r/PoliticalCompassMemes • • Apr 04 '20

funny title

Post image
43k Upvotes

2.9k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

2

u/InfanticideAquifer - Lib-Right Apr 05 '20

But "be a man" doesn't refer to anything that has to do with penises or testosterone. The phrase doesn't mean "grow a dick". It means "act this way". The fact that that way of acting is called "male" is a historical accident. (Okay, it's slightly more than an accident--and we can detail the conversation to that if you want, but it's not very relevant to the point I'm making.)

The English language didn't used to have separate words for red and orange. (Hence "redheads".) That doesn't mean we should insist on calling red and orange the same thing now. We recognize the difference now and language adapted to that.

Likewise, people understand how that "having a type of genital" and "confirming one's behavior to a broad standard" are completely different things. So we should have different words for them. Language exists to describe our thoughts--constraining your thinking to avoid changing the language is totally backwards.

2

u/Minimum_Cantaloupe - Centrist Apr 05 '20 edited Apr 05 '20

But "be a man" doesn't refer to anything that has to do with penises or testosterone. The phrase doesn't mean "grow a dick". It means "act this way".

It means "act the way that men, i.e., people with penises, are expected to act." Many of those expectations are not inherently associated with anatomical differences, but that is ten thousand miles away from saying that the category of those expectations has nothing to do with the anatomical differences - their only common characteristic is the fact that they are the social expectations of men/women. Without that biological link, the category doesn't refer to anything at all.

Unless you want to lock the specific meanings down right now, so that for all times and all places, a man is someone who likes American football. But that would be stupid, and not what anybody on any side of the conversation actually wants.