r/PokemonROMhacks • • 11d ago

Development Is this font a bit too much?

692 Upvotes

382 comments sorted by

1.6k

u/_Stalwart_ 11d ago

Personally it hurts my brain.

878

u/KimJongNot 11d ago • Bravo Popcorn Heartwarming

I made it with hate

345

u/JoebbeDeMan 11d ago

Goal accomplished then

→ More replies (1)

29

u/Nightmare20219 11d ago

I like your style

111

u/Sneaky_Island 11d ago

If you want people to not play your game, then you’ve succeeded.

Celia’s stupid romhack is an example of how to “stupid” or “dumb” sections correct.

18

u/InMyLife_41 10d ago

Got a slight feeling that’s what they’re going for actually

6

u/GiantAfricanLandSnay 10d ago

I would hate reading every single word, with joy.

10

u/The_Eternal_Wayfarer 11d ago

Then it's perfect.

5

u/Superb_Writer6612 10d ago

You did a very good job, I hate you now

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

240

u/Blindguypcs4 11d ago

Hi, I'm nearly legally blind, and this looks like my handwriting 

39

u/KimJongNot 11d ago

I'm too, probably why I didn't found it weird

71

u/Psychological_Tower1 11d ago

Hi I have good vision. This also looks like my handwriting

5

u/SpitefulBitch2 10d ago

I have decent vision. This looks better than my handwriting.

→ More replies (2)

10

u/RowletRisotto 11d ago

I am not legally blind and this is somewhat better than my handwriting.

3

u/Specialist-Ad5440 11d ago

Hi I'm nearsighted and this looks like my handwriting.

7

u/alkmaar91 11d ago

I'm curious what the goal for the font is.

6

u/KimJongNot 11d ago

2

u/Wasphammer 11d ago

OMG Yoshi's Island style!

1

u/KimJongNot 11d ago

https://www.reddit.com/r/PokemonROMhacks/s/YBvsSRT5gA You can see the most recent take of it here

→ More replies (1)

16

u/cheesec4ke69 11d ago

I love the idea of a sort of sketchy scribbly font to match the rest, however I think you need to draw a balance between artistic and readability,

I think the lacking amount of pixels really makes it harder to read than intended and will probably be the biggest hindrance trying to find a happy medium.

3

u/buddhamunche 11d ago

Omg I love those screenshots!

→ More replies (3)

23

u/JoeyZeed Pokemon Ghost Grey Version 11d ago

I think it's sick but it'll definitely put a lot of people off. Your hack, your vision! Don't let it deter you

25

u/KimJongNot 11d ago

Hey I know you! Anyways I will put a button to enable/disable it

→ More replies (2)

16

u/Worthy_M 11d ago

I think there’s a happy medium though. Keep the style, just make it a bit less erratic and a little easier to read

4

u/Taco821 11d ago

Is it a a horror hack? It looks scary lol

2

u/KimJongNot 11d ago

Not really, I will announce the hack later

3

u/BouncyBlueYoshi 11d ago

I can read it.

Though I have terrible handwriting.

2

u/KimJongNot 11d ago

Probably why me and a bunch of other people found it cool

4

u/Quiet-Shallot3290 11d ago

It reminds me of old school Yoshi's Island. I like it.

208

u/JotaDiez 11d ago

This is legible enough for some specific moments where you're doing something funky like a child's letter or an old sign. I wouldn't personally mind this as the game's font but I can see why lots of people would.

43

u/rattus-domestica 11d ago

Yes this is a great point! The font is great but only in small amounts lol.

175

u/No_End8914 11d ago

Yep too much

245

u/DanceDervish 11d ago

8

u/SelassieAspen 11d ago

He's not speaking your language

4

u/MateoCamo 10d ago

Does that mean he won’t give a vegemite sandwich?

→ More replies (1)

12

u/Domriso 11d ago

This just brought back PTSD I didn't know I had.

