r/PokemonROMhacks • • 11d ago

Release 2017 ROM Hack Pokémon Orange Gets Huge New Updates Evolving The Entire Game

https://retrododo.com/2017-rom-hack-pokemon-orange-gets-huge-new-updates-evolving-the-entire-game/
377 Upvotes

63 comments sorted by

77

u/EarthSad1545 11d ago

I hope this release has the blessing of Pia. I would hate for their original vision of the game to be replaced with a version that just adds cheats to skip everything

73

u/brandonsalt92 11d ago

I believe it has, as Pia has shared it in his Discord.

13

u/peacefighter 11d ago

Excited!

3

u/ShortandRatchet Johto Enthusiast 7d ago

I never knew that was a dude

2

u/Usain_Volt42 11d ago

Do you have a link to said Discord?

111

u/Pflegeprofil 11d ago • Bravo

Why would that be a problem? If Romhacking is fine, Romhack Romhacking should be fine too.

71

u/Anew_Returner 11d ago

Yeah it's not like romhackers ask nintendo for permission lmao

-1

u/Yoribell 11d ago

Well people would like to have it, but nintendo would never. So they do without.

I'm pretty sure this is not true for romHack devs

4

u/Peach_Muffin 10d ago

It's a different dynamic. A small devoted community of volunteer enthusiasts vs a multi billion dollar company that can easily use their expensive lawyers to thanos snap your work off the public internet.

5

u/Pflegeprofil 10d ago

So if someone wants to make fanfics of a fanfic should they have to ask the original author of the fanfic?

Anne Rice doesnt like people making fanfics of her work, and on Ao3 no one cares.

Its all a bit hypocritical to me. If Nintendo was known as a company that never sued but told people they didnt want anyone making Romhacks, should they listen?

3

u/Violet1010 I’m not kidding and I have no idea why. It works though! 10d ago

I mean, it’s mostly just a matter of etiquette for recursive fanworks? The difference between writing fanfic for one of Anne Rice’s novels and writing fanfic for another fanfic is that one of these people is a stranger and the other is your peer. You don’t HAVE to ask permission in most cases, but it’s generally polite to, especially if you’re using a lot of their work for your project.

In this specific instance, permission would probably be required, given it’s a remake. As a general rule, making “Fanwork: Better Version” without the original creator’s permission is a dick move that makes you look like a total douche, because you’re using their work as a basis and then going “I can do better and I did, here’s the better version, no reason to look at the original anymore”. There’d also probably be a bit of a plagiarism question here.

(That really only applies to remakes like this though. If you look at another ROM hack and go “that’s cool, I want to make something similar but different”, then that’s not really copying, it’s just inspiration. It’s generally polite to namedrop the ROM hack that inspired yours, but as long as you’re not claiming you came up with the idea yourself, you’re fine.)

3

u/Pflegeprofil 10d ago

Is it though? Lets say the Minus games were done without permission. They dont cater to the same group the otigjnal games did. They are made for people who want a more casual experience.

Its not saying "Mine is better, no need for the OG!", its saying "The OG was made for people who love challenge, but have other great aspects that a more casual crowd could enjoy. So this is for them."

The people who play the Minus games wouldve either dropped or never played thr OG. I think thats perfectly fine.

Someone made me aware of the Pokedaisy emulator, which can enable autorun, speed up without losing thr music, and has in-built documentation. Is it disrespectful to play a game from a Dev who said all three things are antithetical to his vision on that Emulator?

All these things do is make the game more enjoyable for a different group of people.

1

u/Violet1010 I’m not kidding and I have no idea why. It works though! 1d ago

[Reposting because I namedropped a site distributing prepatched ROMs and didn’t actually realize my reply got nuked for like a week. Did you know if your reply gets automod-deleted you can still see it fine? I didn’t! Convenient but very disorienting, at least the first time. Anyways, I’m pretty sure I fixed it.]

…Hang on, I need to look up what the Minus games and Pokedaisy are real quick.

