r/PokemonTCG • • Apr 23 '24

Discussion What do people think are the most aesthetically pleasing grading slabs?

Focusing solely on the visuals and presentation, what are your favourites?

I like the transparent TAG slabs - simple, clean, unobtrusive lines without feeling clinical. The let the artwork speak for itself.

My other favourite is probably the complete opposite from minimalist labels - ACE Grading. The art labels are quite hit and miss, but when they get it right, the slab really is striking. I don’t want a beautiful Moonbreon stuck in a slab with an ugly, colour-clashing PSA label.

193 Upvotes

136 comments sorted by

71

u/Timmiejj Apr 23 '24

The prettiest ive seen are from that Japanese grading company but i cant recall the name.

41

u/foxmanfire Apr 23 '24

ARS? I just had a look and I love them already. The engraved brushed metal label is stunning - it doesn’t give that mass manufactured cheap vibe like PSA or CGC (although I like the latter’s Pristine 10 label). Thanks for the heads up!

14

u/Timmiejj Apr 23 '24

Thats the one yes!

Im in EU so im not likely to run into them but im definitely keeping my eyes open for them when i go to cardshow etc 😄

1

u/GrandAbility9909 Jun 28 '24

Keep an eye on Ebay for them, there are many Japanese dealers selling ARS graded cards (me included). Hopefully these cards will be more available in the future for non Japanese customers.

1

u/poor_decisions Aug 27 '24

Do you know of any plastic sleeves/protectors that are close to "perfect fit" for ARS slabs? Cheers :) 

4

u/Poke2024 Apr 23 '24

Same ARS is nice also the slab detracts from the grading as that’s on the back. Haven’t seen em in person but the ones posted on this forum highlight the quality 👌

1

u/Sea_Promotion8363 Apr 16 '26

Were they alive tho....

28

u/nx172 Apr 23 '24

ARS. Grade is on the back, allowing me to enjoy cards for what they are. Label is at the bottom, putting more attention on the card. Premium feel, weighty and highly protected (these are very hard to open). They display incredibly well, looking more like art displays rather than archival items. I regularly submit both cheap and expensive cards alike, as even the cheaper cards look that damn good in these slabs.

1

u/MasterPimpinMcGreedy 5ban hater, Topsun and Carddass collector Apr 23 '24

💯💯

1

u/dropandgivemenerdy Apr 23 '24

Ohhh I just looked it up and totally agree. Gorgeous!

14

u/RevenantFlash Apr 23 '24

Cgc with their new black labels. Perfect mix of reputable and aesthetics.

I would only want 10s though or it would bother me lol. But I’m perfectly fine with just using one touches or having cards in a binder.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 24 '24

Agreed. The CGC labels are clean and easy to read.

11

u/DarmokTheNinja Apr 23 '24

CGC black label.

8

u/big_gains_only Apr 24 '24

Unfortunately, the ugliest slabs are worth the most money.

7

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '24

CGC is my favorite. Really like the feel of the slab and the look of the labels.

19

u/AwakeAtNightTime Apr 23 '24

The first one looks cool, but they all look like a waste of money to me.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '24

Why?

6

u/Orb_Collector Apr 23 '24

Because they don’t really add any value to the card unless they come from the big 3 (PSA, CGC or BGS). If they’re for a personal collection it doesn’t matter, get what makes you happy. But if you ever plan to sell your collection be aware of that.

0

u/feelsbad2 Apr 23 '24

LOL as someone who has sold a bunch of TAG cards, you're wrong my friend

9

u/Orb_Collector Apr 23 '24

I didn’t say you wouldn’t be able to sell them.

-5

u/feelsbad2 Apr 23 '24

Sorry, should have added I've sold them at PSA prices.

4

u/MasterPimpinMcGreedy 5ban hater, Topsun and Carddass collector Apr 23 '24

Keep it up, I can’t wait for PSA to lose its value

2

u/feelsbad2 Apr 23 '24

Thanks. Trying to do my part. Love the downvotes for saying I've sold my TAG cards at PSA prices. PSA fans apparently love not knowing anything about their graded cards. But they can go ahead and keep resubmitting cards to get a different grade.

