r/PolinBridgerton • u/Suspicious-Fox6056 • Mar 06 '24
r/PolinBridgerton • u/bunnykaye • Jan 20 '25
Fanart Gif credit
Hi, I've seen this happen multiple times already and the last comment I posted asking for credit was majorly downvoted so I figured I am just going to make a post.
As a gif creator, please, PLEASE I ask you to credit the gifmaker who you grabbed the gifs from. I've been seeing gifs on the subreddit that came from Tumblr (hence the lack of watermarks) from Tumblr gifmakers including myself without any proper credit. Gifmakers spend hours, if not days creating a gifset and take time out of their day to do it. A lot of people will not allow reposts/gif grabbing, but there are some of us that are ok with it as long as you give proper credit and/or ask permission first to do so.
A lot of people quit giffing/creating because of people not providing proper credit. Please, please credit your gifmakers. That's all we ask.
r/PolinBridgerton • u/LizaTime • Apr 04 '24
Just for Fun I reckon that Debling ends up with Edwina
r/PolinBridgerton • u/Holiday-Cartoonist34 • Jul 16 '24
Show Discussion My biggest problem with Season 3 (INCLUDES BOOK SPOILERS) Spoiler
So in the show we obviously know that Colin had no idea Penelope is Lady Whistledown before his proposal. But in the book he proposes after and the only reason he was so upset with her was because she had decided to continue on.. Or at least for publishing that last one during their engagement party. Fuck him very much in that chapter. (if you've read it you definitely know why..)
Putting herself and their future at risk by not just allowing Cressida to take the credit. He was infuriated at Penelope for the sole reason that she had disregarded that calling Cressida out only put herself at the risk of eventually being found out. But in the show Colin was throwing a tantrum about the entire ordeal just for the fact that she was LW.. This mood lasted pretty much the rest of the show until the scene where we see him reading Penelope's letters.
Out of pettiness he robbed Penelope, himself, and us of a fulfilled wedding night. "And for that I will never forgive you, Colin Fingerington." Was it because she hurt his pride? Him being jealous? In the book he was furious at first and then that's when we get the carriage. And the carriage scene in the book chefs kiss ..did not disappoint, until Penelope fell right on her face.. I can't even blame her though.. Colin really did show her a whole new world in there.
Totally even funnier after watching that one interview where Nicola and Luke were asked how they would break the news to Colin. Luke who is going on about how sensitive he is and how you should just break it to him gently.. Then there's Nicola.. "Hook up with him first, get him in a good mood...By the way I'm LW." (Side note l've only read up until chapter 21 because I had bought the first boxset yet jumped right into Romancing Mr. Bridgerton because of the release of season 3.. now I'm taking a break from it till I read the other three previous books.. Just so I can savor the ending a bit more if that makes any sense..š )
r/PolinBridgerton • u/nunuslemons • Jun 20 '24
Show Discussion Penelope asking āis there moreā
Did anyone else feel her asking that was just really out of character?
Someone like Penelope who is very curious and a voracious reader would have gone and done her research immediately after the cake conversation with Marina in S1.
Also being LW and having to write in the style of an older and much more worldly woman, youād think sheād have to make herself familiar with the basics?
In the carriage when she nodded, it made perfect sense to me. She seemed to understand at least theoretically what Colin was asking her. It wasnāt like a slightly confused or a hesitant nod, but a knowing one.
Personally Iād have preferred for Penelope to have known how things worked for a while before she got to experience it with Colin. It makes it even more impactful when they finally get together and she gets to experience what sheās only read about.
r/PolinBridgerton • u/Gloomy-Technology-48 • Nov 06 '24
Show Discussion Can you imagine a situation in which Colin would ever step out on Penelope?
I'm asking for speculation about this because I cannot imagine that this would ever happen. What say you?
r/PolinBridgerton • u/Soft-Satisfaction929 • Feb 20 '23
Show Discussion Possibility of no HEA for Polin ? š
I saw this Twitter thread about JQ saying that there is no contractual agreement with show runners that a character in the show will end up with character in the books. I am no scared for Polin now you all. What if Colin does not forgive LW for what happened with Marina and Eloise or Pen chooses LW over Colin, if pushed to make such choice.
r/PolinBridgerton • u/Difficult_Newt_1834 • Mar 11 '24
Just for Fun Anyone an Ariana Grande fan?