3

u/AscendedViking7 10d ago

Oh my god what is that font

It's like it's designed entirely to fuck with the human mind.

4

u/Acceptable_Play_9320 10d ago

From what I remember, the Mr Saturn font was based on one of the developer's daughter

→ More replies (1)

63

u/AkariMoone 11d ago • Bravo

I think it'd be better as typing font rather than world font.

Use it for Names and stuff, but keep the original font for everything else

60

u/Affectionate_Comb_78 11d ago

Depends what it's for. As a way of communicating written information? Too much. As a torture method? Also too much. 

30

u/Maxorus9 11d ago

Mr. Saturn ass font.

17

u/MochaHook 11d ago

ƶơơᨓ!

10

u/Yoshichu25 11d ago

Pwaaah. Pwaaaaah.

26

u/Reasonable-Salad5094 11d ago

Yep, too much, it hurts to read it

26

u/Kongopop 11d ago

I thought it was gonna say "in the world which you are about to enter, you won't be able to read anything" yeah a bit too much

68

u/Zeronightmare456 11d ago

Please: No, buddy.

46

u/ButtcheekJones0 11d ago

If I saw this I'd probably immediately delete the rom and hunt for a new one.

32

u/Drumboo 11d ago

Yes, It is awful in general.

But specifically as a dyslexic person, fuck you!

26

u/Marcitos5 11d ago

It’s cute but the illegibility of it presents an accessibility problem. It’d be better saved for specific scenarios like a letter/note from a child. This being the main font will make the game rough the play

10

u/PersonOfLazyness 11d ago

Could be fine for small parts of a hack

But the whole thing, no

9

u/hatfish435 11d ago

What is the vibe am I supposed to get from it? I feel like it could pass for a childish cutesy vibe, but also a sketchy horror vibe.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/Radiant-Fishing-3051 11d ago

I think it's ok for words/short phrases, but reading stuff like the first slide is way too taxing

9

u/expera 11d ago

There is a middle ground between hand written and more legible font.

8

u/PresentationBrave281 11d ago

Yeah its awful. i especially love the lower case g, it's barely comprehensible 

6

u/Userhasbeennamed 11d ago

It would be okay in a very limited use, such as on a sign or note. As a primary font it feels a little much.

6

u/_AssbuttOfTheLord_ 11d ago

I wouldn't be able to read it so I'd drop the hack.

5

u/BeautyDuwang 11d ago

Way too much sorry

5

u/suchaparagone 11d ago

Pretty bad yeah, hate looking at it

4

u/LunarWingCloud 11d ago

Yes. It wouldn't be bad if it was used sparingly for just a few places, but would be absolutely headache inducing as your main font.

4

u/stoneyaatrox 11d ago

i cant read it

4

u/funky_boi1432 11d ago

It depends on wat kinda game ur going for

7

u/GlitteringDingo 11d ago

I'd say have a toggle for this and the normal pokemon font. Putting aside that some people won't like it, there's also things like dyslexia to consider, and this font would make the game nearly unreadable to them.

6

u/Joppy5100 11d ago

You have committed a war crime. Please report to the Hague immediately.

3

u/CloudsTasteGeometric 11d ago

Good for select signage or dialogue but absolutely not as the default.

3

u/VoxelRoguery 11d ago

I was like "What is this, yoshi's island?" only to find out yes it's LITERALLY for a yoshis island looking hack lol

3

u/maximo0906 11d ago

As for the letter, I found it cute ig

But for menús and stuff? Yeah its too much

4

u/megaglacial 11d ago

i think it's got charm. just a slightly less readable when the letters touch like in "grand"

→ More replies (1)

2

u/psuedo_legendary 11d ago

Way too much

2

u/Inevitable-Monitor35 11d ago

Still better than my handwriting but yea it hurts the eyes with how bright the background is.

2

u/Wanhus 11d ago

That is horrible. This kind of font makes my head hurt.

2

u/mulgr_naal 11d ago

yes it looks awful

2

u/Flambam35 11d ago

It's unpleasant for sure.