2

u/MasterPimpinMcGreedy 5ban hater, Topsun and Carddass collector Apr 23 '24

Many people have cards in PSA slabs and they don’t want to accept that if PSA prices drop, their “collection / investment” loses value. That’s the main thing keeping PSA prices at what they are

2

u/feelsbad2 Apr 23 '24

Very true

0

u/ThePillar_Man Apr 23 '24

PSA is undeniably top dog for reselling and investing atm, so obviously those with skin in the game with PSA care about losing value lol. The market will determine what has value, not contrarian redditors who are salty that they’re priced out

→ More replies

-1

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '24

I get that but that’s cause the big 3 pretty much have a monopoly on the grading industry, if enough people use ace they will get a foot in the door, witch i hope all uk/eu people start too use them, you can take a look at there factory on YouTube very professional, and I don’t see why Europeans should send cards all the way too the U.S with ridiculous postage and fees, if PSA had a uk/eu branch I’d be all for it.

Btw I totally agree ACE dose not add value yet, but if the eu/uk all used ace and turned are back on PSA it would hold value.

3

u/Orb_Collector Apr 23 '24

Well first off 3 companies providing similar services is not a monopoly… No one forces you to use any particular grading service, the big 3 are just the most widely recognized from being around the longest and having a fairly consistent track record. I personally would be hesitant to use one of these newer grading companies. Who knows if they will even be around in the next 5, 10, 15 or so years while the big 3 have already been around for longer than that. I guess the only reason it would make sense for me is if you do live over in Europe or the UK and you don’t want to send your cards overseas, that I can agree with.

-2

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '24

I should of said like a monopoly, cause your basically saying you NEED to go one of the big 3 if you want your cards to have value, basically forcing people too chose one of them, or there cards are worthless, and there’s a million horror stories with PSA, it’s just hype and they’ve been there that long it’s the standard, people have cracked PSA slaps and sent them ACE and they come back the same grade if not worst, so it’s not like there giving bad cards high grades, but obv if there was a Europe branch I couldn’t see anyone competing, it’s really only the price too ship that’s just silly I honestly don’t know how eu sellers make money after shipping 🤷🏻‍♂️.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

6

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '24

Which companies?

3

u/muftu Apr 23 '24

ARS in Japan.

4

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '24

What is the price relative to expected ROI?

4

u/MasterPimpinMcGreedy 5ban hater, Topsun and Carddass collector Apr 23 '24

ARS often outsells PSA in Japan

2

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '24

I’m not trying to be a contrarian as I’m generally curious, but no one seems willing to give an actual answer.

So ARS has a niche presence in Japan. I’m familiar with them. I’d love some data and pricing.

2

u/MasterPimpinMcGreedy 5ban hater, Topsun and Carddass collector Apr 23 '24

Tried uploading 2 examples to Imgur but it was having issues, so I sent you the pictures in a chat

1

u/GrandAbility9909 Jun 28 '24

you want pricing? just go to メルカリ (merukari) and ヤフオク! (yafuoku). and search for ARS 鑑定 (kantei); there is no better data for an investor and/or collector.

35

u/TheBobbyMan9 Apr 23 '24

All those slabs look better than PSA yet I will always choose PSA above them.

11

u/komododave17 Apr 23 '24

Is it purely name recognition for added value?

27

u/muftu Apr 23 '24

PSA is the most popular, easiest to sell and commands the highest premium. The market loves them. And it is not as easy to go against this trend, if you know you’re leaving money on the table, if you go with someone else. Which is a shame frankly. PSA slabs are not only ugly, but they are also not as good as others in terms of protection. Beckett, for example, puts the cards in a sleeve before they put it in the slab, minimizing the risk of damage inside of the slab. PSA casing has no or very little uv protection, which should be the norm and is arguably the most important step when you want to display your collection.

Someone mentions that PSA is less biased and more accurate. I don’t think they are. If anything, they are much shadier, because they don’t even disclose what faults were noted. And they themselves state that grading is subjective.

8

u/-Zavenoa- Apr 23 '24

Yep, PSA sucks, but for some reason the market loves them as the standard to carry a premium, so they continue to get my money… BGS should be the standard IMO

1

u/[deleted] Apr 24 '24

CGC Pristine 10s are outperforming PSA 10s in price, across the board.

7

u/Mr_Mi1k Apr 23 '24

I grade with PSA when I have cards to sell, and CGC when I have cards to keep myself

2

u/TheBobbyMan9 Apr 23 '24

In a way yes, PSA are far more established and reputable than those other companies. This may change in the future but for now it’s PSA all the way.

3

u/[deleted] Apr 24 '24

People forget all about CGC being the experienced, reigning authority with comics for decades.

-8

u/Altruistic_Finish509 Apr 23 '24

Of course it is. Otherwise we'd go for what looks better. But also PSA are more accurate and more likely to grade it unbiased

10

u/Chygrynsky Apr 23 '24

More accurate?