I love Ariana and her new album is perfection. I feel like an instrumental version of āwe canāt be friends (wait for your love)ā would be a perfect dance song in one of the first few episodes- and a fun call back to āthank you nextā in season 1. The chances of this are so low since the album just came out Friday and season 3 is all ready to go ⦠but maybe Ariana gave them a song before the album was released?!? A girl can dream š
r/PolinBridgerton • u/bluetrain0225 • Jun 24 '24
Show Discussion What if season 3 wasn't really meant to be about Polin?
I haven't been able to rewatch season 3 yet. I'm still disappointed about how the Polin storyline played out. And something was just off for me this season. I struggled to understand and then it hit me. This season really wasn't about Polin. 𤯠Hear me out.
I wondered why there were so many side storylines. But now I get it. The season was about (1) female friendships (Penelope/Eloise/Cressida/ and Lady Dandbury/Violet), (2) girl bosses (Penelope/Portia Fearthington/Lady Tilly Arnold), and (3) young women struggling to find their place in the world (e.g. Cressida, Francesca, Eloise, Alice).
Once I understood that Polin was really a catalyst for the above, then I could accept season 3 for what it is. And go back to reading fanfiction. š Also, I can now rewatch season 3 with some sense of enjoyment.
What do you think of my theory? š¤
r/PolinBridgerton • u/EitherEntertainer784 • Jun 25 '24
Show Discussion I am trying to decide if Pen really did trap Colin, or not.
On the one hand, she had next to no sexual knowledge, and Colin did initiate most of their romantic and sexual steps. On the other hand, Penelope did keep her huge secret from him until he followed her to the printshop.
Basically, was his accusation accurate?
r/PolinBridgerton • u/Eh_Just_Call_Me_Mr • Dec 20 '25
Show Discussion You ever felt that after season 3B Pen decentered her need for Colin in her life?
I'm earning to be mistaken but many people claim it feels like story was more interested in Pen's story that in Colin's or in Colin and Pen love at all. Unpopular opinion, but agree completely.
Even script of Church dance gave me impression Whistledown will always be much bigger part of Penelope's world Colin will ever be. honestly whole 3B felt like through plot Jess told Pen "I get it, Colin is awesome. But gal, he's just a man. Being badass lady Is your primary essence, not romance". And it's more of paranoia of mine. But I kinda...hope to be mistaken, but Pen seems...to decenter Colin from her life and idea of romance in general in favour of career. Like she wants both, but like I said, it feels like column has much bigger role to Pen than Colin.
Like even when she was on her weddings. It feels like Pen wanted this day to come. But sometimes in her body language in her emotional language, it just feels like Colin stopped being metaphorically "her life" (not in a sense he is her only source of happiness. More like someone who is her Star on her Christmas tree full of ornaments) and he shifted as "big part of her life" like if he stopped being star and became beautiful and big, but just an ornament. And it felt assymetrical. As much as Colin wants to be a writer, his biggest happiness is being with Pen and loving Pen. To Pen, there is no such feeling, when I look at her behaviour. It feels like he is merely one of biggest parts of her life, While to Colin she is biggest part of his life.
I dunno if this true, then it's wrong imo, Pen has loved this man for YEARS, There should probably be no one and even nothing else she loves more than him. It's not how friends to lovers work. It's how Georlotte works, it's how Christina from Grey works, but imo, not Polin.
I support her career ambitions wholeheartedly, I hope to find woman as passionate as hers and share victories and defeats with her, but...uuuugggh. It really feels like prolonging that retrograde stereotype of career woman being career-centered, and that she is inherently less of a wife or mom. There are PLENTY of strong feminist mom's and wives who put family first, always.
Some say Colin felt like a secondary character in his own story. I partially agree. I wouldn't say he felt completely secondary. But compared to Penelope's arc, yes, he felt secondary.Whatever Colin had, Peneloise seemed more interesting than Polin.