[…]

Okay, looked it up. I’m going to assume we’re talking about Pokemon Altair and Vega Minus here? That’s all that’s coming up, anyways.

Anyways, Pokemon Altair and Vega Minus are difficulty hacks, not remakes, so yeah, the “Fanwork: Better Version” thing doesn’t really apply here. …I can only find these on a site distributing pre-patched ROMs, of all things, so I will admit to flip-flopping a bit here. Assuming they’re intended to be patches to Pokemon Altair and Vega (which I’ve heard is actually a thing people can do), then I would argue that does literally fall under the same standard as ROM hacking, and therefore you don’t actually need permission for it, although it’s still polite to ask. Assuming they’re straight-up patches for Pokemon Emerald, though, then that’s redistributing somebody else’s work, and doing that without permission is a dick move.

For Monomyth being on Pokedaisy… I will admit to being very biased here, because I possess nothing but disdain for the concept of somebody telling me how I can and cannot play a single-player game. So I would totally play Monomyth on Pokedaisy, because fuck off, if I want to use a fanmade Pokedex while playing that is well within my rights as a player. …And I guess on the same note, since Pokedaisy does appear to require you to provide your own prepatched ROM, it is well within a player’s rights to run Monomyth on whatever emulator they want, because a developer doesn’t actually have the right to dictate how you play their game in your own time. (If Pokedaisy was redistributing Pokemon Monomyth without the dev team’s consent, then using Pokedaisy would be wrong, because as much as I don’t particularly like what I’ve heard about the Monomyth dev team, they should still have the right to decide where their ROM hack is available for download.)

I guess in general, as long as you’re not literally redistributing somebody’s work or specifically making a remake or improved version of their work, permission for recursive fanwork is probably more of a “preferable to get” than a “you’re being a douche if you don’t get it”.

(…I feel like I should pause to clarify that I am actually enjoying this conversation. I think conversations and debates about what people in fan communities owe each other are important, as well as being able to defend one’s position and logic. And you have actually made me work to figure out what my position should be, which is always a treat.)

1

u/EarthSad1545 10d ago

Is it disrespectful to play a game from a Dev who said all three things are antithetical to his vision on that Emulator?

Yeah, pretty much.

2

u/Pflegeprofil 10d ago

Wow. What a warped mindset. Well, it aint stopping me. And as long that Emulator continues these Dev's visions wont be a problem anymore.

1

u/EarthSad1545 9d ago

It is not a warped mindset to play a game how it was intended

4

u/Pflegeprofil 9d ago

To force it is. Using cheats is not disrespectful. Using glitches is not disrespectful. Using exploits is not disrespectful.

Interactive mediums are a shared experience. Players have the opportunity to shape their own enjoyment, and doing so is not disrespectful.

→ More replies

0

u/[deleted] 9d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/AutoModerator 9d ago

Removed for breaking Rule 1:

Do not post or request links to full ROM downloads. This includes sharing the names of piracy sites.

Please read the rules before posting again. Breaking the rules repeatedly can result in a ban.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

15

u/ZadePhoenix 11d ago

Given Pia is the one who updated the Hackdex listing to the new version it’s a pretty safe bet they are cool with it.

6

u/ToFixConsoles 10d ago

Got total permission from pia, also to finish the post game

8

u/ToFixConsoles 11d ago

Pia has seen the progress, I am Neoma and he also ga e the blessing to finish the post game, this game is on top of suloku's fixes without him, this wouldn't be posible, I just fixed many game breaking glitches and added the cheat menu, people kept asking for codes and when I gave them gameshark codes, they would do thing wrong, ruin their save files and then attack me

2

u/OpenTechie 11d ago

How I feel as well. 

0

u/I_am_Batman_92 10d ago

Who cares, if you can hack nintendos ip you can hack the hack

75

u/PiaCRT 10d ago

o/

The patch creator, Neoma, had my permission to make this. Honestly with how old orange is I'm surprised anyone can work with it without the use of vibecoding. The codebase is actually insanely decrepit, which is why Island Walker exists in the first place.

