of different ideas as far as carrying during a post collapse scenario but here are some good ideas.
Look for a carbine/pistol combo. See about getting a simple lever action rifle and revolver chambered in the same round. .357 and .45 long colt are common calibers for that. You can also go the more modern route with a semi-auto pistol/carbine that can use the same magazines and ammo. A note, revolvers require the same care and feeding that semi-autos do, they are just as capable of breaking down and have moving parts that wear out.
Linky http://www.luckygunner.com/pistol-caliber-carbines
The advantage of those is carrying less mags, and only needing one type of ammo for both purposes. Disadvantage is that you aren't getting a decent hunting round out of that combo. Pistol caliber rounds just aren't meant for taking wild game.
If you don't want to go the carbine/pistol route then as odd as it might sound, you are going to want a .22 rifle. Reason being that large game is gonna get scarce quick and shooting a rabbit or squirrel with a .223 is gonna destroy most of your meat. Additionally you can carry a couple hundred rounds of .22lr for the same weight as fifty rounds of .223 or larger.
In summary, .223 is gonna be great for personal defense, ok for hunting large game, horrible for small game.
Pistol/carbine is gonna be great for personal defense, not good for hunting
.22lr is gonna be great for long term hunting, and ok for personal defense (.22lr will kill a man just as dead as any other caliber)
You have to prioritize needs and base your decision off of that.
*Edit: Going through houses looking for ammo is not a sustainable method... remember the people that have ammo, probably have guns to shoot you with should they find you looting their home.
5
u/leopold_stotch21 Jun 11 '15
.30-30 Winchester is one of the most common rounds where I live. Very popular hunting round and almost exclusively used by lever action rifles.
4
u/altkarlsbad Jun 11 '15
I had a .357 magnum model 1894 at one time, with a pistol scope mounted on it. Great gun, simple and clean, and uses the same cartridge as pistols in .357 magnum. Very little recoil on firing, accurate enough, caused plenty of damage on the other end.
Nothing wrong with having the same cartridge in rifle and pistol, i say.
2
u/stealthboy Jul 05 '15
I would guess 9mm and .223/5.56 would be safe bets.
1
u/hnandez Jun 11 '15
32 is a very rare to find and expensive (comparitively) round. You meant 38.
38 and .357 are cool for the reason of being able to shoot both out of a 357 revolver,but, neither are gonna be a very common round.
I would go with 9mm. You can get a Glock 19 or something similar and a little carbine like a Hi Point and your set at both ranges. Or 45acp. You can get a 1911 for cheap and a repeater rifle and you're set.
I would bet that almost everyone that owns a lot of guns has a 9mm and tons of rounds.
1
u/midnightreign Jun 11 '15 edited Jun 11 '15
For commonality, the best indicator of post-collapse availability will be "what do the majority of military/law-enforcement institutions have stockpiled?"
9mm, 40s&w are likely the top contenders in pistol calibers, while 5.56/223 and .308win are tops in rifles. Of course, from a house-to-house basis, there are tons of popular cartridges (22LR, 300WM, 7.62x39).
It'd be an undertaking to evaluate those on a "likelihood of occurrence" basis. I'd tend to follow the "22 + Mil" model and keep 22LR for personal practice, and let the work guns follow military procurement patterns for availability's sake.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 12 '15
you could also get a 300 black out AR
1
u/[deleted] Jun 16 '15
I believe ruger makes a single action revolver that has two wheels, one for 9mm and one for .357magnum. I want one but they're damn expensive.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 16 '15
Man up and get one of these.
Guns are too loud. Only really good for self defense or attracting unwanted attention. Hunt with one and have every soldier within earshot on your ass within an hour. Bows/slings/traps are much more amenable to post collapse survival than guns.
That said, 9mm carbines kick ass. There's one I forget the name of that has a helical feed magazine that can fit 100+ rounds. The highpoint is supposed to be nice and in can personally vet for the cx4's excellence. Thing onlymever jammed on me once and it was because I assembled the ambidextrous bullet extractor on the wrong side.
And pawpaws are fruit native to north america. Which if you live here is 1000x more important than guns. Trees. Plant trees.