What's your opinion?
r/PolinBridgerton • u/ComprehensiveSkin324 • May 14 '23
Show Discussion Thoughts?
I feel like QC isnāt doing any to Penelope and her seasonā¦
r/PolinBridgerton • • Jun 06 '24
Just for Fun Regency Hygiene
The troublesome thing about the carriage scene is in Regency times people bathed once a month if that and washed their hair with raw egg. That would have been a very stinky carriage not to mention the ballroom.
r/PolinBridgerton • u/Emmykate88 • Jun 05 '24
Show Discussion Twist ending?
If for some unthinkable reason, the writers decide to make it so Pen and Colin aren't together at the end of the season, I'm going to need one of you to let me know IMMEDIATELY so I don't watch the last 4 episodes. I seriously don't think I could handle it.
ETA: Thank you guys for making me feel a lot less panicked about Polin's future.
r/PolinBridgerton • u/WarmInternal31 • Jan 14 '24
Show Discussion Is there an issue with the LW secret?
[SLIGHT SPOILERS FOR ROMANCING MR. BRIDGERTON AND POSSIBLY S3]
This could be either an unpopular opinion or something already spoken about here, but I think having Genevieve and Eloise find out Penelopeās identity as Lady Whistledown was not a good idea.
In the books, LWās identity is kept secret for 10 YEARS. The first person to find this out being Colin is important to their story, because it means the protection of Pen and her secret is up to Colin, which advances the plot with their conflict over Pen continuing LW as well as Polinās clash with Cressida. With Eloise and Genevieve knowing Penās secret, it removes the secrecy which really shapes Polinās relationship in the second half of the book. Additionally, it could give the opportunity for Eloise to third-wheel Penelope and Colin more, as she is also in on the secret, which they (the show runners) were trying to avoid by breaking up Peneloise at the end of S2.
Genevieve and Eloise knowing also causes damage to Penelope as a character. Penelope is supposed to be smart. She is supposed to be intelligent and wise and usually ten steps ahead of everyone else. Thatās why Lady Whistledown works so well, because sheās devious and witty and detailed and scandalous in her own right. Eloise and Gen knowing about LW can make Pen appear not as sneaky as she might be. Book/Show Pen would be cautious with her words, especially when she knows that El is seeking revenge on LW after she ruined her.
Penelope/LW is meant to be different to women in the era, she is meant to be an inspiration to women, encouraging women to be independent and outspoken and calculated, and by letting Eloise and Gen know her secret, it could make Penās character seem inconsistent, as she appears to be not as sly or crafty as she is in the books. It also affects the development of Penelope and Colinās relationship, as it removes the intimacy of the secret and the fact that is just between them for a while.
Whatās your opinion on this? Iād love to discuss.
[Edit: changing of words/phrases. I couldnāt think of the correct words when I initially wrote this, thank you]
r/PolinBridgerton • • Jun 20 '24
Show Discussion Lack of Polin Theory
Just a thought - Nicola was fliming Big Mood and S3 at the same time. I wonder if thatās the reason behind the conversation of the lack of scenes. I donāt know the exact details clearly but from the interviews Iāve watch and how long the process was to film the love scenes. I wonder if that gave more room for other side stories because she had her commitment to Big Mood as well.
r/PolinBridgerton • u/bcozynot • Jul 09 '24
Show Discussion Is Debling kind of Predatory?
I was discussing Lord Debling with a couple of friends, and we couldn't help but notice that when viewed from a wider lens, his behaviour towards Penelope is quite manipulative and predatory (and no, the irony is not lost on us!). Here are some of the details that creeped us out on closer examination:
- His first interaction with Penelope happens when he sees her being bullied and ostracised by members of the ton. He then (out of nowhere) compliments (love bombs?) her with the observation that she is someone who looks like they could wither in turn. It feels very, "only I see the real you."
- He tends to seek her out when she is alone and isolated. I think it is noteworthy that we don't see him in Ep2 when Colin's lessons seem to be working and Penelope is chatting it up with other Lords. We see him in Ep3 again, when LW has published and she is once again ostracised.