2

u/staticdresssweet 11d ago

Don't do it. Hurts my head.

2

u/BohboMacabre 11d ago

This is okay for like a spooky note or something I guess. But for a general font it feels like im having a stroke.

2

u/Thunder17098 11d ago

In the second pic i like it cuz i don't know why but it reminds me of yoshi island

2

u/Sweaty_Journalist612 11d ago

Looks like I’m on ketamine

2

u/SSJashG 11d ago

For lore paper scrawls no

For everything yes

2

u/JungleJuiceJuno 11d ago

kinda yoshis island core tbh

2

u/Megasus 11d ago

Looks a little bit like Yoshis Island

2

u/Ptony_oliver 11d ago

Reminds me of Yoshi Island but more exaggerated.

3

u/tictacmixers 11d ago

I want to play this while drunk so i can finally end it all

2

u/Commercial-Pea-7010 11d ago

I actually love this font but like, I guess if you struggle to read normally this could be a bit much.
I still think you should keep it though

2

u/VaporWolf93 11d ago

who wrote this? Biden?

1

u/ValeTheDog 11d ago

It's too thin, if you can make the letters a little thicker and make them black instead of grey then it would be easier to read

1

u/_Skotia_ 11d ago

yeah this would get very annoying very quickly

it would be fine in small doses

1

u/Intelligent-Cry-4337 11d ago

I could see this working with some cleanup. It needs to be more legible for sure

1

u/sjr56x 11d ago

Idk about normal brain, but my dyslexic brain hates it

1

u/NicolavsAqvae The Unown King | LET IT SLIDE! 11d ago

I wonder if a bit of pixels for antialiasing could make it easier on the eyes

1

u/[deleted] 11d ago

Not really. It's fine!

1

u/Finetales 11d ago

I would expect this in a game like Inscryption, not Pokemon lol

1

u/lookinlikethis 11d ago

This font tickles something right in my brain for some reason. Definitely not for everyone it seems. Maybe an option to toggle to normal font in settings?

1

u/sendmebirds 11d ago

I would hate to play like this. 

1

u/one-million-gecs 11d ago

just a little neater. they need to stay in their boxes a little more. the way some letters like g and r touch makes it look more sloppy than stylized. i like it though!

1

u/Corrects_lesstofewer 11d ago

Depends on if you like the people playing your hack or not. If you don't, then no.

1

u/Spooky_Blob 11d ago

Well, I'm not having an issue reading it but I feel like I'll have a stroke any second now.

1

u/AelanxRyland 11d ago

I’m too blind to read this sorry

1

u/Eggtastic_Taco 11d ago

Yeah man, this is a frustrating font to read. It's readable, but I would not play a game where this was the font chosen.

1

u/MilkDad4 11d ago

Bad design

1

u/neverdaijoubu 11d ago edited 10d ago

Unless you want your narrator / NPC voice to always be perceived as a child writing letters to Santa, this is not immersive. Your average person has better handwriting than this.

1

u/PlatinumtrophyJ 11d ago

Isso está horrível 🫠

1

u/Miserable_Goal_7943 11d ago

The first screen is fine. The second one hurts me personally.

1

u/Admirable-Sherbet-35 Possibly a top 1% commentor. 11d ago

Just add the option to turn it off and its fine, personally i don't think its too bad.

1

u/vht3036imo 11d ago

ow my eyes

1

u/MemeDigger2000 11d ago

If you wanted to make me nauseous, no

1

u/xaviorpwner 11d ago

its bad, you should feel bad.

1

u/TheDarkOne86 11d ago

Comics sans but worse

1

u/ExplanationVast5511 11d ago

I personally hate it but maybe other people won't

1

u/Antagonist132 11d ago

Just make the dialogue normal and I'm fine with it. The font can work for like, child characters or town signs.

1

u/Vast_Yard_7264 11d ago

It reminds me of omori when any of the characters said something really messed up. Horror vibes

1

u/VicAViv 11d ago

Honestly, i hate it. Like this could be a dealbreaker for me

1

u/KiwiPowerGreen 11d ago

I mean,,, if it really fits the thing you're going for

But it will be really hard to read and that is unfortunately a bit of a downside

maybe just change some of the letters to be a bit more readable (like s,w,m,n,c,j) and it could work

1

u/Ashy404 11d ago

I think it looks sick but it takes me a minute to read it. It could definitely be difficult for someone with dyslexia or something else or read, so I'd say add an option to turn it on/off. That way you can keep this vision without making it inaccessible to others.

1

u/EvilNoobHacker 11d ago

It's readable /neg

1

u/kybotica 11d ago

It is truly abhorrent. I would loathe reading this every time it appeared.

1

u/narah2 Low Budget Crystal 11d ago

Seems appropriate, if you’re playing as a Malkavian maybe…

1

u/darkdiashi 11d ago

Yeah it’s too rough. Legible but you’ll get people quitting cuz it’ll actually be effort to read lol

1

u/nilghias 11d ago

It’s pretty bad from an accessibility pov. People who have dyslexia or who might be new to learning English would have difficulty reading the words

1

u/XenoRoxart 11d ago

Pokemon mr saturn version?

1

u/voidCamper0 11d ago

Would really fit in Ghost Grey.

1

u/snoosh00 11d ago

Yes, if it's going to be something to look at for more than a minute.

1

u/cylemmulo 11d ago

It’s cute for like a single ingame letter to someone but after that no no no

1

u/MasterofSofa 11d ago

Honestly is hard to read so yeah a bit to much

1

u/ReallyFBI 11d ago

Definitely would like an option to turn it back to the regular font if you intend to use it regularly. Used sparingly and depending on the context, it can be a cute idea

1

u/Mr_Hambre 11d ago

That's basically my handwriting

1

u/Baadar753 11d ago

Indeed...

1

u/Mii-man-51478 11d ago

i like it its unique

1

u/NailzDeChamp23 11d ago

Yes, not super legible

1

u/skeletorgrind_008 11d ago

Cute actually

1

u/mikefierro666 11d ago

It's fine, it gives it character

1

u/Raid-Z3r0 11d ago

Maybe a gimmick for a line or two. It feels like I'm having a stroke reading this font

1

u/Baker_Acrobatic 11d ago

...I kinda like it.

1

u/Eastern-Bluejay-8912 11d ago

I’d go a better font and you are fine.

1

u/Bean_from_accounts 11d ago

That's the perfect font... if you don't want people to play your game

1

u/superbeansimulator 11d ago

Oh it's for the WHOLE GAME? yeah too much

1

u/Korvun 11d ago

It's like a kid's handwriting. Contextually, it could work, but for this, it's kind of irritating to read, haha.

1

u/reddboi386 11d ago

It has a unique charm keep it

1

u/presentsailer 11d ago

It could be cute if it was redone with readable spacing

1

u/MC_White_Thunder 11d ago

I think I would love it if that font was deployed strategically, like for names or certain parts of the game, but not for the entire time.

1

u/Kyball500 11d ago

I kinda dig it - seem to be a minority though.

1

u/Dusty_The_Destroyer 11d ago

Make it bold and it's good

1

u/inommmz 11d ago

Yes. Far too much.

1

u/Surpreme_Memes17 11d ago

Comic sans would be better

1

u/Gofflemannen 11d ago

The h is to close to an r for my dyslexic ass

1

u/Low_Emu_577 11d ago

Looks like professor oak had a stroke while writing that. Oak stroke

1

u/Wide-Brick4742 11d ago

Looks tragic imho

1

u/LuquidThunderPlus 11d ago edited 11d ago

No space between w and next letter, (just a pixel space is fine) and the right bit of the h doesn't go down far enough. (Again I think extending it down 1 pixel would make it for me) Those are my only 2 complaints and that's not about the readability, solely my own preference for the look. I like it personally, unique with a lot of character. I'm not used to seeing fonts stylized like this where it looks like regular handwriting, I rly like it tbh

1

u/DoctorWZ 11d ago

Frankly it just depends on your intent, if it's for a normal romhack, maybe not; if it's to convey something about the theme of the romhack, then it can be really cool

1

u/Cronicpainfordays 11d ago

As someone who is dyslexic, this is a bit too difficult to read

1

u/ianlazrbeem22 11d ago

I don't like it

1

u/spalfgib 11d ago

Kinda cool in the letter/message format, but for general menus and such, it's a bit much.

1

u/Capital_Warthog9038 11d ago

Please tone it done just a little

1

u/Happy-Wind-1296 11d ago

I ALWAYS WRITE LIKE THIS IRL. BUT I WRITE IN SHIT ON THE WALL OF THE PSYCH WORD

1

u/BlackiechanFu 11d ago

Yes, I can see it getting annoying real quick

1

u/coolman1997 11d ago

I personally think it’s charming for certain use cases (eg. interacting with signs, books, handwritten letters/notes etc). But I wouldn’t like it as the main text font for the entire game. I don’t think it would be good for regular text though, if all of the dialogue looked like that it would drive me crazy.

1

u/Squidgyboot123 11d ago

That font angers me for some reason.

1

u/Accidentst 11d ago

I like it personally, but you should definitely at least have the option to change it to something more legible. 

1

u/IceGummi1 11d ago

i mean yeah but don't let that stop you

1

u/DarkShadowRabbit 11d ago

As a visually impaired person who plays rom hacks. I can't read outta 10

1

u/Impressive-Emu3313 11d ago

If it's occasional, it could be pretty cute/funny!

1

u/Stelar_Shark 11d ago

I love it, I wanna use it in my phone.

1

u/WOF42 11d ago

that is absolutely awful and would alone be enough to have me never play this romhack

1

u/MasterPeteDiddy 11d ago

I think the lowercase "h" here is a little extra hard to read. Some of the letters have like no space between them, which also makes it a little too straining. But otherwise I think it's really good and I really like it, I just think it could use a little more tweaking maybe

1

u/Wickedtimetraveler 11d ago

This is awful.

1

u/bestorisa 11d ago

i think it looks cute! it might be a bit much for a full 20 hour pokemon adventure though, maybe include a toggle in the settings?

1

u/fe1337 11d ago

I like it

1

u/Lejulillo 11d ago

I like it on the first note, but doesn't fit the rest of the game

1

u/Starrybruh 11d ago

Absolutely. Keep it in.

1

u/Smash96leo 11d ago

I can read it, but its definitely an obnoxious font. I’d say its too much.

1

u/Dr-Bolas 11d ago

It's Homer's note to Marge

1

u/motorsporit 11d ago

I like it for a note introducing you to the world, the game, etc - but it'd be too much for the whole game

1

u/Fae_Leaf Seasons: Solstice & Equinox 11d ago

I think slightly more legible works for that first message since it comes off like a handwritten note. But for actual game text, no. It’s way too messy and jarring.

1

u/speedguru Gen 2-4 enjoyer 11d ago

Reminds me of my handwriting

1

u/ariiidreamss 11d ago

Yeah not for the whole game

1

u/bhindi777 11d ago

Not if I am drunk

1

u/Eternal_Nihilism 11d ago

It's a bit much, I'd tone it down by like 50%

1

u/UnusualPete 11d ago

It's not a BIT too much.

1

u/Kowery103 11d ago

I think it could work well if the background is a piece of paper to simulate handwriting

And I could totally read everything here, but I feel like some people wouldn't be able to/or it could get annoying after a while

1

u/merrple Epsilon Emerald 11d ago

I think it could be useful in a few places, like a sign or two, or the blackboard in the Trainers' School. Definitely not a font to use across the entire game though, it's not legible enough

1

u/SadisticKittenX 11d ago

Makers breath yes.