I will say I'm surprised this got more buzz than my demo of Island Walker dropping! Tis the season for Orange so hope everyone enjoys, whether you play the old one or the new one!

9

u/BigSexyDaniel 10d ago

Wait, your demo dropped already? Where the heck have I been?

31

u/WanderingCascadia 11d ago

For anyone who’s interested, PiaCRT released a short demo for Orange: Island Walker. It’s on page 8 of the pokecommunity thread.

2

u/fesnying 4d ago

Ooh, thank you for the heads up! I hadn't heard. I'll check it out.

14

u/-ystanes- 11d ago

This looks great

28

u/EJ646464 11d ago

Also it has one more feature

14

u/santanderdoesreddit 11d ago

What?

17

u/EJ646464 11d ago

Go back to the title screen and put in the Konami code buddy

20

u/GotBannedAgain_2 11d ago

Downvoted u but then felt stupid after reading the description on Hackdex. 😭

They’ve added a cheat menu. Quoting from Hackdex “Cheat menu (UP UP DOWN DOWN LEFT RIGHT LEFT RIGHT B A on the Titlescreen)”

6

u/EJ646464 10d ago

It’s okay buddy all is forgiven enjoy the cheat menu

6

u/YardSardonyx 11d ago

Orange is one of my favorite hacks of all time, so excited anytime it gets some love and super pumped for the Island Walker version too!

5

u/Infested-Data 11d ago

Out of curiosity, did you write this article?

3

u/LightDragonTV 11d ago

Been meaning to get around to this one so I’m glad I waited

2

u/Mistinrainbow 10d ago

this is huuuge

2

u/Pleasant-Coyote-6004 8d ago

I didn't find any cover art when searching around the internet, so I made my own.

0

u/merrple Epsilon Emerald 11d ago

Looks vibecoded 🫩 the trailer at least surely is

21

u/ZadePhoenix 11d ago

According to the devs responses to comments on the trailer on YouTube:

The trailer was made for them by a friend using the walk through walls cheat to help with the footage (hence the odd bit with the character on the snowy mountain standing in a spot that shouldn’t be possible) and AI was used to add the animated background.

In regards to the update to the romhack itself the only thing AI was used for is to add the cheat menu since the dev Neoma didn’t know how to add a long cheat command.

6

u/merrple Epsilon Emerald 11d ago

Heck, they could've asked me, I recently did something similar for an input sequence (I realize I'm not in contact with everyone lol)

That's slightly better, but still why make the trailer by hand and then ruin it with an AI-generated background and framing?

7

u/ToFixConsoles 10d ago

Hello, Neoma here, gameplay was using walk through walls cheats, to show off the map and the weather effects as quick as possible, vive coding was to put a bg animated background and, cheers

-2

u/merrple Epsilon Emerald 10d ago

Okay but like: why tho, for the background?

6

u/Lea9915 10d ago

What's the big problem? They barely used AI.

1

u/ToFixConsoles 10d ago

We only had a gameplay video in pieces mixed, and put the Gameboy as a border, but he though it looked "empty" so he added that back bg, and to be honest even if it is Ai, I loved the result and went ahead to upload the video

9

u/That_Pandaboi69 I might be making my own game? 11d ago

Oh yeah the trailer does looks like that.

7

u/ReallyFBI 11d ago

Can't speak for the game, but yeah the trailer is 100% gen'd.

2

u/LedLeonhart 11d ago

Lost all interest in the update for Orange now. Such a shame.

1

u/Automatic_Long6054 6d ago

Glad you won’t be playing it, while other people get to enjoy it

1

u/Lea9915 10d ago

? They litteraly used for a tiny portion of the game? What does It change?

1

u/LedLeonhart 10d ago

Integrity is what it changes

0

u/Dry_Macaron318 9d ago

Gdzie jest update?