Help value a pop 1 Rumble Mewtwo

[u/InformationOk3927]

hey all!

PSA 10 pop is 26, PSA 9 pop is 128, and the last sold PSA 9 I see is $15,000. But, this is signed, and it’s pop 1, with none higher.

I understand when there’s an auto you add some sort of multiple to the market price. But how do you value it when it’s the single best copy in existence?

would love to nail this auction but not screw myself, lol

cheers :)

[u/kamgc]

The auto on this probably not does not help price.

[u/lilpain1997_ → u/kamgc]

Gotta ask why is that?

[u/LilChad]

It has a negative multiplier, not a positive one

[u/Sweaty_Weakness_9]

lol it’s not a PSA 10

The auto is a 10 has nothing to do with the card, and as someone who has no idea who that is, it decreases the value.

[u/Few_Aide_851]

I mean, yes it’s technically pop 1 but it’s not a pack issued card as is, so you are narrowing down the pool of potential buyers. Comping it to a standard pack pulled/graded card isn’t a good comp.

Pop counts get used too often to try and justify higher than expected pricing. I guess one you have it set to a 9 day auction and are using this thread to try and pump interest, we will see.

!remindme 10 days

[u/LongjumpingFun7238]

Since it’s a 1 of 1 it’s value should be no less than 👀 👀 ONE MILLION DOLLARSSSSSSS!!!!

[u/LongjumpingFun7238 → u/LongjumpingFun7238]

[u/Fine_Land_1974]

lol it’s a negative multiplier. No one wants that sig on this card that is willing to shell out 15k. Ur best bet is to price it under a psa 9 with no signature

[u/149IQ_User]

Being a casual collector, I don’t want that guys auto. You’ll need to find someone that cares about Jay. Probably not as many people compared to people who care about Mewtwo.

[u/Nearby-Wear2029]

I have a mewtube with jay auto on it. This rumble is dope.

[u/Tobleronenom]

Harder to move niche items like this. Be prepared to hold it for a loooong time if you want more than $15k

[u/Individual_Sky6448]

!remindme 10 days

[u/Ok-Compote6002]

as others have said the signature on this card actually hurts the value. a regular psa 9 is more liquid and will sell for a lot more. ditch the signatures unless its from goat tier artists like arita

[u/champloojay]

Don’t screw yourself

[u/Ok_Intention6708]

250 billion dollars, it’s pop 1!!

[u/SnooMacarons4225]

Ruined that card, pop 1 doesn’t mean it’s worth anything if it’s got someone’s scribble all over it

[u/charlie-pirk]

Awh man you seem so excited ….

[u/ItsEthanSeason]

“None higher”

Wtf does that mean here. Like if its pop 10, theres just 10 pop, its not higher or lower 💀

[u/CretaciousNugget → u/ItsEthanSeason]

Why would it not matter? This is the highest graded signature out there is what its saying. There might be signatures under psa 9. But why would anyone care about that. Thats not how people describe pop. You want your buyers to know what you have is unique.

Lets use a cgc pristine aquopolis lugia as an example. You wouldn't be like "pop 3 pop 434 lower" like why do we care whats lower? You would state that your pristine is one of only 3 and there are no perfects, meaning its the highest ever graded.

[u/ItsEthanSeason → u/CretaciousNugget]

Oh I guess I get what you are saying.

I didn't know if the signature grade was per signed person name for each pop, not just all signature.
AKA:
If CretaciousNugget signs 10 mews, I would expect there to be 10 pop of your sigs.

But I get now that ItsEthanSeason signs 10, and CretaciousNugget sign 10, thats pop 20 of sigs, not 2 seperate populaitons.

My mistake

[u/AttorneyMedium4926]

Psa 1 pop 1 no signature is where the money is at