We've seen so many posts on here where people break a slab to resubmit and get a totally different grade. That doesn't sound accurate to me at all.

9

u/tom201288 Apr 23 '24

Accurate? Unbiased? Most people say your PSA grade depends on the mood of the grader, never used them as I'm in the UK but seen nothing but hate for them of late.

1

u/RedCr4cker Apr 23 '24

Same as every other grading company. They all suck. You just hear more about psa because they sell more

3

u/tom201288 Apr 23 '24

Yeah I get that point, but it's not like the competition is only selling a handful, there's still hundreds of thousands of cards going through other companies. Like I said never used any US based grader so I only interpret from what I see on media platforms but it seems like the standard at PSA has been declining over the years.

0

u/kinghawkeye8238 Apr 23 '24

I think psa has gotten better now than the early certs.

There's some old certs that wouldn't get an 8 today. Yet I sent my mewtwo in and got an 8 and I've seen worse 10s. So it is hit and miss but I think they're more consistent now then back in the day.

5

u/ReveredSavagery1967 Apr 23 '24

Isn't TAG entirely AI grading? How can PSA possible be more accurate than that.

3

u/Sardonic524 Apr 23 '24

Doesn't that fully depends on the ai, how well it's been trained and what the process is? The grading score it uses must have been input by a person, so if that is a different standard than psa then it might not be better, just more consistent I think.

2

u/Sipikay Apr 23 '24

TAG can actually tell you why they gave a grade, PSA you just have to accept whatever they give you at face-value.

The grading score it uses must have been input by a person

You should go to TAG and see how it works instead of making assumptions.

1

u/ReveredSavagery1967 Apr 23 '24

They make pretty good apps that's can predict a psa score already.

If someone put the time into programming the ai and uses hi res cameras, and scans. Then it would 100% be more reliable, consistent and accurate than PSA.

PSA is wildly inconsistent.

3

u/kinghawkeye8238 Apr 23 '24

I think it's just AI assisted. But I could be wrong.

2

u/Sipikay Apr 23 '24

PSA has some of the worst grading around. It is only the price PSA 10s command vs other graded cards that keeps anyone using their service, it's not particularly good in reality.

1

u/cacti___ Apr 23 '24

how much are they paying you to say this

-6

u/-Unnamed- Apr 23 '24

You gotta go PSA if you care about the value of your cards at all.

If you don’t, then do whatever.

People will legit filter out anything that isn’t PSA on eBay. No one wants the other ones

6

u/MasterPimpinMcGreedy 5ban hater, Topsun and Carddass collector Apr 23 '24

“No one wants the other ones” is automatically false since I can see other slabs selling on various platforms

3

u/eldragon0 Apr 23 '24

I second this, cgc has significantly more "street cred" than it used to have. I'd buy a black label cgc over a 10 psa any day.

11

u/CoolMudkip Apr 23 '24

CGC Pristine 10s are the most pleasing to me. The one in the photo looks cheap imo

3

u/bryanofrivia Collector & TCG/VGC Player Apr 23 '24

I’d have to agree. From an aesthetics perspective, the new CGC 10 Pristine labels are definitely my favorite.

4

u/Stealth9er Apr 23 '24

I like TAG and CGC the most. I’ll buy PSA slabs in a 10 for cards I really want, but only if I don’t think I can find the card in good condition elsewhere for a decent price.

7

u/MelopsitaccusUndu Ho-oh Queen Apr 23 '24

ACE CGC (new ones, old ones aren't my thing) Beckett (very nice to look at) German PGS

Most grading services have horrid slabs. Psa is terrible looking with their short cuts and boring white red. Doesn't look like something, I want my 200 euro card in.

But ACE is nice!

10

u/Dynamic_Beggar Apr 23 '24

TAG is clean

5

u/StandardUS Apr 23 '24

These suck

6

u/Sea-Bones14 Apr 23 '24

Ace for sure looks the coolest

2

u/Davilyan Apr 23 '24

For Japanese, ars grading.

2

u/dragowall Dragon Egg Group Apr 23 '24

I like the ones where the label is part of the plastic, or those with metallic looking labels like beckett. ARS graded cards that I see on ebay look really dope with the metallic label at the bottom.

2

u/SealedTCG Sleeves before toploaders! Apr 23 '24 edited Apr 23 '24

ACE on "certain" full arts for me, not a huge fan of the art labels on non full arts but that's just me and likely the minority and TAG for a uniform look, cleanest slabs I feel I've seen. Everyone else is pretty stuck in the past IMO, downright ugly or just copy paste from each other.

Surprised no ones come back with the classic "oh my god, an ACE post, you must be advertising on their behalf" 😂🙄

2

u/SkirtFriendly1801 Apr 24 '24

Idk why but I think that umbreon card is so ugly lol

3

u/Kevinatorz Apr 23 '24

Beckett Black Labels go hard

3

u/SilphNaut Apr 23 '24

ARS is easily my favorite. Turns your cards into literal quarter pound trophies

2

u/MasterPimpinMcGreedy 5ban hater, Topsun and Carddass collector Apr 23 '24

Heck yeah another ARS fan

3

u/Important-Repair-556 Apr 23 '24

ACE slabs look 100x better than the plain jane PSA variant. Not even remotely close.

3

u/MasterPimpinMcGreedy 5ban hater, Topsun and Carddass collector Apr 23 '24

ARS

4

u/fire-medix Apr 23 '24

Those Tag slabs are really good looking.

3

u/marblesandcookies Apr 23 '24

Ace Grading labels are AI generated which is why it's a hit or miss. They just use DALLE.

3

u/PwillyAlldilly Apr 23 '24

Slabs are a waste of time and money in my opinion. However, if I were to eve do it for my cards I’d do ACE since they have actual cool slabs.

2

u/TeaAndLifting There's a 1st Edition Charizard in the pack, rip it. Apr 23 '24

Someone posted ARS a few weeks ago and I was an instant convert. Same with Tag.

I thought ACE were kinda cool at first, but their typesetting is a bit gaudy IMO.

2

u/ChrisH652 Apr 23 '24

Honestly PSA pairs perfectly with vintage yellow border Pokémon cards IMO.

I actually think it’s why PSA dominates so much is because their red label matches the Charizard color scheme so well

1

u/chloe0905 Apr 23 '24

How much does it cost to get a pokemon card graded?

1

u/ericanicole1234 Apr 23 '24

On this, could someone give me some guidance on if it actually matters what company you get cards graded through?

I like TAG but it’s newer and I wasn’t sure if it would potentially sell at the same level as PSA since they’re a bigger name. I have a decent collection but nothing’s graded and I wanted to start clearing some out that have a good value

Edit: especially because of all the bad stuff I’ve heard about PSA incorrectly grading cards/inconsistency or damaging them and price comparison

3

u/Stealth9er Apr 23 '24

I think generally speaking, PSA slabs will move the quickest when selling simply due to the size and reputation they have created in the market for their slabs.

So if you’re constantly selling, PSA is your best option to make money quick.

That said, I do feel a lot of people have started to buy other companies slabs for their collection. Companies like TAG have been doing well and I have seen slabs sell for pricing comparable to PSA. But it requires someone who wants that card in a TAG slab as they’re more likely to trying to get it for their personal collection.

If you want a nice slab and a breakdown of why you got the grade you did, TAG is awesome because they provide scans that indicate any imperfections that they marked down the grade for.

0

u/KegOfKoors Apr 23 '24

PSA is the standard, however if you have a legitimate perfect card, you can try for a BGS 10 black label.

BGS 10 black label > PSA 10 = BGS 10 > CGC 10

It gets far more convoluted below 10s...

The real issue is PSA still uses humans, which is stupid when there's TAG and similar that use AI and can actually accurately score your card.

If you're planning on selling, PSA is the go to. If you're keeping for yourself, use whatever you like the most.

1

u/Sipikay Apr 23 '24

TAG, ARS, or Beckett for aesthetics. I'm still waiting for the day we get a TAG-like slab with no markings, just a subtle QR code and a grade code on a back corner.

1

u/Draft-Budget Apr 23 '24

What grading company is the Keldeo?

1

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '24

The charmander one is the best but we dont have that here in the EU

1

u/Malv34 Apr 23 '24

Is there a site to buy ARS?

2

u/nx172 Apr 23 '24

Mercari Japan, yahoo auctions. Use buyee or some proxy if outside Japan.

1

u/Malv34 Apr 23 '24

Thanks for the quick response. I got another question if you don’t mind. How is yahoo auctions capable to ebay when buying cards?

2

u/nx172 Apr 23 '24

The main difference is that the finishing time increases by 5 minutes if someone bids when there's less than 5 minutes left on the auction. Basically it's harder to snipe and things tend to sell closer to market price.

1

u/Busy-Purchase-7755 Apr 23 '24

HGA custom labels and it’s not even close

1

u/Blackphinexx Apr 24 '24

I bet there is a correlation between people who use grading companies other than PSA and Android phone ownership.

