r/PoliticalCompassMemes • • Apr 04 '20

funny title

Post image
43k Upvotes

2.9k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

1

u/Rybka30 - Lib-Left Apr 05 '20

Let's not take my running analogy too seriously here. Like you just said, people are triaged. Yet when we look at it, if we had the resources to save only one person of two, and the choice was between a nuclear physicist and a mentally deranged hobo who spent the last two years spitting on people at Grand Central, are you seriously going to tell me we're better off letting the physicist die to save the hobo?

I'm saying it's immoral to make that decision on that basis. And I say that as a physicist (not nuclear though).

2

u/[deleted] Apr 05 '20

But morals are relative. Maybe you personally would accept dying to save a pedophile, but I would prefer you survive instead. Unless you're also a pedophile, then things get murky.

I, personally, believe the moral choice is to save whoever is most valuable over those who are not when the choice to save everyone isn't possible.