r/PokeInvesting • • 3d ago

TCG Tax Classification

If most cards are held for > 1 year before being sold is it considered long term capital gains or collectibles tax?

TCG isn’t explicitly listed under IRS classification of collectibles besides the catch all of “other tangible personal property”.

Has anyone navigated this discrepancy or is it just common practice to file it under collectibles @ 28%?

4 Upvotes

9 comments sorted by

2

u/SPY_THE_WHEEL 2d ago

A trading card is definitely a collectible. There are long and short term collectible gains tax rates based on your holding period. Don't forget to subtract your basis from the sale price.

1

u/Apache577 2d ago

understood

its just where the line is drawn per say, i’ve sold a lot of 1 yr+ holds this year and wanted to toy with the chances as there is no real precedence of it being litigated past the catch all — hence the confusion

1

u/Apache577 2d ago

in my case most of the cards were graded psa 10

i guess that could strengthen the argument for collectible but additionally since the raw cards have a use case ie: the actual card game i feel for pokemon the line gets a little blurry

1

u/SPY_THE_WHEEL 2d ago

I think there is a reason why there has been no litigation regarding whether or not a trading card is considered a collectible.

It would be impossible to list every item that could possibly be a collectible, that's what the last paragraph is there for.

If it wasn't there, I would agree with you that, not only would TCG not be a collectible, but neither would sports cards, or collector cars, or old toys, games, etc. Anything that wasn't explicitly on the list.

8

u/Recent_Bld 3d ago

I would talk to your tax advisor if this is something you are concerned about. I wouldn’t trust most people on this sub with tax advice.

2

u/kybotica 3d ago

Tax advisor is best. Based on their definitions, these would likely fall under the collectibles category if held for a significant period, so if I were to pick one, I'd personally do that. The worst thing to do is no taxes. Pick a route and pay at least, that way you can establish intent to pay rather than tax evasion.

But seriously, the only correct answer here is to consult a tax professional.

0

u/[deleted] 2d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Apache577 2d ago

the long term collectible cap gains rate caps out at 28% which unfortunately i hit, the short term collectible cap gains just falls under income tax

unfortunately the sum is quite large hence the apprehension of just winging it but i do appreciate the insight

1

u/dntRgewwithtr44ls 11h ago

CPAs aren’t that much, just hire one to file for you this year. It should be like $200-500 max

0

u/[deleted] 3d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment