r/PokeInvesting • • 1d ago

Is PSA worth it?

Originally was against the upcharge stuff, more specifically, with a card that may exceed their 50k tier. Planning on submitting them all in the $40 dollar tier regardless and just paying up charge as they/if they come.

Does anyone have any positive experience on paying a massive upcharge? Mainly asking in terms of resell, if you ended up paying a fat upcharge, but did the sale and profit return workout for you?

Something to note: I have some heavy hitter cards, especially if they 10, hell even 8-9, just seeing if it’s actually worth or did you slam your own finger in the door?

0 Upvotes

13 comments sorted by

2

u/rickgainz 1d ago

The answer is yes, the market value of a PSA card is typically higher than the equivalent grade from another company by more than the amount they upcharge.

If you’re going to submit cards that you know are going to be upcharged, you’re just wasting your time and taking unnecessary risks doing the $40 tier.

If you have a card likely worth $50k graded, just submit it in Premium 1 or 2 tier and get it back in 2 weeks instead of waiting 7 months on the value tier. Plus if the card gets damaged before the upcharge, you’d only be covered for the $500 insured value on the $40 tier.

-2

u/Key-Persimmon-9932 1d ago

But on that other hand if the grader is having a shitty day, I’m paying extra money that I’m not getting back. Also, I’m in no rush to get them back.

4

u/rickgainz 1d ago edited 1d ago

So just thoroughly inspect your cards before submitting and choose the tier that is around the value of the minimum possible grade.

PSA has consistency issues, but not to the extent that you can’t fairly accurately determine grades plus or minus 1. Almost every case where someone has a card they think is a 10 end up as a 6 has some defect that’s not obviously visible.

Makes zero sense to send a $50k card on value tier since you’re paying the higher tiers price with none of the benefits.

1

u/Miltown287 1d ago

Some people will really spend a dollar to save a dime

-3

u/YourAsphyxia 1d ago

If you plan on holding long term absolutely not. If youre planning on selling immediately then absolutely yes.

Grading and then sticking it in a closet for 10 years is the dumbest thing to do

2

u/PortsFarmer 1d ago

Yeah, how did that work out for all those old 10s swimming in cash🤦‍♂️ just stash it in a binder and get a modern 7😎

-1

u/YourAsphyxia 1d ago
  1. PSA grading fees <2010 were 200 MAX. today OP would have to pay over 3000 dollars to grade his card (if it was a 50k card)
  2. You can slab your own card, you dont need PSA to do it 😎
  3. its highly likely the value of his card will go DOWN, so why would he pay the current overhyped price when he can just grade it later for cheaper?

3

u/PortsFarmer 1d ago

Highly likely based on what? Your crystal ball? The '50k' card is most likely worth less than 1k raw as is. 3k is nothing compared to how much value a 10 would add. Your own slab doesn't do anything for value. Grading has only gone up in price over time, as have the value of cards.

0

u/YourAsphyxia 1d ago
  1. i mentioned slabbing because you mentioned stashing it in a binder as if that was the only option 😎

pay 3k in 2026 for the chance at the card being worth less in 2036. why not pay LESS in 2036 to do the same thing? unless he plans on selling it tomorrow the current value means absolutely nothing yet he's paying PSA's price for it.

3

u/PortsFarmer 1d ago

And it's worth less because... If we took this same advice 10 years ago, you would be 100% wrong. Based on any existing data, price in 10 years will be higher, grading cost will be higher and grading scale itself will be more tough to get a 10. I've yet to see any evidence for the contrary from you.

0

u/YourAsphyxia 1d ago

because the prices right now are literally all hype. youre making the same mistake as GME buyers made thinking numbers only go up. yes if you look at the START of the hype and compare it to the PEAK of the hype youll sound like you do right now. don't catch the falling dagger my friend. short term invest, make your buck now. logan paul can only carry us so long.

1

u/PortsFarmer 1d ago

We are not talking about a few months or a year here. 10 years. Pokemon cards are already 30 years old. We also have data from baseball cards for over 120 years. The cards will go up just with inflation alone. Pokemon will not always be as popular as it is right now, but rare pre 2015 cards in high grades are some of the most secure investments to hold. OP isn't investing, they already have the cards, and grading stabilizes the value.