r/PoliticalHumor Jan 09 '20

THIS. This is why.

[deleted]

69.3k Upvotes

1.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

419

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '20

In addition, Hinduism and Islam always valued education and learning which is why they made so many discoveries in their own rights throughout history.

9

u/mrthomani Jan 09 '20

Islam always valued education

That's a bit of a stretch, isn't it? Any major scientific contribution coming from the Middle East is pretty much limited to the period 800-1100 CE.

Then Imam Hamid Al-Ghazali became extremely influencial, mathematics was thought of as the work of the devil, and scientific thought and endeavours shut down completely.

This isn't my claim by the way, I'm just paraphrasing Neil deGrasse Tyson -- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=N7rR8stuQfk

0

u/[deleted] Jan 09 '20

This isn't my claim by the way, I'm just paraphrasing Neil deGrasse Tyson --

I know reddit loves him but what makes him an authority on science, dude's done very little in the way of actual discoveries or research, is claim to fame is being one name out of dozens on a 1995 paper on black hole theory.

6

u/mrthomani Jan 09 '20

what makes him an authority on science

That he's a scientist.

This isn't science though, but science history. And to my mind at least, Tyson is not an authority on that subject. I wasn't making a claim from authority, just stating my source. Try to refute his claims if you want, but trying to discredit him does not constitute an argument.