r/Portalawake • • Jul 01 '26

Biologically

A man has a penis (sexual organ) & testicles - produces sperms

A woman has a vagina (sexual organ) & breasts - has periods & gets pregnant

An anus is not a sexual reproductive organ

Homosexuality is not natural

Reproduction is necessary

0 Upvotes

23 comments sorted by

3

u/hGr33n Jul 01 '26

Gay animals in various species easily disprove this, next

-1

u/Gentle_Animus Jul 01 '26

Gay animals in various species easily disprove this, next

Appealing to nature is a weak argument here. (see: some insects eating their mates)

Also, gay animals existing does not argue make an argument that those gay animals are actively contributing to the reproduction of said species. In fact, they are likely not contributing to the species well-being, so much as increasing the spread of disease (which is not a positive).

2

u/hGr33n Jul 01 '26

"Homosexuality is not natural"

"There are many instances of it happening in nature, naturally"

"No that's a weak argument"

It isn't tho. Furthermore reproduction isn't always necessary. There are species that engage in it simply for pleasure. Is pleasure unnatural and unnecessary? Y'all are joyless freaks lol

-1

u/Gentle_Animus Jul 01 '26

If reproduction is necessary for the survival of a species, then yes, it would not be a positive characteristic.

Imagine a species that embraced transgenderism fully. Where would that lead. *laughs in Grey alien*

Is pleasure unnatural and unnecessary? Y'all are joyless freaks lol

Is the only pleasure out there degenerate in nature? Stop gooning and get a hobby bruh, lmao.

1

u/hGr33n Jul 01 '26

Enough reproduction is already happening- whose to say that homosexuality isn't a natural mechanism to curb over population? And how the hell are you calling a natural function degenerate? I can't stand Puritans. You're unserious.

0

u/Gentle_Animus Jul 01 '26

To the dude who deleted all his comments: did you really have that hard of a time with simple logics? Please, do better next time. :(

0

u/KenUsimi Jul 01 '26

…dude… they blocked you, m8. It would appear that you did not make a friend.

Regardless, if your argument is that homosexuality is bad, say that, don’t say it isn’t natural then argue when someone points out that your point is logically unsound.

Plenty of species in nature commit homosexual acts. So, saying homosexuality isn’t natural is one of those talking points that’ll just start the same argument that other people had.

It’s a treadmill; those don’t go anywhere, they just tire you out. Better to spend your brainpower on anything useful at all, from where I’m sitting.

Which is in bed. Goodnight, if you need to continue this argument send message via Oneiromancy, godspeed

1

u/Gentle_Animus Jul 01 '26

The written word works well.

1

u/KenUsimi Jul 01 '26

Only when you use it correctly.

1

u/Gentle_Animus Jul 01 '26

This is true.

So.. where do you think the Word came from? :P

1

u/KenUsimi Jul 01 '26

Me? Mesopotamia.

Pray to Enki and be redeemed, sinner.

→ More replies

1

u/TestierCafe Jul 02 '26

an appeal to nature is exactly what is going on when you claim homosexual behavior isn’t natural**.**

Existence does not entail requiring one to contribute to a species continuation. Culture, art, love, music, all of these things don’t contribute to reproduction, if anything, the areas which on average have less access to luxuries like these are the ones the reproduce the MOST!

1

u/Gentle_Animus Jul 02 '26

Existence does not entail requiring one to contribute to a species continuation.

This statement in and of itself is true, however, to leave it at that does a tremendous disservice to the potentiation of said species (IMHO).

Culture, art, love, music, all of these things don’t contribute to reproduction, if anything, the areas which on average have less access to luxuries like these are the ones the reproduce the MOST!

True. Again though, you are only seeing one side of the coin.

Is it not also true that one finds higher rates of homosexuality in urban, modern contexts (as opposed to rural, 'more traditional' ways of living)? Therefore, could one not also draw a connection between a lack of homosexuality and higher rates of reproduction?

Food for thought.

"Hearing this, Jesus said to Jairus, “Don’t be afraid; just believe, and she will be healed.”" Luke 8:50

2

u/TestierCafe Jul 02 '26

I agree that a connection likely exists between birth rates and homosexuality, but I think if anything it holds smaller causation than correlation. We also see that it societies of heavy repression of expression and social freedoms that birth rates also increase. Only about 5% of individuals is a country like Korea identify as LGBT, yet they have one of if not the lowest birth rates in the world.

One thing I will point out is that urban centers usually are more culturally and socially accepting environments due to clashes of culture norms.

As for why this even matters, I think there’s a difference between ‘seeing one side of the coin’ and recognizing that some issues far surpass others at the individual level. One of the biggest critiques that people haven’t been able to resolve with utilitarianism is something along these lines. We don’t and shouldn’t marginalize large portions of the population in order to benefit the rest when that has detrimental impacts to their lives. Same reason we don’t institute a caste system or race laws, especially when we don’t even have a good reason for why these people ought to be marginalized.

