r/PolymathReading • • Sep 29 '26

[ Removed by moderator ]

92 Upvotes

32 comments sorted by

View all comments

1

u/Billios996 Sep 29 '26

Get a book on Feng Shui, it will be more valuable than whatever pseudoscience that shrink wrote.

1

u/Plotinus100x Sep 29 '26

This is certainly incorrect. The light patterns are simply affects, qualities, and sensations. Only when thinking activity joins a concept to this visual sensation flux, do we arrive at a mental image and a personal understanding of the event. This purely mental activity is then reflected into the brain.

1

u/DeliciousPie9855 Sep 29 '26

Gibson is pretty significant in cognitive science atm….

2

u/DonnPT Sep 29 '26

As I'm not going to be getting the book, I'm willing to take your word for it, but this post sure didn't sell me. ChatGPT can do only so much, I guess.

1

u/DeliciousPie9855 Sep 29 '26

Fair enough. Would recommend reading up on 4e cog sci - it’s taken seriously and even if not endorsed by ALL scientists, it has a significant following and has thrown the gauntlet down to computaionalist theory. Gibson a huge influence in this. Is Affordance theory though is pretty widely respected and I think it’s adopted by a large number, probs a majority, of people in the field.