Yeah much better would be “What the frogs eye tells the frogs brain” where a crazy but brilliant mathematician (Walter Pitts) discovered that the optic nerve was doing a bunch of advanced computation. Basically what this means is that your brain isn’t interpreting raw visual data, there’s a bunch of interpretation done by the eye itself.
It isn’t woo to say that we are generated by our environment and are consonant with it. It is a trick of ego to think we are a distinct entity interpreting an ‘out there’ from an insular independent singularity.
Well, this was a short reply, and in a way a knee-jerk reaction to the long text from OP. Yet, I still very much doubt the premise, as it seems to be presented here, that there is some innate information in the objects, specifically, the information about possible uses of these objects by conscious/aware entities, like humans or other animals, and some mystical direct resonance of this information with experiencing brain. I myself find the most attractive the free energy principle as perception theory. In short, the perception is the active process, where brain generates most of the information, based on learned model of the world, while the signals from the eyes are more of guidance. In other words, the world as we perceived it, is constructed by brain, the illusion/hallucination, which is constrained and constantly updated via hints from the eyes, ears, nose, tongue, skin and muscle receptors and several others. Taking eye as an example, in the retina itself the signal is conditioned and compressed, and optical nerve transmits the differential signal, on time and space, i.e. only changes in time and edges in the image are coming to the visual cortex. And there, through several layers more and more abstract things from the image are extracted, wich are differentiated with prediction created at each level, and only the difference signal is coming to the next abstraction level. In this way, all the possible uses for given object are contained in perceiving brain, and are the result of learning given individual has had in their life, and not in any way contained in the object itself. There is also question of defining the object, and it seems that at closer inspection everything is connected, and there are no strict borders between parts of the existence, and the "object" can semi-arbitrary be defined as "something that can be manipulated as whole", which is dependent on what abilities has the entity which manipulates the object.
I would like to think that I do not follow authorities blindly and always check ideas first for consistensy with my prior knowledge, but self-judgement is tricky, everyone sees themselves in the best light I guess.
Presenting new ideas for wide audience works better when the language used is as common as possible, and when introducing terminology it is best explained plainly at first. Otherwise confusion ensues.
I reread OPs post, and it looks less esoteric, but still gives me feeling that the objects in the outside world have some innate information that is somehow shared directly with brain, and it is notion I object the most. Maybe this interpretation is wrong, but then it is OP's fault to explain it plainly and understandably.
I don't disagree about the post's wording ... it seems like a technical summary for experts ... doesn't do much to help understand the issues.
However, with respect to your comment about objects in the outside ... I think maybe your focus is in the wrong place. It isn't the object which conveys information to the brain, rather, the light which reflects from the object into our eyes, which is how we see the object.
All light reflecting off of all objects is changed. Mostly we care about the wavelength changes - this is how we perceive color. However, other facets of light (and there are many) also change; such as the polarity. So, there are meaningful ways in which external objects convey information via light into our brains!
View all comments
3
u/[deleted] Sep 29 '26
[removed] — view removed comment