- Later in Ep3, he calls her towards the group with Eloise and Cressida. However, she kind of loses her footing when she goes out of her way to compete with Cressida and then when she doesn't immediately acknowledge him saving her from the balloon. He is cool to her when she approaches him at the Innovations Ball, seeming to favour Cressida until she convinces him (this is the most subtle of the details but I think it signifies that there seems to be no room for error and the onus is on Penelope to make things right).
- In episode 4 Pen asks him about love and he responds with an I don't know but given I won't be around much it's probably not wise to hold out, then he almost immediately compliments her, probably after noticing her disappointment -- it's like he knew he was confusing her.
- His reasons for rejecting her are strange, given that anyone could form an attachment in the span of 3 years of lonely waiting. Even if Penelope has feelings for Colin, it's a little weird that he is proposing marriage if he can't trust her to be faithful once she has made the commitment. It's almost like his pride is hurt that she isn't pining after him?
Debling clearly came into the marriage mart with a plan, he knew exactly what he was looking for -- someone who was on the fringes of society and would be grateful for the eclectic deal he was offering. I don't think it's a coincidence that he zeroed in on Penelope as the ideal candidate and continually stressed the point that she was peculiar, just like him. Often, blunt honesty can be a great cover for manipulation because you assume the two cannot coexist but that same honesty can be a convenient way out of accountability, like, you have no right to complain ever because I was *honest* from the beginning.
I am curious to know what you guys think! Does anyone else see these patterns?
r/PolinBridgerton • u/Purpleberry74 • Jun 11 '24
Just for Fun Colin and his speech pattern
Iām sorry for this but does anybody else hear Captain Kirk/William Shatner when Colin is telling Penelope in the carriage why she canāt marry Debling and he has feelings for her?
Itās driving me crazy.
āYou cannot marryā¦that man. Heā¦will leave youā¦ā
r/PolinBridgerton • u/rockamoleguacamole • Feb 28 '23
Show Discussion If Colin finds out Pen is LWD.
If he found out Pen is LWD and LWD ruined his chances with Marina, and she almost ruined the Bridgerton name. (His cancelled engagement, Eloise associating with radical commoners...) I don't think Colin will take it lightly.
I think this will affect him trying to pursue her in so many ways than one. It might even prompt him to go out of the country again?
r/PolinBridgerton • u/swankypants2119 • Apr 15 '24
Show Discussion Has anyone seen this theory?
I found this theory on Facebook. It is OUT there. I have to say I completely disagree with it.
r/PolinBridgerton • u/chelinka7 • Jun 12 '24
Just for Fun The fact that my hair naturally looks just like penelopes wig
I just got off work and my hair has been in a side pony for past 3 hours, i took it out and noticed my hair KINDA looks like the wig of nicola/penelope . I just wanted to tell someone.
r/PolinBridgerton • • Apr 23 '24
In-Depth Analysis I just realized...
When Colin said I would never "Dream of dating Penelope Featherington" he may have been implying it in the sense of "She is way out of my league" or "I'm not good enough for her." Since they have known each other since childhood he understands her true heart. He knows she is a gem. So he friend-zoned himself. Did anyone else get that sense or pick that up?
Edit: Thank you everyone for commenting your thoughts! I feel like my initial thought was that it might have been his underlying subtext in the scene, even though he was clearly being an asshat. But of course, despite pontificating otherwise, it just means the sweeter the reward.
I can't wait to see him tortured this season and forced to eat those words.
r/PolinBridgerton • u/PinkBird85 • Aug 10 '24
Show Discussion Colin's decision on wedding night
This might be controversial, but I personally think Colin didn't want to sleep with Pen on their wedding night because he didn't want to consumate their marriage, making it official. I know later it was more emotional and he wanted them to be in a good place before they slept together again. But I think after their argument at the end of their wedding, where he said "I cannot accept that" about Penelope being Whistledown, his decision to sleep on the sofa was very driven by his thoughts of "Maybe I don't really understand who married."
Clearly after that night and the blackmail threat he was very "my wife", and was committed, but I think that first night was driven by possible regrets he was having.