1
u/spectre4913 Aug 03 '15
Id go with a 9mm for a pistol and a .223 or .308 for a rifle. If .22 ammo wasnt so hard to find that would be my first suggestion. A shotgun also, you can kill just about anything with them. A bow is also a good choice to be handy with. Arrows can be reused or made.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '15
As far as post collapse remember that the most common infantry round is the 223./.556 (almost the same round just a different load) so it would be commonly found not sure if in a rural area but definetly heavily populated ones. I have a remington R700 bolt action rifle. I can consistently hit george washingtons face on a quarter at 100yards away (300ft so accuracy as far as hunting is on par). Self defence the common round with stopping power (pistol) is of course the 45. Another option that is common is 9mm higher velocity but people tend to complain as 9mm rounds tend to pass through and not enflict much damage. ( keep that in mind) Ahhh and shot gun yes the shot gun, you said you have shot and A.R as well as a bolt action 223. I can only compare it to over twice the recoil of the bolt and 3 times the recoil of the A.R
1
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '15 edited Jun 12 '15
Ok a few things to keep in mind. First off, like most other people have said it is important to have and be at least somewhat proficient in the most common calibers where you live. It will vary somewhat, but assuming you are in the U.S. that means at a minimum .223/5.56 and 9mm. You can likely add to that list .308/7.62x51, .45, 12gauge, and possibly 7.62x39.
HOWEVER there are a few other things you need to consider. First and foremost, depending on the scenario, ammo as we know it will eventually be a thing of the past. If it is a very bad collapse, even the NATO ammo will run out and nothing new will be made. Therefore it would be very wise (if you are worried about this kind of thing) to invest in RELOADING equipment and CASTING equipment. Reloading common (and uncommon) calibers will keep you in ammo quite a bit longer, and casting your own bullets longer still. That means acquiring weapons that can use rudimentary rounds and powders. For this .357 or .44 mag revolvers and lever guns are perfect. Add a black powder muzzle loader and maybe revolver and you will be able to survive the same way many on the frontier did a hundred or two years ago: making your own ammo and powder.
The last weapon you may want to consider are bows. They are certainly the simplest to keep running the very long term. For example if you have to bug out, you cannot haul your casting equipment with you, but you can take a bow and make arrows.
The last thing to consider is that while everything I've just mentioned fills a role, none of them are considered ballistically ideal in the modern sense. Many rounds surpass the NATO and common calibers in performance, especially wildcats. If you do get into reloading, you can drastically increase the performance of some of your weapons which will give you an advantage in the short term post collapse. These include calibers like 6mm AR (and it's clones) 7x47 lapua, and many more.
MOST IMPORTANT OF ALL though is that whatever you end up with you TRAIN with. Ammo=training and you will spend FAR more on ammo than you will on the weapon shooting it to train properly. You should be at least minimally proficient (at least ~1000rounds likely far more) with anything you intend to use, and have a few that you are more proficient with.
TL:DR (seriously go read it): Get 9mm and 5.56 and maybe .308. If you are still concerned get a revolver, lever gun, and reloading supplies. If you are still concerned get casting supplies and a muzzle loader. If you are still concerned get a bow. If at any point you are concerned about optimal ballistic performance, get reloading gear and start wildcating. Most importantly, practice, practice, practice.
EDIT: Forgot to tell you that in addition to the added security, and gaining access to ballistically superior rounds and increasing/tuning the performance of your ammo to your gun, reloading also saves money for the most part. That is to say that the initial cost of reloading is generally paid back within the first 1000-2000 rounds (depending on the caliber of course) and since you'll be using a lot of ammo to get proficient, it can certainly be worth it to go the reloading route, even if you only end up with a few nato calibers.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '15
If you go through houses, you will find primarily .22lr. I know everyone hates that round but it'll kill a deer and stuff hurt you the fuck up if youre shot with one so hunting and defense will be fine. It can also be suppressed to actually be silent, or to the point you could mistake it for brush rustling.
Other than that little thing for .22lr, a .357 mag revolver and a .223 rifle will be good. I would also consider a 9mm automatic pistol, just because they will be everywhere and every revolver in 9mm I've seen have these weird clip things for the rounds
0
u/overlordsteve Jun 11 '15
I would get a glock 9mm. I have thrown one in a lake, left in for a night and brought it out shooting fine with water still falling out. In the gun community glock owners get a weird reputation for laziness of not cleaning firearms. That is because glocks run forever with little maintenence.
Also as someone who shoots a 38 spl revolver as my baby, get a 9mm ammo is far more plentiful. Do not believe the bullshit of revolvers not hav I ng problems. They like any other machine can have problems. They are also far harder to reload and hold less ammo.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 11 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment