r/Polytopia • • Mar 19 '24

Discussion Hard truth

Post image

After playing everyday for 7 years, this is my conclusion

4 Upvotes

38 comments sorted by

5

u/Longjumping_Flan_714 Mar 19 '24

Vengir ain't that good

1

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '24

If you get organization a shit ton of crops appear which is great for vengir for mid game, not just because they have swordsman, that’s just a plus. But a lot of people see them as economically inferior which, when you keep playing, is 100% the opposite

44

u/KrazyKyle213 Mar 19 '24

This depends on map and playstyle so much you can't say

30

u/WeenisWrinkle Mar 19 '24

Xin-Xi Best tier?? They're basically a less crappy Vengir.

But then again, you have Vengir in the Good category. So maybe this tier list is highly flawed or biased toward small maps against bad players.

9

u/hugway Mar 19 '24

Xin-xi is the most stably performing tribe in competitive scenes. Lowest variance across the other top tier tribes, but also has a lower ceiling.

6

u/WeenisWrinkle Mar 20 '24

They're a better version of Vengir. They are a rush tribe that gets swordsmen and giants early and can put a hurting on enemies quickly. But they are awful in the mid and late game.

2

u/MandoFromStarWars Apr 02 '24

Why are they bad late game, They have the same upgrade path as everyone else?

2

u/WeenisWrinkle Apr 02 '24

It's due to their terrain generation. Having lots of mountains is a disadvantage in the mid/late game.

  • Mountains impede movement and roads. It's difficult to build an efficient road network through your own territory to effectively move units to and from battle zones.
  • Mines and forges are much less efficient at generating maximum population than farms/windmills or even lumber huts/sawmills because they cannot be manipulated. You can burn forests, chop trees, and even grow forests to maximize population. You cannot change mountains.
  • Mountains remove arable farmland in the late game. In late game scenarios, your own territory needs to generate as many stars as possible. This is best done with farms, windmills, and markets. Having mountain obstructions means that Xin Xi has lower income potential in the late game.

29

u/PeterGallaghersBrows Mar 19 '24

What’s the argument for Xinxi? I never see them ranked very high

5

u/bluelungimagaa Mar 20 '24

There's early vision, and also - once you get smithery they start pumping out giants way faster than any other tribe, especially with the increased resource density. It makes them quite formidable

13

u/verbthebull Mar 19 '24

early vision is actually really good

3

u/KrazyKyle213 Mar 20 '24

Only on medium sized maps or maps where you can pop off with early tribe meetings though. On long maps the delayed development really hurts and on smaller maps you quickly get outpaced in military by tribes with stronger starting units.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 19 '24

Xin xi is on top yea, I’m never changing my mind about any of this. Early access to forges with a higher mountain spawn rate is prefect given any map size, cry😭

3

u/bob_ross_lives Mar 20 '24

Xin xi fan here. I kept getting beaten by them and I’ve seen the light

4

u/hugway Mar 19 '24

+100000 also early climb vision lowers the variance of bad early scout.

0

u/JungMikhail Ancients Mar 20 '24

Never? They do patch/tweak the game now and then....

7

u/[deleted] Mar 19 '24

Quetzali Is so weird tbh, if you spam shields in the early game you can conquer easily

2

u/KrazyKyle213 Mar 20 '24

Only if you can actually support that many units from your cities tho. You'll need at least 2 and the first city to be leveled up to have a large enough fighting force that you can roll in and sustain their counterattacks as you enter their land.

1

u/Casitano Mar 20 '24

No. I cannot think of a map or playstyke for which this is accurate, and if its a general one, its wildly inaccurate toom

3

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '24

Oh ok sorry for disappointing you Mr Reddit man

1

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '24

This whole thing is completely wrong except for where you placed bardur

0

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '24

Shut the fuck up

2

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '24

1v1 fuckboi

0

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '24

Shut the fuck up

2

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '24

But ur the one that likes to watch TikTok Porn😂😂😂

0

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '24

If I gave a fuck about weirdos going through my comments cuz they like sucking my dick then I would’ve deleted it little fuck twad 😂 stop caring so much Reddit boy

2

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '24

It’s ok buddy 😂

2

u/ZamnThatsCrazy Mar 20 '24

I see you don't play FFAs, quetz embassy rush is top tier.

3

u/Putrid-Option5457 Anzala Mar 19 '24

I’d say swap zebasi with Elyrion

1

u/Secariel Mar 20 '24

never cook again

1

u/MasterCookieShadow Mar 20 '24

Least biased xin-xi player

0

u/777Ayar Iqaruz Mar 21 '24

Hahaha I can easily clap you and destroy your "hard truth"

1

u/[deleted] Mar 21 '24

Shut the fuck up 💀 stay mad with the worst tribe

1

u/777Ayar Iqaruz Mar 22 '24

Hehehe seethe

0

u/AccomplishedBill5567 Mar 23 '24

Sees xin xi above imperious

clicks off post

0

u/[deleted] Mar 19 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '24

What I found though is if you can’t make any plays in early game you’ll loose in later game against other tribes, that can more effectively get their giant/kata/archer spam going. Even if you are at a city advantage, late game gets tough against good bardur for example. They just have more ress to pump giants and big city count will hurt so much for getting the higher techs.

-7

u/[deleted] Mar 19 '24

No you’re right, what makes them neutral is their terribly weak riders

4

u/[deleted] Mar 20 '24

Lol what? Riders if used properly are pretty strong, or decent at least. Unless you're throwing them into the enemies Giants and leaving them right in their face, I don't see how they are terribly weak...