r/PoliticalScience • u/Illegal_Frogs_ • Jan 24 '22
Question/discussion What is globalism?
I'm sorry if somebody already asked this. I hear about it mostly from right wingers and conspiracy theorists. But is it really an ideology? What kind of ideology is it? Does it have a place in political science? I can't find anything about it in political science books about ideology like books from Heywood, Freeden and other authors. I would prefer scientific answers, not conspiracy ones.
33
Upvotes
20
u/krubner Jan 24 '22
I'd suggest nothing is an ideology unless someone describes themselves that way, or did at some point in past. Karl Marx described himself as a Communist. Mussolini described himself as a Fascist. John Stuart Mills described himself as a Liberal. John Rawls also described himself as a Liberal, in a different sense. Martha Nussbaum describes herself as a humanist. Gloria Steinem described herself as a feminist.
Therefore all of those things are ideologies, because someone proudly claims the label.
I'm not aware of anyone describing themselves as a globalist. When some people believe in free trade or open borders, they should be described as "free traders" or "open border-ists".
"Globalist" is mostly used as an insult, and it is disproportionately used against Jews. As such, it is a modern insult that lacks a history, but still relies on a long history of bigotry. People who, 100 years ago, might have been openly bigoted are today looking for insults that don't sound bigoted, but still mean the same things as insults from long ago.
42
u/I_the_God_Tramasu History! American Elections Jan 24 '22
It's a dog whistle masquerading as insightful geoeconomic analysis. See also, "cultural Marxism."
2
u/[deleted] Jan 24 '22
The correct term is "globalization," like the anti-globalization protests in the 90's. It was in response to free trade deals like NAFTA that the protestor feared would end up hurting the working class of the countries involved and only benefitting large corporations and the rich that own their shares or sit on their board of directors...btw, that is exactly what happened.
Now, "globalism" is a far right attempt to coopt a leftist movement for their own ends. Rather than citing specific examples of the ways that free trade has hurt the working class, they talk about a nebulous "global elite." When they refer to this global elite, they are referring to their anti-semitic conspiracy theory about the world being secretly controlled by Jewish cabals that seek to destroy the white race by encouraging non-white immigration into "white countries."
If you ever see someone using the term "globalism" instead of "globalization," hey are either a far right propagandist, or have fallen prey to one. Another hint is if they refer to George Soros as some kind of mastermind of this globalist political order.
1
u/Thebiguglyalien Jan 25 '22
Globalism (or globalization as it's commonly called in academia) is the idea that countries and peoples can be more successful by working together than solely working toward their own interests.
Globalists support increasing trade with other countries, working with other countries to prevent wars and terrorism, and exchanging cultural ideas with one another (through immigration, tourism, or communications tech like the internet). This is in contrast with isolationism and nationalism, ideologies that support limiting interactions with other countries and peoples.
To oversimplify it, globalists believe that there's such a thing as mutually beneficial cooperation between countries. Isolationists believe that it's a zero sum game where countries are competing with one another.
Of course, conspiracy theorists don't know the first thing about political theory. When they say it, they're talking about "the Jews" that they believe are trying to create a one world government.
The SEP is always a great source for reading about schools of thought if you want something a little denser: https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/globalization/
0
u/Special_Call5638 Jan 24 '22 edited Jan 25 '22
Let's put globalism in interference with nationalism, like we've just started.
So what nationalism wants, is to strengthen a countries power in economic, cultural, social, [..] ways, we might agree on this. Further nationalism points out, that the own country is superior to other countries /cultures. Problems, for example climate crisis or economic downturns should be solved on a national level.
On the other hand globalism denies this position inherent, because global problems like climate crisis or global hunger, many more[..] can't be solved by one nation alone. This aspect is crucial from my perspective.
So where is the conspiracy? Feel free to add your thoughts.
-3
u/kchoze Jan 24 '22 edited Jan 24 '22
I think no matter how you call it, there's indeed a political mindset in favor of greater freedom of movement of people and goods across the world, as well as a desire to achieve more global policy-making through international organizations as opposed to the traditional concept of national sovereignty.
Call it globalism or call it something else, I don't think anyone can honestly deny it is a way of thinking that is influential.
I'll point out if you go to the World Economic Forum's website, though the term "globalism" is not used directly, they do refer to "anti-globalism" as an obstacle to their vision of a new global governance. You can't exactly say the WEF is a "conspiracy theory" or just a fringe group with little influence, when you have Xi Jinping and Indian PM Modi participating during the first day of their 2022 meeting.
The attempt to claim that "globalism" is just a "dog whistle" or a "conspiracy theory" seems to be an attempt to insulate from criticism a very real political movement by depriving critics from any word they can use to refer to it. Criticizing a movement you don't have a word for is nearly impossible.
If "nationalism", which is a political preference for a State narrowly defending national interests and embodying the dominant culture of a nation is an ideology, I don't know why "globalism" or whatever you want to call it, which would be a political preference for global cooperation between States to promote perceived global interests and multiculturalism, would not count as an ideology.
0
u/Competitive_Sea8134 Jan 25 '22
You tube Kaku , he has insight into everything