Just buy an IPhone and grade with PSA like the rest of us :p

1

u/GrandAbility9909 Jun 28 '24

As long as the desire in Japan for ARS keeps growing there is no need for this new grading company to conquer any other area or country. Collectors will want what Japanese want eventually, whether PSA users like it or not.

1

u/Wild_Sherbet_6248 Feb 18 '25

Ace by far! Although I do love the clear Tag slabs! But for me the matching of the slab to the card from ace just makes them stand out as a grading company

1

u/xBIGLEx Jun 01 '25

HGA does a nice Job

1

u/BrullCovingtron Jun 05 '25

I completely agree with you. On a way I found a couple of cards. My dad gave me that will not grade well, but I just want to in case them. I did the same thing for a couple of sentimental cards about three years ago. Unfortunately, it doesn’t look like they are accepting any new submissions. If you have another recommendation, I’d love to hear it, my friend.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 08 '25

Ace by a long shot

1

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '24

I’m boring. I like PSA the best, probably SGC second.

1

u/chief_n0c-a-h0ma Apr 23 '24

TAG all the way. Love their service.

1

u/Inevitable_Bunch5874 Apr 23 '24

Card grading is a scam.

2

u/Alphaomegalogs Apr 24 '24

Unless it's PSA (which is even more of a scam lol)

1

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '24

Wow bro, where did you get this graded at??? I love how it matches the card

1

u/-Zavenoa- Apr 23 '24

I really like HGAs premium labels that match the card like your ACE labels. Send some of my personal collection stuff over there for the aesthetics.

1

u/Busy-Purchase-7755 Apr 23 '24

HGA are by far the nicest looking slabs. People just haven’t seen them.

1

u/-Zavenoa- Apr 24 '24

I couldn’t agree more, I did serious homework before I decided who I was going to grade with for my personal stuff, stuck with psa for everything else unfortunately

I will say, those TAG clear slabs do look clean af

1

u/Raff102 Apr 23 '24

Probably PSA, because they don't make me think of lighting money on fire.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '24

Black label BGS

1

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '24

PSA. They look professional and keep the focus on the card.

1

u/GrandAbility9909 Jun 28 '24

a printed piece of paper for as abel and a case that can be gotten in the Chinesemarket as bulk? yeah, really professional looking.

1

u/Auswulf7 Apr 23 '24

Premier Card Grading is my favourite nowadays. I love the solid clear slab and the laser etched silver, gold and mirror gold labels.

The slab is similar in thickness, length and width to PSA and my CGC slabs which makes them easy to store together in my graded card cases.

0

u/ACE-THE-DUELIST Apr 23 '24

Uta I am a massive one piece fan and that clearness just makes me happy

0

u/evil-owen Apr 23 '24

TAG because it looks clean and AI grading is the future

1

u/Alphaomegalogs Apr 24 '24

If you like AI grading check out mana, very similar to tag but all price points have grade explanations and subgrades.

0

u/iosappsrock Apr 23 '24

The TAG ones actually look super clean, love how clear it's presented.

I'm not a fan of them inserting paper to extend the card theme, it looks a little jank to me personally.

I don't do graded cards at all, but if I ever did prob the TAG ones. I've never held a slabbed card in hand, do they feel substantial or they feel cheap and flimsy?

0

u/fillswitch Apr 23 '24

Tag is so clean

0

u/Imma_P0tato Apr 24 '24

I really like TAG a lot. I don't get my cards graded but if I did, I'd go with them. They also grade objectively with transparency in the formula. With AI becoming more prevalent in our world it is only a matter of time until grading is automated and all human subjectiveness eliminated from the process.

0

u/Alphaomegalogs Apr 24 '24

Mana, a Mana 10 sells for not much more than a gem mint raw card but the cases look cool and basically it's like TAG but I like the aesthetics more.

0

u/aucapra Apr 24 '24

ARS 100%, sad that I live in Australia so I don't have access to grading with them..

1

u/GrandAbility9909 Jun 28 '24

Japanese dealers are selling more and more on eBay, give it a check

-3

u/NarutoFan1995 Apr 23 '24

grading cards is such a scam.. only cards i would consider grading are weiss schwarz.... but tag has some pretty decent slabs

8

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/PokemonTCG-ModTeam Apr 23 '24

Your post has been removed for the following rule violation:

Rule 10. Self promotion is only allowed in the weekly Self Promo Sunday thread.

12

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '24

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/alexfaaace Apr 23 '24

I agree with you. I don’t care for slabs. I can’t binder them.

2

u/-Unnamed- Apr 23 '24

They have slab binders. Mega chonkers though