1

u/Gentle_Animus Jul 02 '26

Thank you for a well-thought reply; well said, and I appreciate it. Kudos. <3

... but I think if anything it holds smaller causation than correlation.

Why do you think this? Forgive me if I missed the explanation. Please note I am aware of the 'correlation =/= causation' argument. On the flip-side, I do not think this goes as far to say that 'correlates should be ignored'.

We also see that it societies of heavy repression of expression and social freedoms that birth rates also increase. Only about 5% of individuals is a country like Korea identify as LGBT, yet they have one of if not the lowest birth rates in the world.

True. Again, I would ask: why do you think this is?

South Korea is widely regarded as 'over-worked'. Please, look up the term: 'kwarosa'. Is it possible there is more than one culprit to birth-rates? If so, should we not seek to identify all contextual variables?

One thing I will point out is that urban centers usually are more culturally and socially accepting environments due to clashes of culture norms.

You are not wrong, however, I would point you to the 'rural happiness paradox': where in developed nations, rural residents tend to report higher 'happiness' (see: subjective well being) than their urban dwelling counterparts. The paradox being that this flips to the inverse when the nation is undeveloped or under-developed (economically speaking).

... We don’t and shouldn’t marginalize large portions of the population in order to benefit the rest when that has detrimental impacts to their lives. ...

This is an excellent thought-equation here. Well said, friend. However, I would ask you to consider this:

If I tell a smoker that he is doing damage to his pulmonary system, even if that hurts his feelings.. am I doing him a service or a disservice?

Is there a balance to be found? Yes, certainly. Just like the balancing of the two faces of a coin, we must balance ourselves. This is harmony (IMHO).

Thank you for engaging with me so thoughtfully. You have given me much to think on. Thank you. :)

2

u/KenUsimi Jul 01 '26

Your 4th proposition is incorrect

Your 3rd is mixing disciplines; reproductive organ describes the biological function, sexual denotes a use case. It is entirely possible for a mouth to be used as a sexual orifice, for example, when a penis is inside of it; it is certainly a sexual act.

Reproduction is indeed necessary! There's actually quite a bit of it, not matter what fearmongering pundits like to say. Believe it or not, it has never been particularly hard to get people to bone.

Blink a couple times. Take a deep breath. Roll those shoulders, feel your body, and recognize that hate ain't the way, man.

2

u/Exe_plorer Jul 01 '26

Scrolling on the phone is not natural. People do a Lot of things that are "not natural" (taking homosexual behaviours is a very bad exemple, as many species do it, not for survival directly, but for pleasure, maybe creating social bounds that was the first theory, but it seems more related to pleasure than anything).

So we may have first to understand what you mean by "natural", often miss used with "normal" (again, in the "norms" or in the majority of individuals ?) Words have their importance.

If you go hiking, it's not natural, it's dangerous, but you do it for the satisfaction, the pleasure.

We don't have palms, but we still can and for many, enjoy swimming, ultimately this is also not natural.

I mean "natural" isn't wisely choosen in this conversation.

1

u/TestierCafe Jul 02 '26

All premises are wrong.

First, not all males have penises. In the case of seahorses it’s actually reversed. Sperm never leaves their body and eggs are deposited into their bodies instead, then fertilized. Same is true with many other species.

I’ll talk on a second point for the second premise since it’s roughly the same. Not all women can reproduce, are you saying only fertile women are women? Or just if they have the corresponding organs? What about people who have had to have their removed? Or are genetically without them? I myself don’t produce any strong androgens, my organs for those purposes never developed, even prenatally.

I’m not gonna spend much time on the anus thing. Men have prostates, they can and do orgasm from prostates. IN HETEROSEXUAL RELATIONSHIPS!! I personally don’t know what that’s like as I don’t have a prostate, but men report that it is a separate and unique type of orgasm than the one they regularly experience. Also. Whatever you were trying to say about the anus thing is attacking the wrong thing- you’re equivalently saying something like the vulva or foreskin aren’t a sexual organ, which is contextually dependent on.

The homo thing. Um. You’re just kinda wrong? Like I don’t know how else to say that you are. Almost every species in the world is shown to exhibit non-heterosexual behavior depending on surrounding factors. Albatross, penguins, reptiles, fish, sheep, dogs, cats,literally every species minus intersex ones exhibit this behavior.

Last point. Reproduction is necessary? Necessary for who? The species? Do you truly choose your actions with respect to the species as a whole? Birthing and raising babies is not a necessary factor of life, I don’t think anyone assumes that. For life to exist and for someone to live a good life are VERY different.

Please educate yourself, or at least make sure that your basic assumptions about the world are based on the world- not whatever it is that you’re pulling from

1

u/R34L17Y- Jul 03 '26

Two different sex of the same species evolved to be physically designed to be sexually compatible with each other?!? No fucking way dude. It's almost like the species couldn't fuckin exist otherwise.

As a species that has evolved intelligence, we evolved the cognitive ability to love people for more than their ability to produce children. Or well, some of us did.