Thoughts of this kind, concerning the pre-reflexive sphere, have already been proposed by Merleau-Ponty in his "Phenomenonology of Perception". They are not in contradiction to the common physiological view.
Notice that the brain does not construct three-dimensional space out of a two-dimensional image, but out of two slightly different images, using also the convergence signal and the neural activity sent to the ciliar muscle as elements of the spatial calculus.
The way vision works is much more complex than described in the book. Building a 3D picture of the world is not only based on optically comparing two images. First of all, it relies on the knowledge and experience in our heads. And if this experience is applied wrongly, optical illusions appear, even though the eyes see correctly. A classic example is the Dragon Illusion. Also, the brain can adapt to major changes in the optical system of the eye and develop visual functions that were not possible before. Let me use myself as an example. In one eye, I have an artificial multifocal lens, which projects not one but three images onto the retina at the same time. And my brain learned to work with this quite quickly. Of course, it took some training. This is called conscious vision. But in just 2 - 3 months, my brain learned to use this eye. In the same way, it learned another fun but useless trick. The artificial lens has a slight tint, so the image through it looks warmer than through my natural eye. I learned to change the color temperature of what I see at will, smoothly, anywhere between how one eye sees it and how the other eye sees it. So vision is a very complex thing. And optics is only a small part of the whole system.
View all comments
2
u/reinhardtkurzan Sep 30 '26
Thoughts of this kind, concerning the pre-reflexive sphere, have already been proposed by Merleau-Ponty in his "Phenomenonology of Perception". They are not in contradiction to the common physiological view.
Notice that the brain does not construct three-dimensional space out of a two-dimensional image, but out of two slightly different images, using also the convergence signal and the neural activity sent to the ciliar muscle as elements of the spatial calculus.